3 ms·
Men and women would have to actually need each other for the contract to make sense. But, the toothpaste is out of the tube. I don't feel the need to get marr
by ravenstine 8y ago
Men and women would have to actually need each other for the contract to make sense.
But, the toothpaste is out of the tube. I don't feel the need to get married because anything a wife can do, I can do with appliances and without breaking a sweat. Anything else can be supplemented by services. House dirty? My robot vacuum picks up a lot of the slack, and if I don't want to do the rest on my own, I can schedule a maid service. If I don't cook my own meals, GrubHub can be my personal chef. Something broken? Need some tough work done? There's apps that will hail handy-people for you. It doesn't end there; there's a plethora of engaging entertainment you can engage with and you don't even have to leave your home. This situation is salient to both men and women.
I think marriage will continue to decline no matter what, but one thing that might make it somewhat more appealing is if western culture could do away with the needless expenses around the tradition and the ceremony. The amount spent on a mere ring is absurd(honestly wtf is going on here), but people want these crazy weddings where 3 parties, the couple, the wife's parents, and the husband's parents have to chip in. The dress has to be expensive, the venue has to be expensive and booked way in advance, the catering is expensive, etc. And I'm supposed to want all of this? Good grief.
If it was not a disappointment that people have modest weddings, perhaps a few more people might get married? Eh, I don't really know about that.
By the way, I'm in no way complaining. There was a time not that long ago when even men who weren't married by a certain age had a stigma against them. In some ways that stigma still exists, but it's largely been defanged as companies today are perfectly willing to hire men who don't have families.
- stcredzero 8y agoI don't feel the need to get married because anything a wife can do, I can do with appliances and without breaking a sweat. It's more about sharing your life with someone than getting chores done. one thing that might make it somewhat more appealing is if western culture could do away with the needless expenses around the tradition and the ceremony...If it was not a disappointment that people have modest weddings, perhaps a few more people might get married? It used to be that only rich people spent $8k-$80k on a wedding. Most of the time in the US, it happened in the living room or in the local church, and the reception was in the backyard. Today's weddings are a fabrication of the wedding industrial complex. They're rich people's affairs sold to the common person as a necessity, much like the diamond engagement ring. Spending the equivalent of today's $300 all told on a wedding used to be the norm. The ceremony and the gathering of friends and community can be wonderful, even magic. I think the money and glitz get in the way. I've been in some bands that would get hired for weddings, and the most beautiful weddings I've been at were DIY affairs done at home on the cheap, but with sincere feelings and meaning. My own wedding was pulled off on the low end of the price scale. We hired a waterside Chinese restaurant, got good fuss-free catering, and got the day-of coordinator and linens for free. I hired musicians I knew and we went and got orchids from a nursery and bought our own drinks from Costco. The most beautiful wedding I've been to was a quaker wedding held in the back yard, completely DIY. Barely nothing more than a circle of chairs and home made decorations.
- ravenstine 8y ago> It's more about sharing your life with someone than getting chores done. I agree, but it's also about those things as well and has been since time immemorial. When those things go away, is it surprising when people settle for relationships over the complexities of marriage? > I've been in some bands that would get hired for weddings, and the most beautiful weddings I've been at were DIY affairs done at home on the cheap, but with sincere feelings and meaning. My own wedding was pulled off on the low end of the price scale. We hired a waterside Chinese restaurant, got good fuss-free catering, and got the day-of coordinator and linens for free. I hired musicians I knew and we went and got orchids from a nursery and bought our own drinks from Costco. That sounds great!
- stcredzero 8y agoWhen those things go away, is it surprising when people settle for relationships over the complexities of marriage? Long term relationships are complicated as it is. Just how much additional complication is caused by marriage?
- derefr 8y agoI think you're arguing in your first and second paragraphs against relationships, not marriage. The question is why marriage is declining within relationships. Your third paragraph partially addresses that, but I disagree: effectively nobody is having weddings beyond their means, or feeling required by society to do so. Plenty of people have modest weddings, you just don't hear about them, because fewer people are invited to a small wedding than a big one, so there are fewer people who have been to a small wedding than a big one. There are just some really rich people (or averagely-rich people with really rich extended families) who pay to have fancy weddings because they can.
- ravenstine 8y agoYes, my arguments can apply to relationships, but they especially apply to marriage as the contract, both socially and legally, implies set of expectations. When those roles have been removed, why go through all the trouble? Relationships can still make sense in the face of role-obsolescence as people who don't need each other can still "Netflix n' chill." People can even cohabitate and serve no other purpose to each other besides non-platonic companionship. So at that point, why potentially ruin an already good thing? > effectively nobody is having weddings beyond their means, or feeling required by society to do so Our experiences differ significantly in that area. Even when it's within their means, it takes them a considerable amount of work to get there. For many, the outcome isn't worth the amount of effort. Society isn't requiring people to get married, but that doesn't mean that people aren't subject to cultural expectations and peer pressure. As a perpetually single person, I am regularly asked by people whether I've "met that special woman yet." A person who gives more shits than I do would likely feel that they really ought to find that other person and "settle down", if you will. Society doesn't need requirements for people to do things in order to conform. > There are just some really rich people (or averagely-rich people with really rich extended families) who pay to have fancy weddings because they can. That, I never denied.