5 ms·
Yes, they are a news organization. Covering the election is what a news organization should do, and it's hard to argue the Clinton emails weren't newsworthy. >
by boomboomsubban 8y ago
Yes, they are a news organization. Covering the election is what a news organization should do, and it's hard to argue the Clinton emails weren't newsworthy.
>They have been to be a known tool for the Russian government, even going as far as creating a show for Julian Assange on the state-backed RT TV Network
This is untrue. There is nothing suggesting that Wikileaks has knowingly coordinated with Russia. And that TV show was indepently produced by Assange, with RT buying some ofthe distribution rights.
- jsutton 8y agoCovering news is much different than exposing the private communications of a political party.
- boomboomsubban 8y agoNo, it is not. It may have been preffered if some of the less relevant emails were not shared, it's also unclear who should make the call of what is "relevant" and either way their release was news.
- midniteslayr 8y agoIf they are a news organization, they do a terrible job of reporting the news. They are a black box repository for leaked data. They were once a great resource for info hackers and leakers to push their data, like back in 2008/2009. But that was before news organizations started using their own secure drop servers for sources. Once WikiLeaks sources started to not go to them, they started to look for other benefactors and sources. They found it in the Russian Government.
- throwaway2048 8y agoNews organizations are under no (legal) obligation to not be biased. Bias does not make wikileaks not a news organization.
- boomboomsubban 8y agoAgain, nothing suggesting they are knowingly working with the Russians. Wikileaks quality has surely dropped. They are still the press, and any prosecution by the US will be over things like the Manning links, a direct attack on the freedom of the press.
- foldr 8y ago>Again, nothing suggesting they are knowingly working with the Russians. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/World_Tomorrow https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/World_Tomorrow
- boomboomsubban 8y agoOK, there is evidence that Assange sold the broadcast rights of a show to a Russian controlled news organization. Do you think that Jesse Ventura should also be prosecuted?
- foldr 8y agoI don't think Assange should be prosecuted for appearing on Russian state TV. (Does anyone?) While it may be technically true to say that he "sold the rights" to Russia Today, that's arguably a little misleading, as the show first aired on RT, and RT had exclusive initial rights to it.
- boomboomsubban 8y ago>I don't think Assange should be prosecuted for appearing on Russian state TV. (Does anyone? People use his television show to claim he's a paid operative of Russia. The same narrative can be made of Ventura, and any reason Assange should be prosecuted but not Ventura seems sketchy. >While it may be technically true to say that he "sold the rights" to Russia Today, that's arguably a little misleading, as the show first aired on RT, and RT had exclusive initial rights to it. They bought the initial rights in several languages, not exclusive, but he did not make the show for RT. That's a fairly clear distinction.
- stale2002 8y ago> They are a black box repository for leaked data Or said another way, they act as a news organization. Modern day news organizations unfortunately have zero integrity and are unwilling to take on the people with power.
- monocasa 8y agoWas Ellsberg a terrible reporter since he managed to get the entirety of the Pentagon Papers (~4k pages) publicly released?
- Heyokamerican 8y agoHe wasn't a reporter at all; he leaked the Pentagon Papers to the NY Times (among others) which then published articles and excerpts.
- krapp 8y agoWikileaks didn't cover the election. Wikileaks released private emails with the intent of damaging one specific candidate. >and it's hard to argue the Clinton emails weren't newsworthy. That the emails were released was newsworthy, but I would argue that nothing in the emails themselves was particularly newsworthy.
- boomboomsubban 8y agoThe emails were newsworthy, disliking what you consider their ulterior motive doesn't change that.
- krapp 8y agoWhat emails, specifically, were newsworthy?
- nailer 8y agoThe ones where it was revealed the Clinton campaign was running the DNC and Sanders never stood a chance. Whether your support that or not I don't think anyone disputes that this was revealed by Wikileaks
- rspeer 8y agoThe pushing of this message by Wikileaks and the Kremlin was quite a feat of propaganda, and you can tell the propaganda was well done because they made its believers believe that everyone else believed it too. Even now that the source has been revealed. Sanders lost the primary all on his own, and you didn't need "leaks" to reveal this, just polls. Conspiring to make Sanders lose is like conspiring to make water wet.
- hackinthebochs 8y agoPlenty of people dispute this narrative, myself included. The DNC never took any action against the Sanders campaign, despite some disgruntled emails by some DNC staffers venting about Sanders.
- shostack 8y ago> "This is untrue. There is nothing suggesting that Wikileaks has knowingly coordinated with Russia." Really? Nothing at all? Big fat nothingburger? https://www.newyorker.com/news/news-desk/what-the-latest-mueller-indictment-reveals-about-wikileaks-ties-to-russia-and-what-it-doesnt https://www.newyorker.com/news/news-desk/what-the-latest-mue...
- boomboomsubban 8y agoAn indictment is not proof for a start, this is a fundamental part of the US justice system. That indictment does not actually mention Wikileaks at all, let alone suggest that Wikileaks knew the source was the Russian government.
- elliekelly 8y ago>That indictment does not actually mention Wikileaks at all If you read the indictment it's pretty clear that "Organization 1" is Wikileaks.
- boomboomsubban 8y agoIf they are "Organization 1," which yeah they almost certainly are, they are called that as they are not even being accused of a crime. Everything in the indictments could be true and you still haven't shown that Wikileaks knowingly coordinated with the Russia.
- kjksf 8y agoCan we agree that an indictment is much more than "nothing" and indicate a strong belief on the part of prosecution that they have a winnable case? Your reading of the indictment (https://d3i6fh83elv35t.cloudfront.net/static/2018/07/Muellerindictment.pdf https://d3i6fh83elv35t.cloudfront.net/static/2018/07/Mueller...) is severely lacking. It specifically mentions that 12 russians conspired "with persons known and unknown to the Grand Jury" to "stage releases of the stolen documents to interfere with the 2016 US election". You don't have to be a genius to infer that one of those "persons known and unknown to the Grand Jury" is Assange.
- munk-a 8y agoI don't believe they are a news organization, but they are something very similar that should be protected with the same freedoms. Their contributions during 2016 were highly biased but they released information that wasn't false, while it isn't wrong to call them partisan they still provided a valuable service. If they had received the emails, discovered they were forged and then released them anyways, then I think there'd be a different story. News outlets need to provide true information, they can be opinionated if they are open about it but blatantly lying (i.e. National Enquirer) is the only thing I think is objectionable.
- tdcbfdct3 8y agoI know that's Assange's line, but that's basically just how all TV is made. Nobody would claim Saturday Night Live isn't an NBC show because it's actually produced by Broadway Video. RT's logo has a producer's credit in his show's credits. It's an RT show. Wikileaks isn't a news organization. They don't do reporting. They are a publisher, which still has first amendment protections.