4 ms·
> The only hope is to culturally adapt, as we did to other weird aspects of social media. This rings true. Call me a cynic, but algorithmic/ML efforts to comba
by livueta 8y ago
> The only hope is to culturally adapt, as we did to other weird aspects of social media.
This rings true. Call me a cynic, but algorithmic/ML efforts to combat disinfo are highly unlikely to meaningfully address the problem or do anything beyond acting as a fig-leaf for Facebook et al to wave around as evidence of how seriously they're taking it. General media literacy is the only thing that comes close to a solution.
I recently heard an interesting interview[1] regarding pre-Internet Russian disinfo; specifically, the "CIA invented AIDS" classic. Of particular interest is the bit about how disinfo is regarded in societies that have had more time to become acclimated to it:
> They've lived under Russian or Soviet rule for generations now. They're media literate. They're skeptical. They're critical thinkers. And they're used to this. It's old news to them. I lived in the Baltic states between 2001 and 2003. And I was always really impressed with the sort of healthy skepticism in those societies.
Anecdotally, most of the people I know who've grown up with the internet are much better at spotting attempts at manipulation than the proverbial aunt who keeps sharing "rapefugee" articles on Facebook. This makes some sense, though is obviously far from universal: if you grew up in an era where media was controlled, mainstream and generally trustworthy, odds are you'll be woefully unprepared for the free-for-all of today, where anybody can at least superficially resemble a "real" media org with fifteen minutes of CSS. In other words, the bullshit heuristics of a large chunk of the population are woefully out of date.
The optimistic view is that as disinformation and other forms of mass-manipulation (e.g. corporate) become even more normalized, the population will become inoculated to a degree.
The pessimistic view considers the history of advertisement and notes the fact that despite lifetimes of exposure, emotionally-manipulative ads are as effective today as they ever were. Media literacy is all very well to talk about, but if a disinfo campaign is well-crafted and short-circuits rationality to jump directly to emotion, it'll probably be quite effective.
---
[1] https://www.npr.org/2018/11/15/668209008/inside-the-russian-disinformation-playbook-exploit-tension-sow-chaos https://www.npr.org/2018/11/15/668209008/inside-the-russian-...