3 ms·
> Paying teachers more is not likely to improve the situation. As research by Justin Sandefur of the Centre for Global Development shows, poor-country teachers
by dahart 8y ago
> Paying teachers more is not likely to improve the situation. As research by Justin Sandefur of the Centre for Global Development shows, poor-country teachers tend to be remarkably well-paid, by local standards (see chart). And evidence from countries as diverse as Indonesia and Pakistan suggests that teachers’ pay levels have little impact on learning.
Is it at all reasonable to use units of GDP to compare salaries? That doesn’t seem right to me. The US GDP per capita in USD is about $60k. The Ethiopia GDP per capita in USD is less than $800. The only way to claim that teachers are “remarkably well-paid” by using units of GDP, while in reality 7 * GDP / person in Ethiopia (about $5,400 per year) is not enough to buy food or pay rent.
If the cost of living in Ethiopia were 1% of the cost of living in the US, then teachers would be better off. But the cost of living there is only slightly lower, so teachers’ buying power there is a tiny fraction of what it is here. They’re getting a lot less than our minimum wage in relative dollars.
https://www.numbeo.com/cost-of-living/country_result.jsp?country=Ethiopia https://www.numbeo.com/cost-of-living/country_result.jsp?cou...
- biglenny 8y agoThose stats are beyond wrong. Those look like prices for specific parts of Addis.
- umanwizard 8y agoIf 7 * GDP / person isn't enough to buy food or pay rent in Ethiopia, wouldn't you expect the overwhelming majority of people there to be starving and/or homeless?
- dahart 8y agoThat doesn't necessarily follow. Poor people can and do live in groups and pool funds. That said, the numbers of people in Ethiopia who are starving is much higher than in the US, it's something like 8-10% of the country.
- nabla9 8y agoThose numbeo stats are not accurate nor relevant for Ethiopians. They are only numbers some tourist, expat, NGO worker would use. GDP at purchasing power parity per capita is better measuring stick than just raw GDP. For Ethiopia it's roughly $2,100.
- dahart 8y agoSo even PPP adjusted, is it fair to call teachers in Ethiopia "remarkably well-paid"? Is using GDP reasonable if it needs to be adjusted for cost of living? Why not just use cost of living? It still feels like using GDP is a way to frame the argument to make a point that would be otherwise difficult to make. This teachers are well paid bit is being used to support the argument that paying teachers more won't help, and to be honest I don't buy that for a minute. For the curious, do you have any references for your number? I'd like to read more about GDP per capita at purchasing power parity, as well as see some stats that are relevant to Ethiopians. EDIT: I found a decent starting spot https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_GDP_(PPP)_per_capita https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_GDP_(PPP)... This article completely backs up my feeling that using raw GDP is super misleading. Even PPP adjusted GDP, "can be problematic because GDP per capita is not a measure of personal income." I feel like this confirms my suspicion that the article is mis-using economic stats to make a misleading argument.
- nabla9 8y agoYour criticism is not well placed. Try to think issues that skew the PPP's relevance to teachers relative pay and you realize that the skew must be against direction you are arguing.
- dahart 8y agoOkay, I should have left out the criticism. It wouldn’t be the first time I’ve been wrong. ;) I just want to understand. I don’t exactly see the skew yet, do you mean relative to other professions?
- screye 8y agoNope, the OP you are replying to is correct. In India, teachers are paid very handsomely when compared to other disciplines (~ Rs. 35000/month for fresh grad, after 7th pay commission). I and my brother grew up in a very high cost of living part of India, with my parents making a similar total wage and life was just fine. We rarely ate out (but my mom is a fabulous cook), nor went on vacation or splurged on fancy gadgets and toys, but the basics were in very much in place. Good nutritious food, large enough 2 bedroom house, decent schooling, working computer, internet access, all utilities, all while staying well groomed and growing up happy. In lower COL areas, it may even be possible to live with a bit more luxury than we did growing up. Cost of living calculations are misleading. The biggest expenses are rent, transportation and food. Those 3 much much cheaper in poor countries. ( joint families, public transport and dirt cheap food) Cultural traditions enable a cheaper lifestyle too. Retired Grand-parents take care of children and help with household tasks, so don't need to pay for day care and outside food. Adults usually stay with parents and slowly take over as head of family, instead of paying rent or needing to go in debt to buy a house upfront. > They’re getting a lot less than our minimum wage in relative dollars. Dunno about Ethiopia, but when compared to India, numbeo says Mumbai is 5 times cheaper than Boston. I am making ~10 times (for 1 person) more than what my parents made (for a family of 4) and QOL is not much different. I can afford fancier gadgets and a lot more fast food. But, human services like house cleaning, home cooks or a domestic help are waaaaay out side my pay grade, while my Indians making ~20 times less can afford some of those. The basics here in the US : housing, transportation and good food are pretty expensive in the US.
- dahart 8y ago> Cost of living calculations are misleading. I can totally agree, but using isn’t GDP units more misleading since GDP inherently reflects neither income nor cost of living? > The biggest expenses are rent, transportation and food. Those 3 much much cheaper in poor countries. ( joint families, public transport and dirt cheap food) Totally, the relative costs for various things I would expect to be different in different countries. But I don’t understand why that invalidates cost of living as a metric. It should be an absolute number that accounts for locally adjusted costs. I expect the local cost of living to account for whatever the normal average costs are for rent & food, regardless of how that compares to other countries. Of course there are a lot of problems comparing costs in the US to India or Ethiopia. But isn’t looking at what the average person makes relative to what the average person has to pay to live there a lot more relevant than the country’s GDP? > Mumbai is 5 times cheaper than Boston. I am making ~10 times (for 1 person) more than what my parents made (for a family of 4) and QOL is not much different. Right, exactly. You’re only making in relative terms 2x more, not 10x. And not all services scale the same way. Hiring human services in the US is relatively much more expensive. That’s all expected and agrees with what I’m saying. I don’t see how any of this supports GDP per capita as a QOL metric. Maybe the PPP adjusted metic like @nabla9 suggests, in which case the teacher pay factor in Ethiopia is 2.5x compared to the US, not 7x.