8 ms·
Living in a country where pretty much _everything_ has been built out of brick/stone/concrete for a long while now (with clay shingles), I find US building code
by rcarmo 8y ago
Living in a country where pretty much _everything_ has been built out of brick/stone/concrete for a long while now (with clay shingles), I find US building codes to be baffling.
Not criticizing, mind you, since clay shingles are still supported by wooden beams in older detached homes and those go out too in forest fires (which we also have, on a yearly basis and with tragic results) - I just don’t get the rationale for small homes to be built out of wood these days - is it cost?
(Edit for typos)
- noir_lord 8y agoPartially and historically the US has had a lot of wood, the UK deforested early (we built a lot of ships and wooden structures) so we had to go to brick and slate quite early (also our climate is hell on wood without modern treatment). Also the US climate is far more varied than the UK's so in some biomes wood makes sense.
- kitten_mittens_ 8y agoA lot of the interior West and SoCal where fires are the most intense is unforested. A good deal of the lumber used to build is shipped in from elsewhere. My home state of Idaho (the south) is largely cheatgrass, tumbleweeds, and sagebrush. None of which are useful for construction. All extremely flammable most of the year.
- hollerith 8y agoThe West Coast of the US is prone to earthquakes, and wooden structures survive earthquakes much better than brick structures do. (They're also quite a bit cheaper.)
- rsync 8y agoWood framed buildings are much, much safer in earthquakes and with plywood shear walls can be considered the very safest construction method. Aesthetically, I dislike it because I have a taste for very solid, permanent things, but if you live in California, stud-wall ("stick built") construction with plywood shear walls over them is really the only choice.
- erikpukinskis 8y agoA wood house can be permanent if you get the moisture management system correct.
- chrisseaton 8y agoAmericans don't believe me when I tell them my relatively recent regular UK house is built out of brick! They say things like 'it's a wooden frame with a brick facade, right?' or 'I'm sure the supporting structure isn't brick.' No it's brick. It's all brick. The walls on all sides in every room are about 30cm of solid brick with plaster directly on top. Even the internal ones. If you want to run a new light cable or something you'll be using a hammer and chisel to make a channel to put it in.
- 0xffff2 8y agoI don't think you could do this in California due to earthquake-related parts of the building code.
- erikpukinskis 8y agoYeah, a brick house becomes a sandcastle in an earthquake.
- luckydata 8y agoWe had the technology to build earthquake-proof houses for quite a while without needing to use timber framing which has all kinds of downsides. http://dme.engin.umich.edu/stubbornstructures/ http://dme.engin.umich.edu/stubbornstructures/ The only advantage is cost and speed of execution, they call them McMansions for a reason.
- defterGoose 8y agoNot sure where you're from, but cheap lumber, bro. California has lots of forests, and therefore timber framing is comparatively cheaper here.
- stevenwoo 8y agoMost (all?) California residential including apartments are wood framed for earthquake survivability of the residents. https://www.nytimes.com/1999/01/31/weekinreview/the-world-one-defense-against-quakes-build-homes-of-wood.html https://www.nytimes.com/1999/01/31/weekinreview/the-world-on...
- imhoguy 8y agoReinforced concrete frames are also earthquake resistant and fireproof, e.g. popular in Greece. Search "Eurocode 8" for reference.