2 ms·
The article implies a scientific fallacy, which is that scientific knowledge is binary - i.e. either science can say with certainty that something is true, or i
by TheOtherHobbes 8y ago
The article implies a scientific fallacy, which is that scientific knowledge is binary - i.e. either science can say with certainty that something is true, or it can say with equal certainty that something is false.
This is not how science works. There are decreasing circles of confidence out from the relative certainty of a core curriculum - approximately an undergrad degree in a hard science - to various research topics. At the edges are pure research which is really just educated guessing. Far from being an invincible march towards knowledge, science actually progresses by throwing grad students at problems more or less at random. Some of them get lucky and find some key insights that match reality.
Most don't.
Unfortunately there's plenty of evidence from history of scientific reassurances being presented as certainties which were subsequently shown to be wrong - sometimes dangerously so.
Add the toxic influence of corporate interest and the unarguable reality that fact that some "evidence" is bought and paid for, and it becomes very hard to accept research as the proof science would like it to be.
So it's actually rational to be skeptical of extraordinary claims.
E.g. GMOs. The extraordinary claim is that GMOs will end hunger. Obviously only a total monster would oppose that.
In reality research into other farming techniques also increases yields, and in any case hunger is actually caused by bad politics, not lack of faith in science.
Articles like these conflate the difference between science-as-pure-research for the sake of knowledge, and science-as-policy-justification.
The standards for science-as-policy should be much higher than science-as-research, because the consequences of warping truth for profit or power can be so much more damaging.