4 ms·
> Amazon is not going to be more productive in New York than in New Jersey That's a humongous assumption and one that I think simply isn't true. Not specifical
by tootie 8y ago
> Amazon is not going to be more productive in New York than in New Jersey
That's a humongous assumption and one that I think simply isn't true. Not specifically that New Jersey is a worse place to run a business, but in general he seems to be assuming that geography is complete non-issue. That's just obviously not true. There's a zillion businesses that have set roots in NYC or other industry hot spots and most of them received no specific incentives. I mean, why did they even conduct this search if everyplace is the same? They could have put their HQ2 in the Nevada desert and saved way more than their tax breaks were worth.
- jackconnor 8y agoYea I found this a very weird thing to say, as engineering talent was a huge reason for choosing New York, and is a resource that New jersey does not have in anywhere near the same abundance. I am curious where they would've chosen had subsidies actually been illegal, as this author says we should do. My guess is that they would've ended up in, you guessed it, New York and Virginia, regardless.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- Hypx 8y agoI find that very hard to believe given the close proximity of NJ to NY. In particular, Newark is literally just across the river from New York City.
- lowercased 8y agoOn top of that, how many people working in NYC actually commute in from NJ? Meaning... they're actually living in NJ in the first place.
- tarboreus 8y agoYou actually are wrong about this. No one here want to work in NJ. Few young people in the city keep cars. People would scratch their heads if you told them you were working out there. Might be just a psychological thing. but it's real. I wouldn't look for jobs in NJ unless they dropped into my lap.
- lowercased 8y agoi was responding to this idea to amazon located in NYC because that's where the engineers/workers are at. If there's actually more in NJ, locating there would have meant those jobs would have just dropped in your lap. But I don't have specific numbers on commuters from NJ, and suspect their decision was based on more than just staff availability.
- philwelch 8y agoWhere do you live and work? I live and work in Seattle, and although I wouldn't rule it out, I would prefer not to cross Lake Washington to work in Bellevue even though it's technically closer to me than certain parts of Seattle that I regularly visit. Boundaries and regional identities have sometimes irrational emotional impacts. Also, NJ is very close to NY by the standards of everywhere in America other than NY. Density and urbanization affect our perceptions of distance: a famous representation of this is "View of the World from 9th Avenue" (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/View_of_the_World_from_9th_Avenue https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/View_of_the_World_from_9th_Ave...)
- weliketocode 8y agoAre you an nyc local? There absolutely is a premium placed for companies based in nyc. Companies in Newark, Hoboken, etc all start at a major disadvantage competing for talent.
- lkrubner 8y agoAs an example, WalMart has put together a new lab that is meant to compete with Amazon. A talent agent called me up and said, "Hey, the team at WalMart is paying well, base salary of $210,000, cutting edge technology, are you interested?" I asked where is it? They said New Jersey. I was like, no way. I'm not leaving New York and going out there. The commute is terrible.
- tootie 8y agoCommute to Jersey City or Hoboken is really fast. PATH is faster and more reliable than the subway.
- berbec 8y agoIf everything works perfectly, sure. Then there are the constant days like yesterday where you might as well walk
- weliketocode 8y agoI'm not sure if you're trying to be sarcastic, but Jet is based in Hoboken, and, from first-hand knowledge, they do pay above market for software engineers in order to compete with companies based in nyc.
- lkrubner 8y agoNo sarcasm. When I've had to work projects in New Jersey its been an ordeal. If I can make $180,000 in New York versus $210,000 in New Jersey, then I'm going to stick with New York. I put a high value on being able to walk home after work. My clients are typically between 14th street and 59th street. I live on 98th street. I often walk home after work. Sometimes the walk is the only exercise I get. I would not want to give it up.
- screye 8y ago> geography is complete non-issue Newark is 0.5-1 hr away from Manhattan (both public transport and driving) Given that NJ was apparently offering more tax breaks and that housing is generally cheaper. I can see why NJ would have been a good option. Someone could easily stay in Jersey City/Hoboken, have a 30 minutes (in traffic) commute and get the NYC feel. Or, they could stay in Newark and rent a mansion at NYC rents. Amazon would still have access to talent going to Columbia, Cornell-tech and get extra access to Rutgers as well. IMO, best of both worlds.
- tootie 8y agoAudible, an Amazon subsidiary, is based in Newark. I'm guessing Bezos knows exactly how easy or hard it is to recruit there.
- jonathankoren 8y agoMaybe it’s because I don’t live in NYC, but there’s to be very little difference geographical benefit of crossing the East River, compared to crossing the Hudson. As far as conducting the search, I thought that was obvious. By holding a bogus competition, they managed to extract tax breaks from the places they were going to settle in anyway, through the bogus threat of settling someplace else. Come on, did anyone really think Columbus, Ohio[0] was in the running? The reason why Amazon didn’t put HQ2 in Las Vegas, is because the access to talent is not there, and Las Vegas has no comparative advantage like NYC (finance) and DC metro (legal). It’s sinply not worth it to either entice people from places that are perceived to be better (for whatever definition they choose), or to invest in training up the local population to take the jobs that are needed today. [0] https://www.forbes.com/sites/bisnow/2018/01/19/amazon-hq2-shortlist-details-on-the-20-finalists-in-5b-sweepstakes/ https://www.forbes.com/sites/bisnow/2018/01/19/amazon-hq2-sh...
- philwelch 8y agoThis is not only untrue, this is almost ridiculous enough to beggar belief. If geography has no impact on how productive a business is, why would any business operate in New York and San Francisco? They are incredibly expensive. If there's literally no difference in value, then businesses should choose based on cost, and you should never see hubs like San Francisco or New York where businesses tend to cluster together. You can only handwave about market irrationality and/or conspiracy theories so much, and even then, why would our wicked corporate overlords do something devious that pointlessly increased their expenses when all the other devious things they seem to do are in the service of ruthlessly decreasing their expenses? B&M retail did end up not being centered in NY anymore for cost reasons (Target is headquartered in Minneapolis and Wal-Mart is headquartered in Bentonville, Arkansas). So obviously it's a concern; it's just that managing the marginal cost of your headquarters real estate and headcount is a bigger deal for Wal-Mart than it is for Amazon, while recruiting the kind of talent that tends to cluster in NY and Seattle is a bigger deal for Amazon than it is for Wal-Mart.