5 ms·
The automation charade
- tabtab 8y agoRather than replacing human workers via direct automation, the Internet has allowed workers in low-wage nations to do much of the work that used to be done locally. Telephone support is a common example. Even if a bot can't cook burgers correctly, a worker being paid 50-cents an hour in Timbuktu may be cooking burgers via remote-control. At a fast-food restaurant, there may be one human overseer monitoring several remote-controlled bots. I suspect that will happen before direct AI burgers. (It might even be a combo of AI and RC worker to speed response.) In general it seems pretty clear that the owners of technology are growing ever rich while the rest are stagnating. GDP is growing, but it's not trickling down much since the 1980's. Nobody is sure, but technology appears to be the main "culprit". We may have to adjust our economic systems to avoid log-jamming the fruits of automation at the top.
- slededit 8y agoIP is the new "means of production". Nobody wants to sell you a tractor outright anymore. They want you to buy the expensive to maintain hardware while they own the IP that makes it work. This ensures they can keep getting a recurring slice of the revenue you create with that machine - without the maintenance and other costs associated with a rental business.
- Animats 8y agoKitchen robots still haven't happened much. Except for computer-controlled woks.[1] Those are big in China. This seemed closer in 1960.[2] [1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jJUMAWL3LXg https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jJUMAWL3LXg [2] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1Xop9py8zBY https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1Xop9py8zBY
- toast0 8y agoConveyor ovens toast a lot of bread, cook a lot of burgers, and bake a lot of pizza. It's not sexy, but it's automation and it reduces the labor needed.
- mdo123 8y agoApparently the bots can cook burgers better: https://www.forbes.com/sites/christinatroitino/2018/06/21/meet-the-worlds-first-fully-automated-burger-robot-creator-debuts-the-big-mac-killer/#444e6cf46a89 https://www.forbes.com/sites/christinatroitino/2018/06/21/me...
- i_am_proteus 8y agoThe article appears to be approaching the issue from a leftist perspective and only telling some of the story. Here's some contrast: US manufacturing output has risen while manufacturing jobs have fallen. https://www.mercatus.org/sites/default/files/manufacturing-for-web-PNG26.png https://www.mercatus.org/sites/default/files/manufacturing-f... (data is from the Federal Reserve)
- dustinmoorenet 8y agoThe article mentions that reality of more-output-less-jobs by stating that the workers are required to work harder, because the boss threatens automation if they don't. It is the fauxtomation (the author's word) that is scaring the workers to produce more. I guess the point of view is leftist because it takes into account the worker's welfare. That doesn't seem like a bad side to be on...
- wahern 8y agoManufacturing output has risen in terms of revenue. That's different than saying it has risen in terms of widgets sold or some other hard measure, just as its different than in terms of per capita employment. One reason why it's important to note the distinction is because revenue can continue to rise even if manufacturing efficiency and expertise has remained the same or even declined. High labor costs in mature economies means those economies will tend to have a comparative advantage producing high-margin products even if their manufacturing expertise is declining across the board relative to low-wage countries, and even without automation. This is Economics 101, though professional economists don't always appreciate this, especially academics with an agenda like those at the Mercatus Center. Without knowing more, the fact that US manufacturing revenue has continued to climb (either in absolute or relative terms) does not refute the argument that American manufacturing is dying; not for most vernacular meanings of dying. In fact, it's perfectly consonant with that argument, and increasing revenue isn't particularly probative one way or another. (Note that I'm not arguing that US manufacturing is dying. But it does that mean that increasing labor costs in China and the shift of low-margin manufacturing elsewhere should make US manufacturers even more uneasy as it means the economics might finally be in favor of increasingly higher margin industrial processes moving to China. Depending on other factors, that could lead to a rapid, precipitous decline in American manufacturing revenue. Long story short, in the cut-throat world of global capitalism, we should be skeptical of anyone who suggests its okay to rest on our laurels. In many ways such views are even more detrimental than those who bash free markets. The surest way to be caught flat footed by free market volatility is by pretending it doesn't exist.)
- philipkglass 8y agoThis article reads a lot like one of the best frustrating books I have read: David F. Noble's Forces of Production: A Social History of Industrial Automation. Noble's book is about the introduction of computer numerically controlled machine tools in American manufacturing after WW II, covering the technology but focusing on CNC's effect on the balance of power between skilled workers and management. The technology was very expensive and fragile when first introduced, and was more effective at cowing workers than at quickly making high precision parts. American makers of CNC machines started with defense industry applications and couldn't manage to make machines competitively priced for civilian use even after they had stopped making wholly defective ones. The chronology ends in the late 1970s; the book was published in 1984. Management forces crazy process changes into a business, and is forced to backtrack after wasting years and huge sums of money -- a familiar story, right? Except that's not how it ended. There was no backtracking. The optimistic early claims about CNC became, after much time and money, realistic claims. German and Japanese machine tool manufacturers eventually produced the priced-for-civilian-work machines that American tool manufacturers couldn't or wouldn't. Nowadays, no American manufacturer would pay high wages for someone to precisely guide the motions of a lathe by coordinated hand-eye movements. They wouldn't even pay low wages for that particular task; human performance is too inconsistent. What of this vignette from the article, that also takes place between the immediate postwar and the 1970s? In 1946, some 550,000 auto workers had produced a little more than three million vehicles, but in 1970 some 750,000 auto workers had produced a little more than eight million vehicles.” The rapid pace took a devastating toll of people’s health and lives, leaving millions of workers disabled or dead; one study from the period estimated “sixty-five on-the-job deaths per day among autoworkers.” Auto industry executives credited the industry’s productivity boom to advances in machinery, but the predominantly black workforce knew it was in fact due to old-fashioned exploitation, not automation: heavier workloads and unsafe, unhealthy conditions. Today, General Motors employs 180,000 people and sells 9.6 million vehicles per year. Simultaneously, injury rates in manufacturing are down a lot since the 1970s. I think that both Noble's book and this article would be more persuasive if they committed to one major rhetorical thrust. Either "management is bluffing about how labor can be substituted by machines, so workers shouldn't be intimidated" or "machines can substitute for labor, so workers shouldn't expect the market economy to always provide paid work", but not both.
- gimmeDatCheddar 8y agoThis article is just more commie trash that somehow gets a bunch of upvotes on Hacker News.
- theamk 8y agoSure, robots cannot eliminate all jobs, but they can significantly decrease the number of them. In McDonalds example, cashiers disappeared, but new servers did not magically appear, so the total number of jobs has decreased. The same way, in "online order" example, author has not realized that while the human still helped with the order, the electronic system likely allowed them to fire one of the cashiers. I am not sure how elastic the labor supply is -- but if it is not very flexible, then even relatively small changes can affect wages a lot.