3 ms·
"This paper solely addresses the Fifth Amendment framework for compelling acts of decryption by entering passwords without disclosing it to the government. Com
by michaelmrose 8y ago
"This paper solely addresses the Fifth
Amendment framework for compelling acts of decryption by entering passwords without disclosing it to the government. Compelled use of biometrics and compelled disclosure of passwords raise different Fifth Amendment issues."
Are we to believe that typing it in the presence of officers of the court doesn't communicate the password to officers? This seems questionable. I'm sure judges love, technically we are violating your clients rights but as long as officer smith looks over that away we TECHNICALLY wont be.
Further one can argue both having forgotten a password AND the fifth amendment. You can argue that the act of trying to unlock it is testimonial AND that you don't know the password. Prove them wrong.
You could argue that the authorities have presented you with a device that has had the password changed. If they actually do this do they just get to lock you up for however long they feel like?
It's probably true in many cases that you can establish that a device was used by a person, bought by a person, that that person PROBABLY knows the password. This isn't enough for it to be a foregone conclusion.
This reads like complicated wishful thinking designed to relieve the prosecution of the burden of doing intelligent police work.
- appleflaxen 8y ago> You could argue that the authorities have presented you with a device that has had the password changed. If they actually do this do they just get to lock you up for however long they feel like? I am strongly against compelled decryption, but haven't come across this argument before. I think it's a brilliant point.
- nabla9 8y agoArgument that represents unlikely logical possibility rarely wins.
- jamescostian 8y agoExcept when fear comes into play. You might enjoy reading this: https://psychology.stackexchange.com/questions/9200/why-do-people-fear-statistically-unlikely-things https://psychology.stackexchange.com/questions/9200/why-do-p... In this particular case, there is a fear that one could get a severe sentence (e.g. capital punishment) without having even committed a crime, all due to the police changing their password. If a person is afraid enough of that (unlikely) potential outcome, they may ignore statistics all together and follow their fear. For more examples of how much people ignore probability, consider https://money.cnn.com/2017/08/24/news/economy/lottery-spending/index.html https://money.cnn.com/2017/08/24/news/economy/lottery-spendi... and https://www.quora.com/How-much-does-a-casino-make-daily https://www.quora.com/How-much-does-a-casino-make-daily
- nabla9 8y agoHow that fear is supposed to help with court cases? Defendant being fearful does not help his case.
- jamescostian 8y agoI'm not saying people should take the stand and say they're afraid... perhaps we have different interpretations of the quote from appleflaxen that was quoted and that you responded to. Here it is: "You could argue that the authorities have presented you with a device that has had the password changed. If they actually do this do they just get to lock you up for however long they feel like?" I interpreted that quote to be used as potential horror story that could be created by compelled decryption. As such, the fear that story creates could make it used as an argument against compelled decryption ("if a court can compel you to decrypt your files, then $HORROR_STORY is possible! We need to all fight against compelled decryption!"). A good number of people will get behind that argument, even though (as you said) that argument depends on an "unlikely logical possibility". And those people using the fear of that horror story to dislike (and maybe even rally against) compelled decryption is what my point was about.
- nabla9 8y agoI guess I should have mentioned that my comment was about argumentation in the court.
- JoeSmithson 8y agoWhat is the intelligent police work that you think should be done instead of compelling unlocking?
- tristor 8y agoThe same police work that they would have done before the existence of smart phones. As an observer it seems to me as if law enforcement agencies are lazy and believe that investigation of crimes should be simplified by ubiquitous use of technology rather than frustrated. But technology is a tool which serves its master, and as long as users remain the master of their technology it will serve their interested and frustrate other actors. Police investigations don't need to rely on access to this technology and can be pursued through the same methods they have been for centuries.
- JoeSmithson 8y agoYou're avoiding the point - a smartphone is a place where evidence can now exist where it couldn't before. Suppose a child discloses to a teacher that their father raped them and filmed it on his iPhone, specifically what actions would you take as a detective tasked with that case?
- AnthonyMouse 8y agoGet a warrant and set up surveillance. As soon as the surveillance captures the iPhone password, seize it.
- michaelmrose 8y agoFirstly you would do the same thing you would do in the overwhelming number of cases in which they tell their teacher their father raped them and didn't film it on their iphone. In most instances the perpetrator wont have obligingly kept evidence for you. This is something like the scenario in which we defend torture by positing a ticking time bomb scenario. Sure we want to break the terrorists fingers and lock away the pedophile until he brings forth evidence of his evil deeds but that doesn't make it it a good model to arrange our life and laws on. Logically you would secure the child so he couldn't come to harm. Interview him, interview the perp, other family members, other adults who interacted with the child say at school. Have a therapist/psychologist analyze the child's behavior. If you believe you need access to the phone/computer you could seize it while its unlocked, attack their phone, attack their home computer and use it to attack their phone, plant a bug/physically surveil them. In cases where it was vital cops seem to have been able to do this so far. They just wish they could do it more easily.