5 ms·
I was listening to a great podcast about this. They said they asked owners of businesses, "If you're having trouble hiring, why don't you offer more money?".
by jedberg 8y ago
I was listening to a great podcast about this. They said they asked owners of businesses, "If you're having trouble hiring, why don't you offer more money?". Their response was all a variation on, "because then I'd have to pay all my other workers more when they found out, and it's cheaper to just pay the current folks overtime at their lower rate than give everyone a raise".
- danieltillett 8y agoThis can only go on so long before they have to raise pay.
- minikites 8y agoWages have stagnated since the 1970s, so "they" definitely don't have to raise pay: https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/thumb/7/73/US_productivity_and_real_wages.jpg/800px-US_productivity_and_real_wages.jpg https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/thumb/7/73/US...
- danieltillett 8y agoNot if unemployment is back to 1960s levels. I suspect you are right in that the Fed will kill any general wage rises.
- faceplanted 8y agoAnd in the meantime everyone is underpaid and the owner is stressed because he can't hire people.
- danieltillett 8y agoSuch is life when caught in a vicious circle.
- breitling 8y agoDo you remember what podcast this was? Sounds like something planet money would do.
- jedberg 8y agoI believe it was The Indicator (by Planet Money)
- graeme 8y agoThis is the crux of the issue. Let's take a staff of 100, at salary level 100. Total wage cost is 10000. The owner wants a 10% increase in labour. How much will it cost? Let's assume they can only find new labour at 110, but if they pay this they must pay existing labour 110 as well. 110 * 110 = 12100. A 21% salary increase for a 10% labour increase. Also it probably won't be a straight 10% labour increase, as some % will have to go to admin and the organizational costs associated with size. So, that's why. It's also potentially zero sum, as if one employer raises wages, then others will follow, and there may not be a 10% gain in employees. Just increased costs all around. (There will be some gain in employees of course, as workers are pulled in from less efficient sectors)
- choicenotchance 8y agoYou probably meant 101x110 =11,110
- pdimitar 8y agoThere are people who would work for the companies but not at their current wage levels. Increase the pay and the pool increases as well.
- graeme 8y agoThat was explicit in my post. You increase the labour pool by increasing wages. But when supply is constrained, you get a less than linear increase in output per unit of wage increase.
- mattm 8y agoOTOH it means they've been skimping on raises (not keeping pace with the market) and now it's come back to bite them.
- DanTheManPR 8y agoUnder normal market conditions, they would hemorrhage current employees to any alternative local employers who raise their wages. But if all local business owners are freezing their wages while unemployment is low, then the liquidity of the workforce freezes, and you get into a weird equilibrium. Workers might want to leave, but there's no alternative that improves their compensation. Businesses are engaged in a natural cartel behavior, but where the incentives to cheat are reversed - the first to raise wages hurts themselves the most.
- Lapsed 8y agoWouldn't the first to raise wages get the pick of employees?
- digitaltrees 8y agoAnyone remember when Steve Jobs and other tech leaders were caught making secret agreements to prevent employees from moving?
- robben1234 8y agoI've seen this in my hometown in Ukraine. It has ~20 outsource companies in different sectors and if you're good at doing what you're doing and kind of swapping jobs, there's still a ceiling they wouldn't want to break for you despite usually being paid by US citizens for their services. It's easy for companies to get new trainees and juniors as city has 2 universities with CS courses and everyone seems to want to work in IT. Most of folks who want bigger salary either move to a city with product companies (Kyiv, Odessa, Lviv, Kharkiv, etc), so there's natural competition and outsource rise their salaries too, or go remote.
- idontpost 8y ago> It's easy for companies to get new trainees and juniors as city has 2 universities with CS courses and everyone seems to want to work in IT. If its easy for them to hire, then it's not the same situation at all.