3 ms·
> It's understandable to not mention this I feel like the very first word, "Estimating" made what you're talking about pretty clear. It's extremely common for
by dahart 8y ago
> It's understandable to not mention this
I feel like the very first word, "Estimating" made what you're talking about pretty clear. It's extremely common for estimates to make simplifying assumptions that don't necessarily hold if you care about accuracy or specific situations. He also called the rule of three "quick and dirty".
> If you were to randomly read 20 pages in a book and find no typos, 15% probability makes more sense.
OTOH, if typos are actually uniformly distributed, then reading the first 20 is better than a random 20 unless you take care to pick random pages without repeats.
- mark-r 8y agoInteresting that you would worry about repeats. Most people would interpret "randomly read 20 pages" as "choose 20 from n" not "take 20 rand(n)".
- dahart 8y agoYou're right, and mathematicians and computer scientists aren't most people. We are being pedantic / precise here. If someone wants to caution that people need to be really careful about estimates because there are some assumptions involved, then it's fair to hold them to their own standard, isn't it? If typos are uniform, then the suggestion to read random pages doesn't help. And whether or not people interpret it one way most of the time, if you interpret "random" like a programmer, you've introduced a small amount of bias, right?
- mark-r 8y agoAs a programmer it still never would have occurred to me to interpret it that way, but maybe I'm not typical. If your random library doesn't have a choose function, it's easy enough to just shuffle a list and take the first 20.