4 ms·
The next wave of medical advancement may require us to give up some privacy. It has worked in the past. Once upon a time childhood cancer was a death sentence
by sandworm101 8y ago
The next wave of medical advancement may require us to give up some privacy. It has worked in the past.
Once upon a time childhood cancer was a death sentence. Cancer in young kids moves very fast. Doctors in the 50s/60s did their best but studied the problem as individuals, writing and presenting papers based on patients at their hospitals. But nobody had enough data to discover the incremental improvements. Then docs started getting together and adding patients from multiple hospitals into larger and larger studies. From this larger pool of patients came trends and treatment advice that, today, means childhood cancer is largely survivable. (It is still horrible, but today many childhood cancers are very treatable.) That movement required patient data leave the hands of their individual doctors. Today EVERY kid with cancer is part of multiple studies and it is normal for their information to be shared far and wide. AI may be the next great thing, but it needs data. It may be necessary for patients to again give up a little privacy to enable progress.
- bognition 8y agoThere's a problem with your reasoning here. Most people do not object to the pooling of data for scientific discovery. They object to the pooling of data by company that makes its money by exploiting personal information on individuals.
- FussyZeus 8y ago^ Exactly. I have an app on my phone from my insurance company that tracks my every move. I'm fine with it, because their agreement for it's use specifically says that data is not sold to third parties, nor used in any purpose beyond specifically evaluating my driving. And apparently I'm a pretty safe driver because they give me a fair amount of cash back on it. I would never in a million years let a company like Google or Facebook have that kind of info on me.
- golergka 8y agoWow. I had no idea this exists, but I'm very glad it does.
- sandworm101 8y agoWait until they issue you speeding tickets based on that data. It has happened before (2001) https://tech.slashdot.org/story/01/06/19/187210/rental-car--gps--speeding-ticket https://tech.slashdot.org/story/01/06/19/187210/rental-car--...
- golergka 8y agoI'd be delighted if they made it mandatory. Speeding kills way too many people.
- rocqua 8y agoWe know that driving kills a lot of people. I essentially consider that common knowledge. But it is not 'common knowledge' to me that this is due to speeding. Not that I know different, I'm just surprised to see so definite a statement.
- auslander 8y ago> specifically says that data is not sold to third parties Businesses are for profit. They'll find ways to monetise the data. Wording 'the data' can be bypassed by modifying it, like extracting location heat maps, and selling it instead of raw data. Or/and they may create a service that uses the data and sell it instead.
- Spooky23 8y ago> "their agreement for it's use specifically says that data is not sold to third parties, nor used in any purpose beyond specifically evaluating my driving" Unlikely. The master contract for your insurance company almost certainly allows for information that you provide for a variety of business purposes. Insurance companies pool risk data, and it seems unusual that any negative event would not be shared if captured via this mechanism. Another key thing is to look at the precise wording around "We do not sell your data". That is a weasel-wording that usually means "We will rent your data" or "We will provide your data at no cost to our business partners, for our business purposes".
- sandworm101 8y agoOr, we won't sell/rent "your data" but we certainly sell/rent "our data" collected by the company and not specifically tied to individuals. (Insert long debate about anonymization and/or exactly how few people can be in a pool while still keeping it non-individualized.) It is amazing how many data links can be made with non-PII data points such as vehicle type, color, neighborhood, distance traveled, method of financing ect.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- Spooky23 8y agoI have no problem with data sharing for clinical or research purposes, especially since ethical standards for medical research provide meaningful privacy protection. I do have a problem with insurance organizations and pharmacies abusing data sharing agreements intended for subrogation and similar procedures to manage pharmaceutical sales quotas and conduct outbound marketing. Case in point: My wife was admitted to the hospital due to complications that from what was an early miscarriage. The health insurer sells data that allows an advertiser to surmise that there was a hospital admission to the OB department. The PBM provides anyone paying with information regarding prescriptions before my insurer even gets the claim. Outcome: An advertiser (infant formula company) determines that my wife is likely pregnant and likely to deliver on Month/Day/Year. Guess what arrives on that day? A Fedex care package of formula. That was a very hurtful event for us, and similar violations happen thousands of times every day.
- zaroth 8y agoThere’s a “funny” Target story where a family starts getting ads and coupons for baby products in their Target mailers after the teen daughter becomes pregnant (unbeknownst to the parents). In that case it had nothing to do with mining medical records for advertising purposes. The daughter’s browsing and shopping habits sent a strong enough signal to trigger the ad targeting. I don’t know anything about your case, and am very sorry to hear about your family’s loss. I don’t know if you can draw a line to the insurance company selling you out. But now I’m very curious to learn more about what data insurance companies are allowed to sell, and to whom.
- gowld 8y agoIt may not be the insurance company specifically, but anyone who has been pregnant in the USA can confirm that getting medical care for pregnancy leads to marketing. They even give photography companies access to patients in the delivery ward.
- Spooky23 8y agoI appreciate that. I've posted this a few times on these matters because it was very impactful to us and really sets the stage about the farce of medical privacy. It is my small way of perhaps inspiring a positive outcome from an awful event. I know the insurance companies, hospital and PBM sold pieces of the data because the formula company immediately upon request disclosed the list that they obtained my name from, and identified who had the relevant information by process of elimination. I don't know specifically all of the ways this is done. Basically, claims data is sold, but not diagnosis. There is other context (type of admission, source of claim) that can identify the reason with confidence. (ie. ER admission, hospital admission, claim from OB/gyn) The prescription, can strengthen the assumed condition, and your pharmacy provides that data in near real-time to pharmaceutical companies, brokers and others. That script is tied to the DEA number of the doctor and can be cross-referenced to the admission. The formula company takes that data and mashes against people who have used their coupons in the past.
- ceejayoz 8y ago> Then docs started getting together and adding patients from multiple hospitals into larger and larger studies. It's important to note that these studies are subject to pretty rigorous review by IRBs (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Institutional_review_board https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Institutional_review_board).
- endorphone 8y ago"The next wave of medical advancement may require us to give up some privacy. It has worked in the past" Of course. But companies like Google, Facebook, Amazon, Apple (yes, I'm including Apple), and others should be a mile from that data. Google and Facebook particularly are ill equipped, from a moral and focus perspective, to have anything to do with this industry.