3 ms·
She has good points. However, when practically implementing this, I could see the "any measure that becomes a target ceases to be a good measure" effect biting
by xg15 8y ago
She has good points. However, when practically implementing this, I could see the "any measure that becomes a target ceases to be a good measure" effect biting back: I imagine many companies would suddenly become very eager to insist that their algorithms are in fact not algorithms at all but "simply computer code" or such - and a lot of hair-splitting will ensue about what exactly is or isn't an algorithm...
(I'm not arguing this shouldn't be done, only that it would be messy)
- mbel 8y agoYeah, the only way I can imagine it working is forcing everyone to open source their code. It doesn't sound very realistic.
- carlmr 8y agoWell you could technically demand the companies show the source to this hypothetical organization. AFAIK the FAA will take a look at the software that runs on planes, and how well you can trace requirements, whether the requirements are tested. Still Boeing and Airbus don't have their code on GitHub.
- mbel 8y agoAlright, I haven't thought about that. Yes, definitely certification is another option.
- carlmr 8y agoDon't get me wrong. I think it's possible, but it would be so costly that you would need to close nearly every software business in the US. Safety critical software costs about 100x as much money/time to develop as compared to non safety critical software. "Algorithms" are everywhere, so certification costs would make any software shop as costly as automotive and aerospace. That's just completely misguided. Countries without such restrictions would take over the global software market quickly.
- denzil_correa 8y ago> I imagine many companies would suddenly become very eager to insist that their algorithms are in fact not algorithms at all but "simply computer code" or such All you need to do is make human(s) accountable for decisions taken. It doesn't matter what is fed as input into the decision making process.
- emiliobumachar 8y agoFun fact: algorithms cannot be patented. Calling an algorithm something else is a very well developed branch of patent application work.