3 ms·
This is the scenario where you know nothing else other than you waited 10 minutes for this event and it didn't happen. Sure, if you have more data, then you ca
by PeterisP 8y ago
This is the scenario where you know nothing else other than you waited 10 minutes for this event and it didn't happen.
Sure, if you have more data, then you can get much tighter bounds for your estimate.
- nkurz 8y agoThis is the scenario where you know nothing else other than you waited 10 minutes To make the math work, I think you need to make several other assumptions. Don't you also have to know that that ten minutes you sampled are representative? That the events (if they did occur) are independent? It seems odd that you'd in a situation where you can rely on specific assumptions like these while also believing that buses and aliens are equally likely to appear.
- YeGoblynQueenne 8y agoYou always have more data -background knowledge- unless you've only existed in those last 10 minutes. And if something has really never happened before, like my alien invasion example, what have we learned by applying the rule of three? Honestly- perform the experiment yourself. Wait for X time, then calculate 3/X. Do you now have an upper bound on the probability that an alien invasion will happen?
- carlmr 8y ago>Wait for X time, then calculate 3/X. Do you now have an upper bound on the probability that an alien invasion will happen? Assuming we would observe an alien invasion and write about it, we have about 5000 years since humans started writing. So 3/5000a, so an upper bound on an alien invasion in a year (assuming p hasn't changed since we started writing) is 0,06% per year. It's an upper bound in any case, meaning that is this or less. That includes p = 0. You're just 95% confident that it won't be higher than that. But maybe the aliens brought us our writing system.
- PeterisP 8y agoYes, I do have a reasonable (95% confidence, as per article) upper bound on the probability - as I haven't noticed an alien invasion during my lifetime, it seems reasonable to conclude that noticeable alien invasions are very rare events and happen less frequently than once every decade. Possibly much less frequently, possibly many orders of magnitude less frequently, possibly never, but that's how upper bounds work.
- YeGoblynQueenne 8y agoAn upper bound of "maybe, who knows" is not useful or informative enough to make a whole "rule" about it.