7 ms·
I've been impressed watching them test in the Sunnyvale/Mountain View area (I see them on the road nearly every day, often multiple times a day). Among the sit
by nostrademons 8y ago
I've been impressed watching them test in the Sunnyvale/Mountain View area (I see them on the road nearly every day, often multiple times a day). Among the situations I've seen them handle: bicyclist swerves into the lane in front of them; pedestrian starts crossing the road right as they're about to make a right turn; pedestrian jaywalks in front as they're stopped at a stop sign; boxed in and prevented from making a lane shift on a 3-lane boulevard; avoiding construction on El Camino; stuck behind a bus; U-turn in front of a car edging out to make a right; unable to merge while coming off the highway; unable to merge onto the highway; tailgated and cutoff while on the highway.
It's possible that they were under manual control at the time, but I doubt it. They have a distinctive way of driving while under computer control, which I guess I'd describe as "like a grandma" but basically involves acceleration, braking, and turns that are a bit smoother than any reasonable driver would make them and a top speed that is a bit more law-abiding.
It is California, so it's always sunny (well, smoky right now) and most of these were daylight, but I've encountered them in a lot of different situations and consider them safer than human drivers.
- josh2600 8y agoI watched a driver-intervention near-crash today on 16th street with cruise where the car sped up and swerved into oncoming traffic across a double yellow to avoid a car backing up that was obvious to the human driver. It's only luck that the cruise car didn't end up in a head on collision.
- komali2 8y agoHaha, opposite of my experience. They have failed to navigate the left turn off rengstorf El Camino for the last 2 years (they always stop in the middle of the intersection). A pedestrian on the corner next to a stop sign causes them to pause in the middle of the intersection for an uncomfortable amount of time, to the point where you aren't sure if you should just go around them or what. On my bicycle and motorcycle, I don't trust them at all. I've had them come within inches of me on a turn, without slowing down a bit. Maybe they saw me and executed a highly efficient path avoidance mechanism, no way to tell, all I know is they operate around me in a way that fires all my 'watch out, this motherfucker doesn't see you' alarms while I'm on two wheels. Ok, I'm being mean - it's a miracle they can go at all, let alone not hit people. Today at the aforementioned intersection, at the turn they always fail at, a bicyclist got ran over by a pick-up truck. The waymo SUV slowly pulled up to the intersection while people ran back and forth dragging the bicycle and his groceries and other debris away, and didn't run anyone over. Never stopped slowly creeping towards people, which was weird as hell, but hey. Handled a super odd situation like a champ.
- dougmany 8y ago>pedestrian jaywalks in front as they're stopped at a stop sign; >A pedestrian on the corner next to a stop sign causes them to pause I am struggling to reconcile how the pedestrian does not have the right of way in both these cases.
- toomuchtodo 8y agoWhat action you take depends on what state you're in, and where the pedestrian is. > Pedestrian crossing: 50 state summary > The majority of states, however, only require motorists to yield to, rather than stop for, pedestrians crossing at uncontrolled crosswalks. Nineteen states require a motorist to yield when a pedestrian is upon any portion of the roadway. Louisiana mandates motorist yielding when a pedestrian is upon the same half of the roadway. Nebraska requires yielding when a pedestrian is upon the same half of the roadway or within one lane of the motorist. Massachusetts mandates yielding when a pedestrian is upon the same half of the roadway or within 10 feet of the motorist; and 20 states mandate motorists yield when a pedestrian is upon the same half of the roadway or approaching closely enough from the opposite side of the roadway to constitute a danger. In addition, in at least five states and the District of Columbia, bicyclists have the same or similar rights as pedestrians. http://www.ncsl.org/research/transportation/pedestrian-crossing-50-state-summary.aspx http://www.ncsl.org/research/transportation/pedestrian-cross...
- komali2 8y agoIn my example (standing at corner), they certainly have right of way, whenever they plan on walking. Sometimes they're just hanging out, which is usually obvious to a human, but in a subtle way I can't describe, let alone guess at how to program.
- nostrademons 8y agoIn my example (jaywalker) they stopped and waited for the pedestrian to cross the street. The pause times do seem longer than a human would take (I noticed this with the right-turn with pedestrian case as well), but I'd rather that self-driving cars err on the side of safe rather than sorry.
- fjsolwmv 8y agoDo you mean "smoother than any unreasonable (human) driver"?
- modzu 8y agothose are a lot of specific observations.. u sure u dont work for waymo? lol