4 ms·
Has there ever been a case of a medical device being hacked to do realworld physical harm? Considering the billions that will need to be spent to secure future
by sandworm101 8y ago
Has there ever been a case of a medical device being hacked to do realworld physical harm? Considering the billions that will need to be spent to secure future devices, are there not perhaps other areas of healthcare where the same money could save more lives?
- bdelay 8y agoMy guess is that yes, absolutely, but very few people know about it / a Doctor or nurse was blamed. Medical system security does not seem very good. When I was operating in the area a while back, one comment I kept seeing was similar to yours. "Yes, the security is bad, but the good these devices do outweighs the bad." I agree with that, but my follow-up has always been, why can't these devices continue to help patients, but in a secure way? The manufacturers really don't want to spend the money to try and have some form of a security posture? Rhetorical question. At the end of the day, my pessimistic view is that nothing will happen until some firm finally proves that there has been a high profile attack, there is an ensuing media firestorm, and the regulation process starts happening.
- Nasrudith 8y agoThe problem with them is the same as DRM essentially - you have to keep it accessible to everyone and not accessible at the exact same time. The key management is a nightmare. I believe the best compromise would require forward thinking leadership and design. Make medical devices that must or would be served by communication and control short range by design. Ideally it could be turned off by the patient but close range enough that a doctor can access it while the patient is in no position to assist. The added danger is minimal given that anyone that close who wanted them dead could just murder them in other ways. Have a centralized registry of valid public keys - there are debates about who should have one but that is a whole other topic. The point being that nonrepudiation - an audit trail will be left which means in cases of malfeasance the entity corresponding is the one responsible - either directly or by letting their key get compromised. The practical pain is the logistics of course.
- sandworm101 8y agoBut unlike most modern drm, you have to do it without network access. You cannot even assume the ability to deliver updates.
- sovietmudkipz 8y ago> I agree with that, but my follow-up has always been, why can't these devices continue to help patients, but in a secure way? The manufacturers really don't want to spend the money to try and have some form of a security posture? I speculate the truth is benign; security isn't a top feature for many development shops.
- HillaryBriss 8y ago> why can't these devices continue to help patients, but in a secure way my guess is that they are subject to the usual security vs convenience trade off, that more security means more time and money spent gaining access to the devices for legitimate actors (e.g. nurses) which means some additional patient lives will be damaged or even lost. of course, that may be well justified depending on how much dangerous or malicious hacking there is
- apercu 8y agoMedical device security was pretty decent in 1997 at the company I worked for. Until we ported everything to NT from a variety of *NIX OS's. Then it became non-existent.
- sovietmudkipz 8y agoIt could be possible hackers simply haven't turned their attention to exploiting these devices yet. There is always a time before a vulnerable system gets hacked, and there is always a person doing the hacking. Maybe this article on HN, some tweet, or some other comment on the internet will prompt someone to break into a IOT medical device and cause harm to someone. Who knows when it will happen. That said, I wouldn't understand the rationale behind someone who knowingly hacks a medical system for malicious intent. What honor is there in turning off someone's pacemaker? That just seems like murder but with a technological twist.
- bluGill 8y agoAll nations are interested in the ability to remotely control the pacemaker or the leaders of all other countries. We should assume that Russia, China, and the US are all able to pull it off at will if it is possible. Would they every use this? It is an act of war, and they risk the replacement leader being "worse". However it is something they would like to have. Of course once someone starts using this all medical device makers will have to take security seriously, which enters an arms race. The only protection most people have is we are not important enough to target. However if you are a world leader of some sort you are always at risk that some other country will decide the best way to deal with you is kill you. Vulnerabilities in your medical devices is just one possible choice such nations have. Then again there are lots of other choices for murder. Poison has been used going back thousands of years has the useful property that you can make it look like an ex did it thus avoiding war.
- HillaryBriss 8y agoalso: sidelining or killing a particular, highly effective CEO might be profitable for some devious competitor or stock market short-seller
- 1001101 8y agoAs you probably know, short sellers and researchers have been teaming up (one example) [1] [1] https://www.nytimes.com/2016/09/09/business/dealbook/hedge-fund-and-cybersecurity-firm-team-up-to-short-sell-device-maker.html https://www.nytimes.com/2016/09/09/business/dealbook/hedge-f...
- informatimago 8y agoSo far, bugs in medical devices have been documented that have led to death or physical damage. Bad radiation doses, retina burning laser powers, etc. Given that most of those devices run on MS-Windows, I'm still more worried about bugs than attacks, but indeed it would be trivial for bad guys to target you if you need to be hooked on such devices...
- rbanffy 8y agoImagine, for instance, manipulating medical images to make a prominent politician (and their doctors) believe they have a dangerous tumor in their amygdala, making them undergo radiotherapy that fries half their amygdala, turning that politician into a liberal. Moral implications aside, I can see a reason to explore that idea ;-) Note: https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3092984/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3092984/
- vertexFarm 8y ago"Individuals with a large amygdala are more sensitive to fear...which, taken together with our findings, might suggest the testable hypothesis that individuals with larger amygdala are more inclined to integrate conservative views into their belief system." Fascinating. I'm going to avoid going off-topic any further, though.
- rbanffy 8y agoGood someone enjoyed the idea. It cost me a ton of karma ;-)
- maxxxxx 8y agoWe have thought about this in my company a lot but it seems there is no money in hacking devices and it usually doesn't scale well. Some person may try to inflict damage on people just for the heck of it but that will probably be isolated cases. It's potentially much more profitable to hack patient databases but even there there are probably better targets in other industries.
- vertexFarm 8y agoSecurity should be the default. I don't think it will cost much more to make them secure relative to what medical hardware already costs; adding encryption to the microprocessor in a state-of-the-art implant isn't going to be a hefty line item on that particular BOM. Think of it this way--any life-critical machine should have at least some consideration payed to security during design. Even non life-critical machines need security, so is it acceptable when we entirely ignore it in the whole field of medicine? If we leave it that that way, then yes, be utterly certain that it will be exploited somewhere by somebody. All information security paranoia is proven correct on a long enough timeline. Ask any infosec professional--does _____ system really need security? The answer is going to be yes, regardless of what's in the blank. We've learned this many times with many devices which we used to think nobody would ever bother to tamper with or that couldn't be made to do anyone harm. Every time our hubris brightly illustrated and we finally realize that yes, every networked device has the potential to be crucial to somebody and it all needs at least some consideration toward security.
- timeseries2018 8y ago>> consideration payed consideration paid