4 ms·
One way to divide people on mathematics is to separate those who see it as a technology (have problem -> apply mathematics -> problem is solved) from those who
by roenxi 8y ago
One way to divide people on mathematics is to separate those who see it as a technology (have problem -> apply mathematics -> problem is solved) from those who see it as a way of interpreting the world (eg, the stock market /is/ a set of correlated random variables, adding things to a heap /is/ addition, geometry /is/ how the world fits together).
Usually there isn't a huge amount of difference between these competing philosophies, but it really rears its head in probability and statistics where a huge amount of damage is done, eg, p-value-hacking by people who think statistics is a technology rather than a perspective.
- llamaz 8y agoThere is a divide between pure and applied math, one that arguable should be bridged, but the divide you talk about /within/ applied math seems artificial: Either you learn math properly, at least with regard to depth as opposed to breadth, or you shouldn't be working with it in the first place. Within electrical engineering the design process is 1. pen/paper + math 2. simulation 3. building/testing. You learn quickly that jumping straight to 3, or even 2, is a /bad/ idea. This is because in order to isolate where the problem lies, you need to know what is expected. A similar process is used within any engineering discipline. There is a such a thing as software engineering, where in the interest of safety the software system is documented completely. But in the vast majority of case, I hold the outre opinion that programming cannot in good conscience be considered engineering. In conclusion: If you are working in engineering or applying math, you should learn math properly, and shouldn't treat it as a black box.
- globuous 8y agoThe otherday, I realized that slugging a string is a projection ! It's a surjective map with a reduction of dimensions (aka I give you a slug and in nearly all cases you won't be able to find the original string), and is idempotent, that is, the slug of a slug is itself. As is, this realization is completely useless since I don't really have any useful way to apply it, but it's a fun way of looking at slugs. And while we're at it, we can also see that there is a reduction of dimension in the process of hashing but that it is not a projection since the hash of a hash generally isn't itself. I'm almost sure about what I just said (I'm not a mathematician), but please correct me if I'm wrong !
- joppy 8y agoIt’s a good observation, and the slug(slug(x)) = slug(x) property means that if you have an x and you’re not sure it’s a slug, it’s always ok to slug it to be sure it is. This property can be really handy in building robust systems, where you might have to attempt a couple of times to complete an operation for sure.
- throwaway487548 8y ago> the stock market /is/ a set of correlated random variables No. this is neo-platonic bullshit. In this context is here must be a type-error. What could be imagined in not what really is - reality is one, interpretations are infinite. Stock Market is the result of human (and computer) actions - the result of actions of all institutional participants. This is what it is. A model could be created to be superimposed on these partially-observable stochastic processes (and, boy, there is no shortage of these, and no one is right, of course) but it will be only a model, usefulness and applicability of which depends upon who is using it and for what means (usually, bullshitting). Geometry is closer to "what is" because it abstracts out "concrete" patterns this universe is able to produce (and lots of imaginary bullshit, of course). Let me stress is a gain - maths are generalized and abstracted out patterns of what is, plus abstract sectarian bullshit. Reality comes first, (it is a closure) interpretations and abstractions are bound by it.
- throwawaymath 8y agoI'm having difficulty following what you're saying here. I think you're saying mathematical models are only an (imperfect) interpretetion of reality, which sounds fine. But then you're talking about "sectarian bullshit" and "neo-platonic bullshit". And at the same time, you called the stock market a "partially observable stochastic process" - why do you have an issue with calling something in reality a set of random variables, but you don't have an issue with calling it a stochastic process? Those are the same thing. Honestly it feels like you launched into a tirade over a perfectly innocent and fine choice of words. I don't think the commenter you responded to meant to push some kind of weird philosophical agenda.