4 ms·
Understanding mass in molar terms is necessary to do a lot of chemistry correctly. The mole is effectively a count of the number of molecules kicking about, alt
by jcranmer 8y ago
Understanding mass in molar terms is necessary to do a lot of chemistry correctly. The mole is effectively a count of the number of molecules kicking about, although the count is large enough that terms like "quadrillion" don't cut it. (One mole is about 600 sextillion molecules). Knowing how many molecules are around lets you actually compute how much stuff can react in a given chemical environment, and other aspects of chemistry end up being pretty related to molecule counts. Vanilla mass doesn't cut it since an atom of iodine weighs about 6.6 times that of fluorine but can still only react with one other molecule.
The flip side is that the molecular count is less useful to us in the everyday world. We can gauge the weight of a kilogram much more than we can gauge a septillion molecules. And if we're trying to figure out how much stuff a shelf can hold before it collapses, it's the weight that matters, not the actual molecular count. (Note for pedants: in the familiar environment of Earth's surface, mass and weight can be treated as the same quantity in most cases.)
So mass and molecular count are both very important quantities that have importance in different fields of science, and they don't have a trivial relationship to each other. Avogadro's constant and molar mass is a way to express their relationship.
- zwkrt 8y agotrying to use kg instead of moles when calculating a chemical reaction would be like trying to set up a speed dating event by taking the weights of all the men and women instead of matching them up pairwise. Sometimes it is much easier to calculate based on scalar quantity than it is to calculate based on mass.
- dfox 8y agoThe argument there is that avogadro's constant is just an arbitrary number and mol is not an unit, but weird case of SI prefix. On the other hand it is fundamental-ish constant, because it is defined as arbitrarily scaled result of inherently uncertain measurement. And the new definition of kilogram had significantly increased the attainable certainity of such measurement (to the extent that it is uncertain due to practical issues, not by definition). The other proposed replicable definition of kilogram (ie. mass of Si monocrystal wih particular geometry) would fix the definition of mole as some known and defined number, but would be significantly harder to replicate (because it would define how to produce an artifact in contrast to how to directly measure the mass as the ratified definition does)
- jackpirate 8y agoI think the GP is making the claim that Avogadro's constant should be 1 (effectively eliminating it), not that there's no need to count molecules.
- nas 8y agoYeah, I think that's his idea. So, instead of tables of molar mass in g/mol, you would have tables in terms of "amount of substance"/g. E.g. number of atoms or number of molecules.
- maccam94 8y agoAn Avogadro's constant number of molecules is one mole. One mole of hydrogen has much less mass than one mole of iron. You have to choose an arbitrary mass of a single element as the base quantity. Hydrogen might be the best theoretically, it's just a proton and an electron, but it is tricky to work with because it's a gas at room temperature. So instead the mole has been defined as the number of molecules in a specific mass of carbon-12.
- filmor 8y agoCarbon 12 is being used because that accounts for the nuclear forces which are absent for H-1.
- mbreese 8y agoI think this is exactly the rationale. But, from a more practical perspective... If instead of g/mol, we referred to molecules/g -- we would end up populating tables and charts with really big numbers. This would make lookup tables hard to read, difficult to publish, and hard to work with. Imagine if you had to do math with a bunch of 10^23 exponents all of the time. Instead, it was agreed to effectively pull out a constant value from each of those to make the math significantly easier. Now, instead of dealing with a lot of big numbers, all of the lookup tables could now list smaller g/mol values. And we would be left with just the one single large (Avogadro's) number in the equations. Honestly, we don't need a set mole constant, but it makes chemistry significantly easier to do so. Unlike the other constants mentioned in the OP, Avogadro's number is completely arbitrary. It could be '1' as the parent suggested, except then it makes the rest of the math more difficult. Even for this SI overhaul, we didn't really even need to redefine the mole, except for the fact that it was previously defined in terms of the old kg. This was just "fixing a glitch".