8 ms·
Facebook Applied for Patent to Predict Who’s in House Based on Family Photos
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- strict9 8y agoAs creepy as it is to see detailed illustrations, I've always assumed they've been doing this for a long time. IP address patterns joined with timestamps, tags, and other social interactions are too easy to link and beneficial for all sorts of targeting.
- buboard 8y agoIsn't the patent trivially contestable? Dont advertisers mine such data to infer relationships, such as parents/children? Don't people infer the kind of relationship just by looking at a (physical) photo of a couple in a house ?
- rustcharm 8y agoGo ahead and contest it then.
- nothis 8y agoWe're 5 years away from this shit being regulated away in Europe for good. It's ridiculous. The only reason it's not illegal is that we never had the technology so no reason to worry about it.
- buboard 8y agois the 5 years some kind of future roadmap? Also, why should this method be illegal?
- dmead 8y agoif this is not illegal, why even have a CIA? why shouldn't the government just pay facebook for data access?
- giancarlostoro 8y agoI usually make the joke that Google / Facebook are the NSA.
- Jill_the_Pill 8y agoDo you think they don't?
- buboard 8y ago> the government just pay facebook That's ridiculous. Imagine the outcry if the US government had to pay facebook for that. horror! but thanks to the NSA and coercion, it's all free.
- interlocutor 8y agoThis should be illegal because I have a right to privacy. Corporations should have my permission in order to store, process and sell information about me.
- buboard 8y agoright , facebook can ask you for this permission when uploading the photos. But that doesnt make the algorithm itself illegal.
- threeseed 8y agoComments like this make no sense to me. You gave Facebook your data and agreed with a ToS that states pretty clearly this is what they will do. And then are upset when they do it ?
- dwd 8y agoAnd for others in the photo, some of whom may not have an account, did FaceBook get their permission to generate meta data about them?
- squarefoot 8y agoWhich brings us to a similar issue: what if I don't want my voice being recorded, analyzed and tracked by digital assistants? How do I prevent companies from profiling my habits by using other peoples devices?
- dwd 8y agoGood point! This was discussed a bit when people started wearing Google Glasses and creeped out strangers who didn't want to be recorded. Could be a hard one. I imagine that the voice recognition is processed in the cloud, where for privacy it should be on the device. As it is, there's no need for the Government to bend the law to store meta data on citizens; these companies do it all for them.
- 8y ago
- gerdesj 8y agoWhen reading the article, was your instinctive response: "cool use of technology" or "ooooh, creepy"? This is a very large international corporation deriving additional information about you based on something that you have shared. This is of course a major part of the very modus operandi of FB n Co. We are all dimly aware of things like shadow profiles and the like and that our mobile (cell) contacts are mined routinely and cross referenced. Our browsers spew personally identifiable info. and so do our browsing habits. This is all very new (15 years or so) and very odd (hasn't happened before). FB, Google and all the other data miners for ads for cash pushers are a new phenomenon. These companies are massive, international and seemingly insensitive to anything that doesn't adversely affect their bottom line. Now we have an example of FB proudly attempting to patent a creepy (my term) process because it is now considered normal. I'm not sure I like the kind of environment that allows FB to consider that sort of process as being potentially patentable. Actually I'm very uncomfortable with the idea that that sort of process being patentable is normal. I'm going to tentatively label that sort of environment as toxic.
- buboard 8y agoI 'd say mildly cool use of technology, considering the current state of machinelearning this doesnt seem groundbreaking. the creepiness depends on how it is going to be used. As I am not a facebook user, this FB-phobia seems a little bizarre to me. I am certainly not for throwing out all tech because of possible creepiness.
- gerdesj 8y agoI'm not exactly a Luddite myself (my 4.19 Linux kernel is compiling right now) but I'm old enough to see a few trends come and go (47). I'm CREST accredited, MD with two partners and 20 employees. I do have a FB account (named as per my name here) and don't get me wrong, it is quite handy for keeping in touch and having ads blasted at me in return. OK, I use Privacy Badger, uBlock O and a few other tricks to attempt to tame the tsunami of crap. As you say, it is very much: "mildly cool use of tech." but it is also insidious and corrosive when you look at the effect it has. I am not advocating throwing out all tech (I'm fitting up Home Assistant at home right now, carefully) but I am pointing out that what is seen as normal today is not what was seen as normal a few years ago.
- giancarlostoro 8y ago> The only reason it's not illegal is that we never had the technology so no reason to worry about it. The technology was available for as long as people have had smartphones and social media, smartphones specifically due to their geolocation capabilities. I'm just surprised if they only just now started doing this.
- bordercases 8y agoNo one is logically omniscient. And it shouldn't be a reason to not regulate just because we could have regulated sooner.
- giancarlostoro 8y ago> No one is logically omniscient. And it shouldn't be a reason to not regulate just because we could have regulated sooner. True, though it seems me and a few others in this thread thought they were already doing this. They at least should have a rough idea by what users already tell Facebook, but I guess they want to make it even more aware of people who don't tell Facebook everything about their personal lives. I also found it creepy that Instagram had Bluetooth data enabled, like if it wants to know where I am and compare it with where other people are by keeping track of bluetooth devices around me, of course it could just be some weird Android permissions thing I usually don't give apps permissions and reset them occasionally though.
- kodablah 8y agoOne hopeful side effect of such laws would be reduced substanceless whining. Day after day is deja vu with these articles and the comment sections. This is not an indictment of HN as it's an accurate microcosm of opinion of the non-silent masses. Sadly, the whining would shift to non-compliance and non-enforcement as has occurred with GDPR and its predecessors.
- noarchy 8y ago>We're 5 years away from this shit being regulated away in Europe for good. No doubt the EU governments themselves will not be beholden to such regulations.
- shaki-dora 8y agoAll EU privacy legislation, such as the recent GDPR, apply to government entities exactly as they apply to private companies. (When your cynicism gets so bad that you just support your rage against everything with made-up facts, that effectively removes any incentives for politicians to do good. Why bother, when your actions never even make it to all the red-faced constituents screaming all sorts of invectives at whenever you appear in public?)
- 706f6f70 8y agoI just hope the EU has the foresight to make the legislation enforceable in a post-EU European legal environment.
- longerthoughts 8y agoIs it naive of me to be completely fine with this?
- Jyaif 8y agoIt's unacceptable to not bash FB on HN.
- yumraj 8y agoPlease feel free to share a valid argument in favor of FB and its actions, if you can find one. I'm sure you will be upvoted, for creativity if nothing else.
- gammateam 8y agoThat's optimistic. Hackernews is not exempt from the groupthink and the downvote censoring effect is in almost every thread, would it be called irony if you didn't notice?
- longerthoughts 8y agoThere's a difference between arguing for the freedom to say something disagreeable and arguing the disagreeable thing itself.
- buboard 8y agoDefending facebook and criticising the cult-like herdishness of the "tech" crowd in here are two orthogonal things. one does not invalidate the other.
- jsizzle 8y agoIs there a real advantage for them to patent this as opposed to keeping it a trade secret? Why would they patent this and make their intentions known publicly?
- gradys 8y agoMy thoughts exactly. It's easy enough to hide infringement of a patent like this that I doubt they'd ever be able to enforce it anyway. Did they forget that journalists scan patent filings, especially from big, newsworthy companies?
- adamnemecek 8y agoCan this company just quietly go away?
- schintan 8y agoIs a PR campaign in progress against Facebook ? Lots of negative articles in a short period of time.
- RandallBrown 8y agoI think it's just an easy way to get clicks these days.
- longerthoughts 8y agoI suspect it's news providers chasing a popular wave of outrage because they know people want to read articles about Facebook doing something sketchy. Reminds me of the flood of negative articles about United Airlines in the wake of the incident with the guy getting dragged off of the plane.
- muthdra 8y agoMaybe they finally broke enough things.
- buboard 8y agoMore like, the market loves fb-bashing articles. Some advertisers will be very happy.
- SwellJoe 8y agoEven before we knew how nasty facebook behaves behind closed doors, I would have found this creepy. Not that I'm surprised companies are doing it...the profit available to whichever company grabs the most data about people is huge, so there will always be huge resources devoted to figuring out more and more about people (even details they've chosen not to share). I used to be somewhat naively optimistic about companies like Google and Facebook. I knew so many people who worked at those places, and I had such positive feelings about their ethical core...but, in hindsight, that optimism and that faith was poorly placed. They're companies that make money entirely based on the profitability of violating people's privacy. Of course they're gonna be evil; evil is where the money is in the advertising industry.
- consumer451 8y agoMy personal forward-looking concerns about both of the companies you mentioned are what will happen when the founders die or retire. It is likely that truly amoral Wall Street folks will take over. I am still very concerned about Google in this regard, but I am not convinced that FB could get any worse.[0] [0] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18453958 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18453958
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- jaggederest 8y agoImagine Larry Ellison running Facebook. The mind recoils at the thought.
- consumer451 8y agoFB is already close to there in my opinion. My main concern is someone like Ellison running Google. For all of Google’s faults, they could be a lot more evil.
- scottlocklin 8y agoSounds better than Zuck and whatshername. Maybe they'd ship features users want once in a while.
- iagooar 8y agoI wonder how many FB engineers read HN. In case some of them do: please, LEAVE Facebook. Don't be part of the problem. Don't justify contributing to mass surveillance just because you can work on cool tech. Don't be evil, goddammit.
- tagawa 8y agoUnless they have some power to change things from within, in which case please stay.
- SmellyGeekBoy 8y agoSo all of the engineers with a moral conscience leave, selecting for less moral engineers? This doesn't seem like a great strategy.
- iagooar 8y agoI would love to believe that reducing the engineering supply because most people don't want to work there could have a significant impact on the amount of outcome that FB can produce. Thus, a net positive, yes.
- tomashertus 8y agoOhh another genius engineers needed a patent added into their resume in order to ask for a promotion.
- ilovecaching 8y agoCan we please stop with the constant barrage of anti-FB posts? This is supposed to be a community for hackers. Many of our friends and colleagues work at Facebook, Google, and other advertisers, those people help build the open source projects we use to run our businesses, go to the same conferences as us, and its asinine to assume that because they choose to work there they've sold out their morals and that Facebook is an irredeemable den of evil. We're already all aware of the issues at Facebook, and that Facebook is working on fixing them. Constantly dragging them through the mud on HN is just going to build a wall instead of promote a dialogue about what they could be doing to improve.
- saagarjha 8y agoI mean, it's also not great to bury your head in the sand…
- PKop 8y ago> and that Facebook is working on fixing them. Facebook's business model & DNA is probably antithetical to seriously fixing them.
- danso 8y agoFacebook is one of the most powerful and influential companies in the world. With great power comes great responsibility, and scrutiny. Your pleading to treat them like garage-company hackers is absurd and out of touch with reality.
- throwawaymath 8y agoOh come on, they pled no such thing...must we constantly do this with Facebook? There's nothing about the comment that's absurd or out of touch with reality, they're just expressing exasperation at the utterly repetitive deluge of news about Facebook and the incessently rehashed discussion that follows. I can understand going over these talking points when a sprawling piece of investigative journalism with legitimately new information is published. But we have to do this song and dance when Buzzfeed searches Google Patents with the keyword "Facebook" now too? How many patents do you think Facebook has that would draw the conspiratorial ire of HN? We'll be here day in and day out for months. While we're at it, for those downvoting - why don't you take a close look at all the similar patents registered by every tech company that competes with Facebook. Every large tech company has patents like these. This is not news, this is just outrage bait.
- o0-0o 8y agoGod, what a creepy bunch of fucks.
- threeseed 8y agoFor anyone thinking this is something novel. It's not. It's very common for relevant companies e.g. telcos to try and predict the composition of your household so they know what plan you should be on and how much data you are likely to use. Likewise for energy companies it's useful to optimise their demand curves.
- hahajk 8y agoI don’t think they predict that based on photos though. Facebook might indeed be the first company to do this particular analysis since they have the data to do so. That doesn’t make it patentable, though. I doubt they invented any new math or techniques; just different inputs and outputs to a CNN. But that also doesn’t mean they won’t be awarded a patent.
- smt88 8y agoIf the headline had been, “Utility Co. uses data to predict household size,” it wouldn’t have this much HN activity. The problematic parts are that 1) Facebook was thinking about using personal photos in way that users don’t expect and don’t intend; 2) the data is photos, meaning it’s possible to ID the subjects with high accuracy; 3) Facebook is not using this to plan their costs, but rather to help advertisers get inside our heads.
- llampx 8y ago> “Utility Co. uses data to predict household size,” How about "Utility Co. shares data with city, predicting when you have an Airbnb guest or take a vacation"? I'd say a utility using data from its own systems is the definition of what used to be allowable. Sharing that data without consent and using unorthodox sources (detecting objects in the background) is what most people find objectionable.
- rubenhak 8y agoFB should be renamed to EvilCorp...
- scarejunba 8y agoThis is cool. I wouldn't have to tag people as mom, son, etc. My photos would be auto-categorized. If the kids are home and the thermostat is up that's fine. If not, it's not. Yeah, definitely cool.
- llampx 8y agoI'm a bit more cynical and think that the beneficiary of this is not you and the objective is not to reduce your electricity bills. Rather, you (collective you) are the product, and the companies that want your attention and will pay the most are the customers.
- tehlike 8y agoMost companies file patents for various reasons, even eithout actually having the invention implemented. Often times, there is compensation for the employee in case one is filed
- hkyeti 8y agoMost companies? Source for this claim that the majority of companies in our industry do this.
- samstave 8y agoWhat if someone reveals the GPS coordinates of the FB eecutive offfices? What if FB execs "checkin" every place they are? Do they want this? No. What if FB were to scan every single license plate that drove by their HQ campus and reported that to the authorities? Would people want that? Where is the line drawn?
- auslander 8y agoGoogle Photos, with all your Android pics, already "automatically analyzes photos, identifying ... People, Places, and Things. Google Photos recognizes faces, grouping similar ones together; geographic landmarks (such as the Eiffel Tower); and subject matter, including birthdays, buildings, animals, food, and more." https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Google_Photos https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Google_Photos
- ComputerGuru 8y agoYes, but their reason (at least ostensibly) is so that you can search for photos by their content. (yeah, yeah, I hear ya.)
- auslander 8y agoI'm amused every time i see Android phone in hands of my tech-literate friends :)
- jvolkman 8y agoWhy?
- auslander 8y agoiPhones today are roughly the same price as top Androids, and are not running Ad company spyware.
- dirkgently 8y agoSpyware? Any evidence of this or you are just high on Apple Kool aid / Google hate?
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- 8y ago
- Simulacra 8y agoI think if any company will reach that of The Circle, it will be Facebook.
- fuckokcupid 8y agoIf they continue keep doing these kind of creepy things, one day, it will become Myspace. It's already a ghost town for most part where middle aged people are adding random political articles.
- llampx 8y agoAs long as those middle-aged people keep clicking ads, younger people keep clicking Instagram stories, and angry mobs keep sending each other incendiary messages on WhatsApp, the Facebook juggernaut has nothing to fear.
- anonytrary 8y agoSo it's illegal to peep inside your neighbors' windows, but automating this on a mass scale is patentable? Tangent: Now I'm curious if criminals can patent methods for committing crimes. There's a whole science to pick-pocketing, I'd love to read clever pick-pocketing technique patents if they exist!
- adjkant 8y agoWhich would be more costly? The criminal sentence for pickpocketing or the patent infringement lawsuit that follows?
- anonytrary 8y agoAdditionally, would this incentivize pick-pocketers to steal more valuable items?
- lwansbrough 8y agoIf you work at Facebook and you build this shit, just know that if anyone knows what you do, they'll hate you for it.
- AceyMan 8y agoRelevant mention: just saw new billboards in LA for the Facebook Portal video chat devices today. Anyone who uses these should expect to be data-mined good and hard.
- aacook 8y agoI feel like the best audience for the product is elderly people. The Portal has a serious shot and helping to fight isolation and loneliness. The downside of the Portal is giving up a bit of privacy. Isolation with elderly is such a big problem that for me at least, it's worth the potential downside. I tried setting my 94-year-old grandparents with an Echo Show last December and what unfolded was hilarious: https://nanagram.co/blog/echo-show-unboxing https://nanagram.co/blog/echo-show-unboxing But in all seriousness, in the coming weeks, when I was able to get the Echo Show to actually work, it was an incredible tool for communicating with my elderly grandparents. The two main problems with it (besides being unable to say "Alexa") were them hardly ever being in view of the fixed camera and the volume buttons not being user-friendly. Ultimately it didn't work out. My grandmother is now between assisted living / rehab / hospitals and I'm seriously considering the Portal.
- fleshfly 8y agoCompany culture starts from the very top. C-level huddles determine the ethical priorities of its decision-makers, and these eventually are delegated down to teams.
- urandom99 8y agoI had a small though experiment about how to model a system influenced heavily by social media that tracks users and builds extensive profiles of them. On first level, such a system (let's call it A) is equivalent to a imaginary loaded die with a control that lets one control what comes out when rolling it. A system (let's call it B) without social media is more like a fair die. On a long run, the net outcome of system A will be heavy with induced biases and that of system B will be fair but could be with slight biases due to natural randomness. If the system A is controlled by private interests rather than societal welfare, it would lead to unhealthy societal setup. Hence, the system A is inherently flawed and is also dangerous to overall well-being. System B doesn't have this flaw inherently. ... PS: purely thoughts and so abstract.
- flashgordon 8y agoWith all this what would a paid market for WhatsApp/<share stuff only with people I care about app> with full privacy look like? Or is this what slack is?