3 ms·
Security by obscurity obviously shouldn't be your only method, but it can absolutely be a valid component of a broad defense in depth.
by monocasa 8y ago
Security by obscurity obviously shouldn't be your only method, but it can absolutely be a valid component of a broad defense in depth.
- fromthestart 8y agoI don't know if I agree. While obscurity can be a deterrent, I imagine most groups are unlikely to come up with sufficient, convoluted complexity to prevent identification of exploits. Primarily because you're effectively pitting yourself against a collective of $hat hackers, instead of doing things "right" and attempting to use encryption. This doesn't mean it isn't a deterrent, but doing things in an obfuscated and unusual way also means you're potentially treading on unexplored ground, and so there will potentially be other exploits, bugs, innefficiencies which can come with the territory.
- monocasa 8y agoThis isn't an "instead of doing things 'right'". Like I said, it's only valid as one component of a broader strategy. You might have a point if someone had ever made a perfect scheme, but everything that seems to have attracted attention has been broken AFAICT. So, a moat around a castle does help. Calling it good after digging a moat and not building any walls is probably less useful than doing nothing. The moat is only useful in the broader context.
- lostapathy 8y agoConversely, sometimes the obscurity layer will obscure the issues not just from others, but also yourself. I worked for a thin client vendor years ago that was obsessed with encrypting our boot image etc, and poured all our resources into that. Which lead to encryption that was still trivial to work around, and a lot of other real security issues were never dealt with because we were fixated on the ineffective obscurity layer.
- monocasa 8y agoThat just sounds like misplaced priorities than the obfuscation layer getting in the way.
- lostapathy 8y agoAbsolutely. The obsession with that obfuscated our priorities, 100%. It also made our images more insecure, because it added no real security, while making it harder to improve security where it mattered.
- codedokode 8y agoDefence from whom? From system administrator?
- monocasa 8y agoME is (among other things) supposed to be the secure enclave for SGX keys, which Intel is hoping will allow encrypted computation on cloud computing clusters that are protected from inspection by the system admins. So, without even getting into the whole DRM argument, yes?
- squarefoot 8y agoAnd lawyers probably.
- wolfgke 8y ago> Defence from whom? From system administrator? From the user, since SGX is also used/intended for DRM purposes.