3 ms·
For anyone thinking this is something novel. It's not. It's very common for relevant companies e.g. telcos to try and predict the composition of your household
by threeseed 8y ago
For anyone thinking this is something novel. It's not.
It's very common for relevant companies e.g. telcos to try and predict the composition of your household so they know what plan you should be on and how much data you are likely to use.
Likewise for energy companies it's useful to optimise their demand curves.
- hahajk 8y agoI don’t think they predict that based on photos though. Facebook might indeed be the first company to do this particular analysis since they have the data to do so. That doesn’t make it patentable, though. I doubt they invented any new math or techniques; just different inputs and outputs to a CNN. But that also doesn’t mean they won’t be awarded a patent.
- smt88 8y agoIf the headline had been, “Utility Co. uses data to predict household size,” it wouldn’t have this much HN activity. The problematic parts are that 1) Facebook was thinking about using personal photos in way that users don’t expect and don’t intend; 2) the data is photos, meaning it’s possible to ID the subjects with high accuracy; 3) Facebook is not using this to plan their costs, but rather to help advertisers get inside our heads.
- llampx 8y ago> “Utility Co. uses data to predict household size,” How about "Utility Co. shares data with city, predicting when you have an Airbnb guest or take a vacation"? I'd say a utility using data from its own systems is the definition of what used to be allowable. Sharing that data without consent and using unorthodox sources (detecting objects in the background) is what most people find objectionable.