5 ms·
As the article points out, the practice is nothing new, it's about the scale that Amazon does it at. And that's basically the point for everything Amazon does.
by AndrewKemendo 8y ago
As the article points out, the practice is nothing new, it's about the scale that Amazon does it at.
And that's basically the point for everything Amazon does. They aren't doing anything other companies don't, it's just they do it on a massive scale.
With "store brand" specifically, the idea is that Equate or other store brands were well known to be comparable, if slightly less good versions of name brands. In economics terms they were "substitute goods" from brand names, but depending on quality they may not be "perfect substitutes."
In the case of Amazon, if they have brands that are at first glance not Amazon brands, but actually are amazon brands, then they are kind of doing an end run around what was an implicit agreement between consumers and retailers. Namely that a retailer will make it explicitly clear, with obvious branding, what is a "store brand" and what is not. Simply stating "our brands" isn't obvious enough to make that connection if you are only spending 30 seconds on a product description page.
This is something that Amazon is great at actually.
- dixie_land 8y ago> Namely that a retailer will make it explicitly clear, with obvious branding, what is a "store brand" and what is not. how are brandings such as Kirkland Signature(Costco), Simple Truth(Kroger) or 365(Wholefoods) any more obvious than what Amazon is doing with "our brands"?
- jld 8y agoThe fact that those brands are used storewide make them more identifiable as store brands. You can buy simple truth milk, chicken, soup, and diapers at Kroger stores. Amazon has multiple distinct brands per category, which makes keeping track much harder.
- jahewson 8y agoSo it’s like cars, beer, candy bars, clothing stores, etc.
- thenanyu 8y agoKroger: https://www.kroger.com/b/ourbrands https://www.kroger.com/b/ourbrands Macys: https://www.macysinc.com/macys/private-brands/default.aspx https://www.macysinc.com/macys/private-brands/default.aspx Many of those brands are not obviously private label. Whole Foods and Costco are the exception in that they have only 1 store brand that everything is labeled under. This is probably because they are high-value brands unto themselves and it's advantageous to put their own stamp on it.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- AndrewKemendo 8y agoI'm not sure how it's unclear. The comparable to Signature/Truth/365 would be Amazon Basics. The branding is consistent and minimal. As the article points out, Amazon has dozens of other house brands that are not associated with Amazon. Amazon's argument would be that they are perfect substitutes, so branding them consistently with Amazon Basics would make people think they are lesser quality. So they just give them a new house brand. Target is doing the same thing by the way [1] but they just don't have the massive scale. [1] https://corporate.target.com/article/tag/385/owned-brands https://corporate.target.com/article/tag/385/owned-brands
- dawnerd 8y agoMost of targets stuff is trash too. Stopped shopping there when the men’s section just turned into poor fitting in house brands.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- Shivetya 8y agoFor the most part grocery store brands don't tend to mention that they are store brands. people figure them out with information found online but its a crap shoot if there is any labeling that the item you are looking at is a store brand. You have to separate out generic brands as well, like the bagged but not boxed cereals that are not the store brand at all but people think they are because of packaging. some cross boundaries as I have found Kirkland brands outside of Costco. if anything Amazon at least is up front about it.
- GuB-42 8y agoIt is not more obvious in absolute terms but it is easier to spot in big retail stores. The biggest clue is usually that it is the only brand that isn't a big name, and yet, there is plenty of it. On Amazon, there is a huge variety of lesser known brands, so you can't assume that just because you didn't hear about it, it must be the store brand. The pricing is another clue. Store brands usually have a well defined spot, with no competition in that spot. Typically between the no-name stuff and the name brand. Amazon has a lot of brands in every price range. I am of course assuming that it is not obvious. If a brand bear the name of the shop, or is used for every product category in the shop, it is obvious.
- kakarot 8y agoHow is this any different from the scale of the likes of Johnson & Johnson? Most people don't read the fine print on the back of their packaged home goods.
- AndrewKemendo 8y agoWell it's bigger for one, but J&J has been constantly sued for anti-trust. The question is, should people need to read the fine print to know what they are getting? Said another way, what level of generalized a-priori knowledge is reasonable for a consumer to have in order to know what additional information the manufacturer/retailer needs to provide for the consumer to make an informed decision?
- OJFord 8y agoJ&J is a conglomerate brand, but only that. Amazon is increasingly not only the place where you buy everything, but also the conglomerate that owns everything you buy.
- ams6110 8y agoHarbor Freight does this, and they even try to associate with real brands. For example their house brand air tools are "Central Pneumatic," obviously similar to the much higher quality brand "Chicago Pneumatic." HF also call their house brand welders "Chicago Electric." A casual shopper might think they had simply misremembered which brand used the term "Chicago," and think they are buying a better quality air tool than they're really getting.
- gscott 8y agoWhen shopping at harbor freight just buy two... one for immediate use and the other for when the first breaks.
- dawnerd 8y agoIt’s actually a good test to see if you’ll actually need a tool for long. If it works for the one job and you never touch it again, lots saved. If you use it a lot buy the better brand when it dies.
- amyjess 8y agoReminds me of how house-brand medications at CVS mimic the color schemes and design layouts of their competitors.