3 ms·
(Source: am a university professor) Do you live near a research university, which employs anyone working in aerospace engineering and/or fluid dynamics? Altern
by impendia 8y ago
(Source: am a university professor)
Do you live near a research university, which employs anyone working in aerospace engineering and/or fluid dynamics? Alternatively, do you ever have the occasion to visit your old university?
I'd try to set up some meetings with professors. Say that you've been working independently, based on questions that were bugging you in your undergrad days, and you'd be extremely grateful if you could discuss your work with them (at their convenience).
Resist the temptation to oversell your work. It sounds like you're claiming to understand drag better than an entire community of experts, who devote their careers to studying it. That is an extraordinarily difficult sell. If you make such a claim, whether in person or in a paper, then your conclusions are likely to be immediately dismissed -- especially at the first sign of any mistake.
Just say you have an alternative theory, and would be grateful to get the chance to discuss it (and have it critiqued) with an established expert. If you make a positive impression, then they will encourage you to publish your results, and will be happy to give you practical advice for doing so.
As a professor, I'd disagree with Nomentatus's suggestion that you should try to "offer to help professors in the area". Accepting help usually creates more effort (for them) than it saves.
It's okay to simply cold-email professors whom you don't know and ask if you could meet them. Be prepared for them to say no, or for them to not reply at all. If they do say yes, don't go in trying to establish a "relationship". The most likely outcome is that they'll say "Oh, that's interesting, you should read X, Y, and Z." Take notes, and -- if you're serious about this -- read X, Y, and Z before you request a second meeting.
In the meantime, make sure you understand why "most people believe drag is simply not possible in inviscid / incompressible flow". If you thoroughly understand the potential objections to your theory, then you might have a shot at convincing someone.
Here is a blog post, which outlines some of the hurdles you could potentially face.
http://blogs.discovermagazine.com/cosmicvariance/2007/06/19/the-alternative-science-respectability-checklist/#.W-1bBuhKjb0 http://blogs.discovermagazine.com/cosmicvariance/2007/06/19/...
In the long run, if your theory is correct, I believe you have good odds of getting it accepted. Good luck!
- lordvon 8y agoThanks for the great advice! My first thought was reaching out to former professors by email (can't visit in person), but I wanted to see if there was a more appropriate way, like an online pre-print vetting community or something. I will definitely tone-down my description of the current state of drag prediction; definitely don't want to offend or be considered a crackpot before anyone even looking at my derivation and results.
- impendia 8y agoThe arXiv does serve as an online preprint vetting community, and it would provide you a venue in which to publicly disseminate your work. (You might need either a university-affiliated email or an endorsement, though -- not sure exactly.) But it's not really a good place to attract attention. Dozens of papers are published there every day, and the more unconventional ones tend to get ignored (unless they're authored by people who are already famous). Another thing you might do is attend a scientific conference. If possible, see if there's some small, not-terribly-prestigious conference in a related subject, somewhere within driving distance. In my subject, number theory, these are quite common; they're typically held over weekends and are largely designed to give graduate students a venue in which to speak. Book a hotel, go to all the talks, ask questions. If you strike up conversations with people, you might can ask if you can run your theory by them.
- lordvon 8y agoI took a look at registering for arXiv, and since I am not currently affiliated with a University it seems like I wasn't able to proceed. And then there is the question of whether it is beneficial for me, like you said. I would love to go to conferences, though it might be expensive for the ultimate aim of getting professional second opinions. Will look into it!
- itronitron 8y agooffending an academic is often a sign that you are on to something significant :)