4 ms·
Is it possible to firewall Microsoft products using only the things that the average person has access to? (A telecom-supplied router and a Windows computer.)
by whatshisface 8y ago
Is it possible to firewall Microsoft products using only the things that the average person has access to? (A telecom-supplied router and a Windows computer.)
- esotericn 8y agoI don't believe it's possible to firewall Microsoft products in the general case of a power user that has access to an edge router. You'd have to do something insane like IP whitelisting only for services you care about, hope that none of them use MS services like Azure, disable Windows Update entirely, etc. It might be possible in the abstract sense of "right now nothing is getting out" but they have root on your box, it's closed source proprietary software, and you've basically broken the OS with this firewalling anyway. You need to be able to trust them.
- bilbo0s 8y agoThis. The fact that you're running Windows means you are potentially already compromised.
- lwkl 8y agoYou can Firewall Windows services. There is a inbuilt firewall and there may be default rules but you can customize it the way you want. It would be a pretty big security flaw if they let their services bypass the firewall. They may be profit oriented but not stupid.
- vetinari 8y agoTo use Windows Firewall, you would have to know what to black- or whitelist. Even most powerusers do not know that, and it could change with every update anyway. Therefore, Glasswire/Little Snitch-type firewalls are being used, where you get an alert during connect() time, and you can create the rule on the spot. Windows Firewall cannot do that, and neither can UIs built on top of it, like TinyWall.
- pritambaral 8y agoWindows update has, in the past, bypassed the user's firewall rules to download updates.
- laumars 8y agoAs discussed in the other thread, Windows firewall is garbage for this particular type of problem: 1/ it's not novice friendly (your best suggestion thus far required users to input dozens off lines of code into cmd.exe) 2/ it's defaults still allow Windows telemetry to get through (which was the exact thing the GP was trying to protect against) 3/ it's a pain in the arse to keep updated compared to any of the other suggestions made in this thread. If the only option was Windows firewall or nothing, then I'd suggest people go with a PiHole since it takes an equal amount of technical know how to get the initial set up done. But at least once PiHole is set up, it's self managing (unlike Windows firewall) and will have much saner defaults too. Thankfully though, there are other software firewalls for Windows that address the limitations I've described above. I've named one, another poster has listed a few others. If the option is software firewall or nothing, then I'd strongly recommend that user go with a third party one instead of relying solely on Windows firewall.
- laumars 8y agoA software firewall might work. It's been years since I last ran Windows but there were decent 3rd party solutions like Zone Alarm where you could white list specific applications and the specific sites they tried to connect to.
- lwkl 8y agoYou don‘t need any third-party tools for that. Since Windows Vista and Windows XP SP3 the inbuilt Windows Firewall can take care of all that. Just create a rule that denies internet access for the telemetry service. It can be configured by GUI and script.
- laumars 8y agoThe point of Zone Alarm and it's ilk is that you can have deny all rules and you'd get a desktop notification when an application attempts to make an outbound connection - which you can then approve or deny. As far as I know Windows firewall doesn't do this. Thus with Windows firewall you'd need to know all of the services you want to block up front - which is definitely not that easy for experts let alone the novices the GP was discussing.
- lwkl 8y agoThe way you describe it would not be feasible for a novice either. Almost every piece of software you use today needs internet access. That‘s why Microsoft delivers Windows with sane Firewall rules and just asks if you‘re in a trusted network and adjusts the firewall rules based on that. Also most software developers configure firewall rules during setup. If a unknown executable will try to access the internet there is a pop-up like you described that asks you if you want to allow access. Anyways the OP was asking if there are any tools available to the basic user to deny internet access for these telemtry services and there is the inbuilt Windows Firewall. I even found a script [0] that does what the OP is looking for. I‘m not sure if it‘s up to date though. All the information needed to update the script is published in the public documentation provided by Microsoft though. Thanks to GDPR you have extensive documentation on all things telemtry related to Windows 10 and Microsoft Office. For most users setting their telemetry settings to basic should suffice. [0] https://winaero.com/blog/stop-windows-10-spying-on-you-using-just-windows-firewall/ https://winaero.com/blog/stop-windows-10-spying-on-you-using...
- squ3ek 8y agoI just use "Windows Firewall Control" as a front end for the built in windows firewall and have it set up to default deny all.