4 ms·
In my view, the only way to reduce the cost is to figure out where the money is going. Otherwise, everybody can say: "We had to charge $58000 because we had to
by analog31 8y ago
In my view, the only way to reduce the cost is to figure out where the money is going. Otherwise, everybody can say: "We had to charge $58000 because we had to pay someone else $57000." Right now everybody points to everybody else as the culprit for high health care costs.
A centralized system has a better way of tracking this. If everybody involved with the health care system is working for a government salary, and everybody who sells equipment is selling it to the government, then we know who is getting rich by exactly how much.
- AnthonyMouse 8y ago> In my view, the only way to reduce the cost is to figure out where the money is going. It isn't going to any specific place. The system is designed to destroy price sensitivity, so everything is overpriced and everyone is charged for things they don't actually need. When there is a bill for $58000, it's not that the procedure costs $1000 and there is this one place receiving the remaining balance we could just cut out. It's that the procedure would cost $1000 only everything that should have cost $20 was charged for $200 and then 500% more steps were performed than were necessary. Trying to play the blame game is pointless because everyone will come up with a reason to justify their high margin or unnecessary step and the truth is nobody is innocent. What's needed is to actually make purchasing decisions based on price. If one provider charges $58000 and the other charges $56000, the patient should know ahead of time that there is a $2000 price difference, and actually pay the entire $2000 less by choosing the less expensive one. Do that and there is price competition, and the provider that does the work of eliminating unnecessary costs for you will be the one with the lowest price. And once you have someone offering to do a $1000 procedure for $1000, who is going to pay $58000?
- pfisch 8y agoWhy should we have to figure this shit out for them at all!? This procedure costs $x because it is the oecd average cost and that is the end of the discussion. It is on them to fight over their slices of the pie with each other. They don't get to make their problems our problems. Its not realistic to act like people have time to price compare for emergency medical services. It just isn't a normal free market so much as it is like a mugging. When you get mugged the question is how much will you trade for your life, and the answer is everything you have. We need to stop pretending like it is a free market and trying to apply free market solutions that do not apply.
- AnthonyMouse 8y ago> This procedure costs $x because it is the oecd average cost and that is the end of the discussion. It is on them to fight over their slices of the pie with each other. When their costs are lower than the OECD average then you're still paying too much, but it's even worse when they're higher. Each country has different regulations, taxes and subsidies, real estate costs, medical licensing rules and supply of medical professionals, average income and cost of living which affects how much workers have to be paid etc. When the OECD average price for a procedure is $5000 but the zero-profit cost of doing it in your country is $7000, nobody will do it. Or the provider who already owns the equipment as a sunk cost will do it, but the waiting list for the procedure will be 22 months. (Hopefully it's not related to an active pregnancy.) > Its not realistic to act like people have time to price compare for emergency medical services. It's not realistic to act like all medical services are emergencies. Most of them aren't, what's the excuse then? And once you have a baseline for what a procedure costs in a competitive market on a non-emergent basis in your location, it becomes a lot easier to identify a 10,000% markup for no reason in an emergency situation as manifestly unreasonable.
- pfisch 8y agoThe only way the profits could be 0 is if people's salaries are too high. Vet school costs a lot, almost as much as medical school. Yet the procedures are much, much cheaper. Probably because vets are paid half as much or less than doctors.
- AnthonyMouse 8y ago> The only way the profits could be 0 is if people's salaries are too high. Salaries are supply and demand. If you lower salaries you get fewer doctors -- you have to convince people to go to medical school instead of law school or business school. And the OECD average salary may be too low if the relevant city has a higher cost of living than the OECD average, requiring higher salaries to get people to practice there rather than somewhere their money goes further.
- fzeroracer 8y agoI'm wondering if you have honestly ever been seriously ill or injured. Because no one is going to haggle properly when they're in unimaginable pain, or when their options are the local far more expensive doctor vs another that's hundreds of miles away, or when the illness is time critical. People need to stop thinking that somehow price transparency will solve problems that arise from mostly unpredictable circumstances.
- AnthonyMouse 8y agoThe large majority of medical costs are not a result of time-critical decisions. A surgery that currently costs $50,000 may be scheduled weeks in advance. If a doctor 200 miles away would do it just as well for $10,000, how many people are going to say "nah, don't want to drive 200 miles, I'll just pay the extra $40,000"?
- fzeroracer 8y agoI can think of three groups of people. The first are people who can't take any time off from work. 200 miles away means less time working or less time managing family. I can think of a few circumstances where people lost their job as a result of such an injury, so for them the priority is feeding their family and then dealing with the bills later. Because you can put off medical bills, you can't put off food on the table. The second are people that are going to go bankrupt anyways. Why does it matter to them how much they're going to pay when they're losing literally everything anyways? Might as well go for the closer option since again, work and all. And finally the third are people that literally don't have the option to drive 200 miles. When my mother had her stroke she didn't have the option to go anywhere but the closest possible hospital, and post-stroke recovery had to be done locally. If you can't think of the dire circumstances people are in, then you've never been poor or have had to deal with seriously ill people. Think harder.
- AnthonyMouse 8y ago> I can think of three groups of people. What about everybody else? Lowering the cost for everybody outside of three groups of people would still be pretty great. Especially since it would be hard for providers to justify specifically discriminating against your groups, so they would still benefit from competition lowering prices in general. > The first are people who can't take any time off from work. 200 miles away means less time working or less time managing family. I can think of a few circumstances where people lost their job as a result of such an injury, so for them the priority is feeding their family and then dealing with the bills later. Because you can put off medical bills, you can't put off food on the table. This feels pretty weak. You can't afford to take a day off work, but you can afford to pay an extra $40,000? Basically nobody is in that situation. If they incur the $40,000 debt, they'll not be paying it, so this is really just your second group. > The second are people that are going to go bankrupt anyways. Why does it matter to them how much they're going to pay when they're losing literally everything anyways? Might as well go for the closer option since again, work and all. But then they're not actually paying it. When charging $50,000 only means that it selects exclusively for people who will file for bankruptcy, the provider who does that is headed for bankruptcy itself, to be replaced by someone who realizes it's better to get $10,000 90% of the time than $50,000 ~0% of the time. > And finally the third are people that literally don't have the option to drive 200 miles. When my mother had her stroke she didn't have the option to go anywhere but the closest possible hospital, and post-stroke recovery had to be done locally. Isn't this just emergency care again? Emergency care is different. It makes sense to have the locality provide it in the same way they provide fire departments, with the purpose to stabilize the situation to the point that you (or whoever is making your decisions) has a chance to assess things and make a reasoned choice how to proceed further. It's also a small proportion of overall medical costs. And for recovery, we're just back to cost vs. convenience. If it was actually $40,000 more for each visit, it may still be worth driving 200 miles each time. If you had to drive 200 miles each way every day for ten years to save $40,000 once, well, that's another story. But the claim isn't that the further away place is always cheaper on net, it's that the fact that it sometimes can be would force the closer place to compete more on price. > If you can't think of the dire circumstances people are in, then you've never been poor or have had to deal with seriously ill people. Think harder. This kind of policy choice is literally a matter of life and death. Don't pretend you know the answer before you've had the debate. Being wrong is killing people one way or the other.
- pfisch 8y ago>A centralized system has a better way of tracking this. If everybody involved with the health care system is working for a government salary, and everybody who sells equipment is selling it to the government, then we know who is getting rich by exactly how much. Did you not see the audit from the pentagon that came out today??? https://www.reuters.com/article/us-usa-pentagon-audit/pentagon-fails-its-first-ever-audit-official-says-idUSKCN1NK2MC https://www.reuters.com/article/us-usa-pentagon-audit/pentag... Why would you think they will track things well when they clearly do not.