3 ms·
The precedents on snooping that have served us up to the 1970s are outdated for several reasons. On one hand, it's true that where in the past most people woul
by michaelt 8y ago
The precedents on snooping that have served us up to the 1970s are outdated for several reasons.
On one hand, it's true that where in the past most people would have sent letter and kept physical record books that could be siezed, the modern equivalents are often encrypted.
On the other hand, modern phones don't only contain the letters and records someone in the 1970s would have kept. People have GPS location records, records of things they've read, heart rate monitor records, naked photos of their lovers, and all the credentials needed to empty their bank accounts.
There is also a change in scalability; while in principle monitoring on 0.01% and on 99.99% of the population may be equivalent, in practice a quantitative difference of so many orders of magnitude is quantitatively different. In the 1970s, trailing someone everywhere was so expensive large-scale monitoring was impossible, and rules to keep tabs on the impossible weren't needed. In the modern age, the costs have dropped to a fraction of a penny, but the protections against abuses haven't kept pace.
Achieving a reasonable balance will be difficult.
- FakeComments 8y agoAside from GPS logs, which of those things wouldn’t have been on your desk, when the police raided your home office for papers in the 1970s? The problem is with overly broad warrants, that allow for whole device imaging — though we sometimes see that with real warrants too, which just grab everything.