3 ms·
the productivity in the US has been stagnating/decreasing for more than a decade already. Tight labor market requires to pay more to employees which in turn req
by trhway 8y ago
the productivity in the US has been stagnating/decreasing for more than a decade already. Tight labor market requires to pay more to employees which in turn requires the businesses to increase productivity and efficiency - i.e. the more expensive the labor the less waste of that labor can the business afford. Add to that the tax cuts which automatically made the employees even more expensive (actual cost of employee = cost paid - tax on profit, i.e. $100 employee salary comes down to just $70 in actual cost with 30% profit tax rate whereis it is $80 with 20% profit tax rate). Even more automation/computerization/robotization/etc. to come.
- daveFNbuck 8y agoHow does giving companies more money automatically make employees more expensive? That's extremely counter-intuitive.
- dragonwriter 8y ago> How does giving companies more money automatically make employees more expensive? Giving companies more money by itself (e.g., “here, have $100,000 no strings attached”) doesn't. OTOH, taxing retained profits at a lower rate does (it increases the after-tax cost of any reduction in before-tax retained profits; any expense is, considered on its own, a reduction in before-tax retained profits.) In exactly the way deductibility of charitable donations subsidizes such donations at the taxpayers marginal tax rate deductibility of business expenses subsidizes such expenses at the businesses marginal tax rate, and cutting the tax rate cuts the subsidy.
- daveFNbuck 8y agoI think I get what you're saying. The savings from not paying the employee are increased when the profits are taxed less. This makes sense if the employee is a net negative on pre-tax profit. If having the employee increases pre-tax profit, wouldn't lower taxes on profits make them effectively cheaper?
- trhway 8y ago>If having the employee increases pre-tax profit, wouldn't lower taxes on profits make them effectively cheaper? in a situation of rigid linear connection between expenses and revenues - i.e. when adding additional work units immediately and proportionally increases your revenue. In real life there is usually elasticity between expenses and revenues - while increasing/decreasing expenses has immediate direct effect on the bottom line there is no such effect on the top line. The situation is even worse when you need to hire or do capital investment today (and thus take the hit today) while the related revenue increase would come only some years down the road.
- daveFNbuck 8y agoSo this is part of a more general effect where low taxes on profits deter investment? It makes a little more sense to me phrased that way. You don't need to worry about increasing your future profits as much when they're higher now.
- usrusr 8y agoIt's intuitive iff you believe that paying taxes on profits is worse than not even having any profits to tax. (I don't share that belief)
- trhway 8y agowhatever one's beliefs are, it is very intuitive to everybody what is going to happen to charitable contributions if the tax deduction is removed. In accounting grand scheme of things employee salaries, materials, depreciation of capital assets, etc is just the same thing as charitable contributions - just deductions.
- usrusr 8y agoThat would only be a meaningful comparison if we were talking about wether or not money a business doesn't have because it was spent on wages should nonetheless be counted as taxable earnings.
- trhway 8y ago>money a business doesn't have because it was spent on wages should nonetheless be counted as taxable earnings. that is exactly how it works. All business revenue is counted as taxable earnings unless that amount is reduced by deductions. Money spent on wages is just a such a deduction. Charitable contributions is just another such a deduction. No difference.
- usrusr 8y agoAnd that's the point, nobody is challenging that, for good reason. Changing the deductibility of charitable contributions would be just like that, a redefinition of the tax base. The tax base is orthogonal to the tax rate, which is why decreasing the corporate tax rate does not make employees more expensive. (well, occasionally the idea of gross revenue taxation sparks up, but I have not seem that anywhere in this discussion, and it never survives the first mentioning of vertical integration anyways)
- rebuilder 8y agoDon't know why you're getting downvoted. This is a problem all wealthy countries face. As GDP increases, you have to pay workers more or they will find more profitable work, as is being suggested in the article. That, or a lot of workers must not be allowed to reap the benefits of economic growth, and that will be tremendously destablilizing. The problem is, growing wages make domestic production less and less competitive with foreign production. So wealthy countries import goods from places with lower production costs. So, as wealth increases, if you're trying to maintain any semblance of income equality, anything requiring human labour must increasingly get outsourced to cheaper countries. Wealthy countries can only competitively produce high-value goods and services that require e.g. massive capital investments and high levels of technical skill and education. It follows that wealthy countries will eventually face a labour crisis: They have, as a historical leftover, a large class of labourers who no longer have employable skills, and can't even theoretically be re-trained into more current working roles, as there simply aren't enough of those to go around. "Productivity increase" is just another way of saying "more unemployment". I'd like to propose a kind of trilemma here: High median wage, High employment, large population - Pick two. Having all of these can not be sustained IMO, and I think the current political upheavals in the west largely stem from this. You either have tremendous income inequality among workers, you have a large unemployed class, or you have a population consisting largely of highly-skilled specialists.
- nicoburns 8y agoThis is precisely the problem that a basic income would solve...
- rebuilder 8y agoYes, it's the problem a basic income proposes to solve. I'm intrigued by the idea, but I do wonder about the long-term economic effects of it. It seems to me that at it's core, basic income would involve a transfer of wealth from companies and wage-earners to the unemployable. Isn't that just looking at the issues I described and going "oh well"? It doesn't seem to solve the competitivity problem. Optimistically, basic income might enable enough workers to re-educate themselves into new roles that the result would be a net positive, but apart from that, I'm not really seeing how it changes the big picture.
- mooreds 8y ago> the productivity in the US has been stagnating/decreasing for more than a decade already. Here's a chart which shows this statement is incorrect: https://www.bls.gov/lpc/prodybar.htm https://www.bls.gov/lpc/prodybar.htm Now, productivity growth has slowed down, but it hasn't decreased. 1%/year may or may not be stagnation.