3 ms·
If you wanted to apply an interpretation that was extremely generous to the confederate states (for the sake of understanding people who say such things) you co
by michaelt 8y ago
If you wanted to apply an interpretation that was extremely generous to the confederate states (for the sake of understanding people who say such things) you could make a comparison to the EU.
The EU has 'union' right there in its name, but it isn't a single country and there are a bunch of things it doesn't try to homogenise. Every time the EU broadens its control over member countries, there are mutterings about sovereignty until one day, something like Brexit happens.
No brit says "Britain should leave the EU because they want to ban our high power kettles" they say "Britain should leave the EU because of its ever-expanding infringement on our sovereignty; an illustrative example of this is the proposed ban on high power kettles"
The "states' rights" claim is the same: that it was about the ever-expanding powers of the federal government, and slavery was just an illustrative example of such an expansion.
Of course, as albntomat0 points out the Mississippi declaration of secession supports slavery in the second sentence, so what I just said has a big dose of historical revisionism.
- rsynnott 8y ago> No brit says "Britain should leave the EU because they want to ban our high power kettles" I mean, that sort of (usually untrue; your example has never even been considered by the EU and would make no sense) trivia was a HUGE part of the leave campaign.
- kodablah 8y agoAs with modern elections and surely the civil war, people tend to over-value publicly visible campaigning (and the subjects thereof) as reasons for outcomes they don't understand. Since justifications can't easily be quantified, assumptions based on the most visible rhetoric tend to get made.
- michaelt 8y agoyour example has never even been considered by the EU [...] trivia was a HUGE part of the leave campaign. My post didn't say I was for or against Brexit; rather, I described a possible mindset of someone who was pro-Brexit, to illuminate my proud-soverignty-of-states-within-larger-unions analogy. I'm glad to hear you found my illustration of a Brexiter's rationale plausible!