4 ms·
>You may be surprised to learn that Everest is not the tallest mountain on Earth, either. That honor belongs to Mauna Kea, a volcano on the Big Island of Hawaii
by SilasX 8y ago
>You may be surprised to learn that Everest is not the tallest mountain on Earth, either. That honor belongs to Mauna Kea, a volcano on the Big Island of Hawaii. Mauna Kea originates deep beneath the Pacific Ocean, and rises more than 33,500 feet from base to peak.
Can someone explain this? How do you differentiate "the mountain" from "the rest of the earth that it comes out of"?
(Side note: the issue of "tallest mountain", as discussed here, is a great example of dealing with an ambiguous concept and clarifying it by asking what you're trying to do with the answer.)
- magduf 8y agoWhen comparing the actual height of a mountain, they're measured from their base (which is whatever elevation the ground they sit on is) to their peak, rather than just looking at their peak altitude. This is how you compare mountains on other planets, and why Mons Olympus on Mars is the tallest mountain in the solar system. For Mauna Kea, the mountain is taller than it looks because its base sits at the bottom of the ocean, whereas Everest sits on an already-lofty piece of continental plate.
- SilasX 8y agoRight, I got that much. I'm asking, how do you rigorously distinguish "the base" from the rest of the earth (or that earth from the mountain itself)? Edit: IOW, if Kea's base were on some raised ocean floor, when do you count that as part of Kea too?
- gpm 8y agoWhy is "height from the solid matter base" more correct than "height from the non-gaseous matter base" though. From the perspective of humans, who generally live at the border of gaseous matter not the border of solid matter, I think the latter might make more sense.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- Nition 8y agoI get the impression that the asker knows that but that their question is more like, is there any official way to define where the mountain starts? Could we keep tracking the side of Everest right down into a far-off ocean trench and say it's now the tallest again, it's just also really wide? I guess you're looking for obvious local minima. If the land slopes back up a lot or stays mostly flat for a long time it's probably not part of the mountain anymore. Would a smaller mountain in the middle of Uluru be measured starting from ground level at the top of Uluru? Edit: Asker has now confirmed in a separate comment that this is what they meant.
- SilasX 8y agoI like your clarification better though!
- whoopdedo 8y agoMy definition would involve some definition of geological homogeny such that you could classify the terrain as mountain and not-mountain. Probably based on whether it was involved in the process that formed the mountain.
- SilasX 8y agoYeah, that was what I was hoping/expecting the definition would use, that mountains come from some plate interaction involving lava which would provide a natural boundary between "mountain" and "rest of earth".
- magduf 8y agoI think a lot of mountains don't involve lava at all, they're just the product of continental plates running into each other. I'm pretty sure Everest is an example of this. Hawaii is the opposite; those mountains don't involve plates at all, they're solely the product of lava.
- carleverett 8y agoI had to look this up, but apparently "sea level" on Mars (called "topographic datum") is decided using the average elevation near the equator. http://passporttoknowledge.com/lfm/ask/terrain-geo/Determining_0_DATUM_or_Sea_Level_on_Mars.txt http://passporttoknowledge.com/lfm/ask/terrain-geo/Determini...
- mc32 8y agoRight, basically, in a different context accrding to this principle volcanoes at higher altitudes (say close to andes but not in the andes proper) are not as tall as more coastal/lower altitude volcanoes, if the cone’s rise isn't as high.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- rnnr 8y agoIt's wet :) (under water surface) The claim of the article that mount Everest is the tallest point from the earth's center happens because earth's surface, relative to its size, is as smooth as a billiard ball. Even the tallest mountains are nothing. So high mountains located at the equator can easily "outperform" higher mountains elsewhere.
- OscarCunningham 8y agoApparently it's not quite as smooth as a billiard ball. More like very fine sandpaper. https://skeptics.stackexchange.com/questions/10763/is-earth-as-smooth-as-a-billiard-ball https://skeptics.stackexchange.com/questions/10763/is-earth-...
- jake-low 8y agoThe article is likely referring to the estimated dry prominence of Mauna Kea. Topographic prominence [1] measures the height of a peak relative to its lowest surrounding contour line (that doesn't also contain another, taller peak). Usually the ocean's surface is considered "flat ground" when computing this measure (called a "wet prominence"), but one can alternatively imagine the Earth to have no water, and compute a "dry prominence" that permits the lowest surrounding contour line to be below sea level. [1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Topographic_prominence https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Topographic_prominence The above Wikipedia article specifically mentions the dry prominence of Mauna Kea, estimating it to be 9330m which is taller than Everest's conventional height of 8848m. However, an apples-to-apples comparison would use the dry prominence of Everest too, which is the distance from the bottom of the Challenger Deep (-10,911m) to the summit. This would make Mauna Kea the second tallest mountain by topographic prominence if the Earth had no oceans.
- wallace_f 8y ago>However, an apples-to-apples comparison would use the dry prominence of Everest too, which is the distance from the bottom of the Challenger Deep (-10,911m) to the summit. This would make Mauna Kea the second tallest mountain by topographic prominence if the Earth had no oceans What? This does not make sense, if I am not mistaken? Topographic prominence would place Mauna Kea as the tallest (highest peak from base contour line), but it would certainly not be the second highest above the Challenger Deep... And the Challenger Deep is not the base contour line of any mountain..?
- jake-low 8y agoThink about it this way: imagine standing at the bottom of the Challenger Deep. Draw a small circle around yourself on the ocean floor. Now step outside the circle. Because you're standing on a spherical object (Earth), the area outside your circle isn't infinite like it would be on a plane. It's another finite region, which covers almost the entire Earth, and contains both yourself (standing just beside the lowest point of the Challenger Deep) and also the peak of Mount Everest. Therefore the circle is a base contour line for Everest, and Everest's wet prominence can be measured from the circle. However, this same contour line cannot be used for the wet prominence measure of Mauna Kea, since it contains every mountain on Earth, many of which are taller. Mauna Kea's lowest contour line that doesn't contain another taller mountain would probably enclose a sizeable portion of the floor of the Pacific Ocean, but wouldn't include the Andes, Japan, or the Sierra Nevada, since those peaks are taller. The contour line would therefore be deep below the ocean surface, but not as deep as the Challenger Deep.
- ashtonbaker 8y agoYeah that has always seemed a bit jumbled to me. It's not clear to me why that point, 33,500 feet below the peak of Mauna Kea, is appropriate to use as a basis of measurement for the mountain. And why not a lower point? And why can that point not be used to measure the height of Mount Everest as well? Anyway, I think what you're asking can usually be described by the concept of Topographic Prominence[1], one definition of which is "the height of the peak’s summit above the lowest contour line encircling it but containing no higher summit" [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Topographic_prominence https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Topographic_prominence