3 ms·
Not providing a key not in your possession is not a crime. If I have a locked container that belongs to my dad, don’t have the key or combo because he is incap
by Spooky23 8y ago
Not providing a key not in your possession is not a crime.
If I have a locked container that belongs to my dad, don’t have the key or combo because he is incapacitated, am I a criminal for not giving the police they key and combo?
The police can have a reasonable suspicion that something is in that box, why should that make me a criminal?
- ams6110 8y agoThe full argument in TFA, however, is the scenario in which it can be proven that you do have a key.
- Spooky23 8y agoThe nuance is that a password is something I know, not something that I have. How can it be proven that I know something at a given point in time? The law enforcement argument is "That is ridiculous, the suspect entered the password 50x a day until we seized the device". (And they are probably correct) But justice is supposed to be about "beyond a reasonable doubt". As a juror, I couldn't convict someone of a crime because he asserted that he does not remember a fact.