5 ms·
Let's be clear, the free market this is not. It's yet another perfect example of government gone wild. It's one thing for to use taxpayer monies to create jobs
by chiefalchemist 8y ago
Let's be clear, the free market this is not.
It's yet another perfect example of government gone wild. It's one thing for to use taxpayer monies to create jobs and job opportunity (i.e., education). That's a reasonable expectation within the scope of gov's governing.
However, it's another thing for gov to buy jobs - and thus votes - by effectively subsidizing some mega-corporation. If Amazon needs money, that's what Wall Street is for. If Wall Street isn't willing to give Amazon et al money then that's a red flag and taxpayers should naturally stand clear.
Some might say, "But without such things Amazon would have to raise prices, and that's not good for consumers." But it's the consumers that paid the __higher__ taxes to supply the subsidy. The difference is, with the latter method the gov gets to skim some off the top.
Bottom line: The taxpayer / consumer loses. Politicians and Big Inc win.
- NoblePublius 8y agoLiterally the opposite. The tax gains out number the tax breaks 3 to 1. Each one of these $150k jobs will net NY state $13.8k of income tax per year and (at least) $2500 of sales tax. The tax break per job is $4800 per year (the $48k figure you may have seen is over ten years).
- peteretep 8y agoPlus the construction spend + attracting tech people et al
- ajeet_dhaliwal 8y agoStill not free market though.
- endtime 8y agoHow is not free market for polities to compete for attractive employers?
- airstrike 8y agoBecause only one company is benefiting from these tax breaks.
- chiefalchemist 8y agoYup. You can't tilt the board and say it was "fair". If a given community put out a RFP / RFQ that said, "Here are our assets. Here are something things we might be able and willing to offer...Which of you are interested in coming here?" Perhaps not free market, but certainly closer to fair and less corrupt.
- endtime 8y agoI think you might be viewing it backwards. In this case, Amazon is the only one selling but lots of places were buying.
- dwaltrip 8y agoApplication of tax policy does not seem like a "market" that local governments should "compete" in. I understand this does happen internationally, between nations. Not that it is a good thing, but seems very difficult to stop. However, at first glance, it seems absurd to me to allow this to occur within a single nation, between the different sub-localities. How does this benefit the US as a whole?
- nerdponx 8y agoThat's fair, but how much of that will go towards compensating people who will be driven out of north/west Queens and north Brooklyn as a result of rising rents?
- harryh 8y agoJust let people build more housing so rents don't rise.
- nerdponx 8y agoHousing is going up like crazy in New York, it's just not affordable.
- harryh 8y agoThat's because the city doesn't let people build enough new supply. THAT'S REALLY BAD. And it's the fault of city government, not Amazon or any other company.
- chiefalchemist 8y agoActually, my understanding is there is a fairly significant amount of housing (pretty much everywhere?) that for one reason or another is kept off the market. (Likely due to some other gov policy? Maybe?) That is, there is capacity but supply is being held back.
- harryh 8y agoYour understanding is wrong. Residential vacancy rates are tiny in most big cities. In the few exceptions (like Seattle for example) where they aren't tiny due to new supply: surprise! rents are dropping.
- chiefalchemist 8y agoLink please. But yes, of the housing available in the market, tiny. But there's plenty of housing held off the market.
- lallysingh 8y agoAre these software jobs? I don't know if they'll be attracting more people in such a tight labor market, or just bumping up rates for those who already here. There's plenty of unfulfilled demand for software engineers in NY, what does Amazon offer to add to supply?
- vonmoltke 8y ago> There's plenty of unfulfilled demand for software engineers in NY, what does Amazon offer to add to supply? You wouldn't know that from the pickiness of some companies around here.
- seattle_spring 8y agoI think GP meant good software engineers.
- vonmoltke 8y agoThe definition of "good" is where the pickiness comes in.
- komali2 8y agoI recently spent half an interview being asked about embedded systems and C for a frontend JavaScript position. If the question is "do companies, in general, know what software engineer they need for a position?" my answer is almost universally no.
- chiefalchemist 8y agoGains? From more road repair? Higher housing costs (read: more welfare state). Other services? Etc. Etc. Etc. You're making it sound like there's only upside. Regardless, the gov should not be in the job buying biz. My gawd, they struggle to govern, and that's their job. Pockets are being lined - once again - at the expense of the tax payers. "Each one of these $150k jobs..." Pardon me, I know this type of reply is frowned upon on HN, but...wanna buy a bridge?
- kodablah 8y ago> Regardless, the gov should not be in the job buying biz Says you. I think they do a better job buying that biz than many of the other biz's they buy with public funds. If you want to see pockets being lined, look to things that don't have returns on investment or are poorly managed in real corrupt ways (ala many public pension plans). Not comparing dollar spent to dollar spent of tax money compared to benefits makes it clear some are just anti-private-sector. > "Each one of these $150k jobs..." Pardon me, I know this type of reply is frowned upon on HN, but...wanna buy a bridge? Are you implying that the average salary to get the incentives isn't going to be 150k/yr as stated their agreement?
- chiefalchemist 8y agoThe gov's job is to govern. Period. How about we let it get that right before it starts branching off into things it's has little or no expertise in. Again. The gov created the housing bubble __and__ the student loan bubble. I don't say they should be in the job buying biz. __The Gov__ has said that. Whether you're listening or not is up to you.
- kodablah 8y ago> The gov created the housing bubble __and__ the student loan bubble. I don't say they should be in the job buying biz. More specifically, you should believe based on your examples that they shouldn't be in the money management business. Because they are really bad at it. I can definitely sympathize with those applauding them for taking less as a way to promote growth.
- liquidmetalll 8y agoExcept NY state won't gain any income tax from people who fill these jobs but live out of state (NJ or CT). If you've ever worked in NYC, you know that this will be a non-trivial proportion of people. Factoring that into account, it's not clear at all that NY state will see a positive return on this.
- jopsen 8y agoIt's still a race to the bottom. Attracting businesses with tax-exempts is a zero-sum game. In the EU we have rules against things like this. As it's considered anti-competitive behavior.
- airstrike 8y ago> Attracting businesses with tax-exempts is a zero-sum game. That's not a foregone conclusion.
- bb1234 8y agoI believe you mean to say prisoner's dilemma, rather than a zero sum game.
- NoblePublius 8y agoIreland gets away with it fine
- conanbatt 8y agoThe tax gains would always outnumber the tax cost for any business, which is why the city government is favoring corporate over small business, that employ way more people for a lot less monopoly rents.
- chiefalchemist 8y agoMaybe not: https://www.citylab.com/equity/2018/11/property-tax-dark-store-theory-retail-apocalypse-walmart/574123/ https://www.citylab.com/equity/2018/11/property-tax-dark-sto...
- kodablah 8y agoDisagree. The freedom for a community to spend funds in ways they want is much more free than the opposite. Also disagree with your bottom line. In many cases (e.g. ones where abatements were given in my community) it lowered the tax rate over time.
- chiefalchemist 8y ago> "The freedom for a community..." If this was a community decision why is there pushback in LIC? Because, it wasn't a community decision. It was the gov using taxpayer money to subsidize one of the largest most successful companies in the world. Fact: The Gov created the housing bubble. Fact: The Gov created the student loan bubble. Fact: The abatements in __your__ community came out of someone else's pocket. That money had to come from somewhere.
- kodablah 8y agoIgnoring the other facts as guff, this is a common misunderstanding: > The abatements in __your__ community came out of someone else's pocket. That money had to come from somewhere. Abatements are not gifts, they are reductions. The money that was not taken did not have to come from anywhere. The reductions did not amount to a negative total (not even close in my case), and therefore the abatements essentially amount to a sale price, not below cost. In other cases, such as sports teams, the benefits of the trade-offs are not as easily recognized because they are not purely financial. But here, it is simpler to understand the bulk discounts in exchange for economic growth.
- chiefalchemist 8y ago> "Abatements are not gifts, they are reductions." Yes. But you make it sounds like the gov services being provided was also reduced. Is that the case? If not, then that means the services being provided still have to be paid for. So if it's not your community, then where do you think that money is coming from?
- 8y ago
- anigbrowl 8y agoIt's yet another perfect example of government gone wild. I like how you tacitly acknowledge the large corporate entity shares a little responsibility in there at the end. Yes, this is a government failure but it is also the logic of capitalism at work, which says that money should come before all other considerations. Government is rather corrupt, but it is business that has corrupted it.
- newsf 8y ago> Yes, this is a government failure but it is also the logic of capitalism at work, which says that money should come before all other considerations. It does? I'm pretty sure it's just a system of allocating resources.
- ConcernedCoder 8y agoWisconsin spends 4 billion in tax breaks to attract a Taiwanese manufacturer ( FoxConn ) and nobody bats an eye...
- outside1234 8y agoOh, believe me, eyes were batted there too. You might notice that state went blue.
- chiefalchemist 8y agoEyes were batted. Let's also note that FoxConn is not Amazon. Also, NYC doesn't really have a problem attracting employers - especially not one who is likely to crush their local economy one same day deliver at a time. Your point is valid. But the scale and precedent of this latest "deal" is more questionable.