4 ms·
It's pretty clear he has a few misconceptions about economics. First of all, maximum efficiency happens when people are out of work. So, however inefficient a
by skybrian 16y ago
It's pretty clear he has a few misconceptions about economics.
First of all, maximum efficiency happens when people are out of work. So, however inefficient a government job might be, so long as something gets accomplished, it's less inefficient than one alternative. In times of low unemployment, we might say that government inefficiency is the problem since it crowds out private investment, but currently there is a worse problem. Unless you're competing with the government to hire people (and how many companies do that?), you don't lose anything when the government puts people to work.
Yeah, but they're spending tax dollars, right? Well, the only reason the government has to collect taxes is to prevent inflation. It's not because they need the money (the Fed can always create more money). It's to offset the inflation caused by government spending. (This is quite similar to a MMORPG where you need to control the sources and sinks.) We can talk about better ways to drain the system that would provide for better incentives and more interesting economic activity, but there have to be sinks somewhere, or money loses its value.
- barmstrong 16y ago"So, however inefficient a government job might be, so long as something gets accomplished, it's less inefficient than one alternative." Not true at all. If a government employee is paid $100k and only delivers $50k worth of value, it would have been better if he remained unemployed. The citizens would have keep their $100k and presumably invested it in something with a higher return.
- skybrian 16y agoA few things wrong with that: - Since inflation is so low, the government doesn't actually have to raise taxes. (This is the part people don't seem to get - taxes are to prevent inflation, so when there's no inflation, there's no reason for a tax increase.) - Currently, money is not the limiting factor for investment. Savings are up, investment is down, and money can be borrowed at very low interest rates. If investors wanted to invest more, they could, but they aren't. Your example is the same (economically) as paying one person $50k and giving away $50k to someone else. Capacity is standing idle due to lack of demand. It's the sort of thing that makes economists joke about burying cash in mines for people to dig up (Keynes) or dropping money from helicopters (Bernanke). Of course, it all changes if the economy picks up again.
- dennisgorelik 16y agoBusinesses definitely compete with government when hiring people. So if government employs somebody and wastes employee's effort in the process, then these efforts is actual loss for the economy.
- skybrian 16y agoOnly if they would have been employed otherwise - not especially likely in this economy. Also, most government jobs are lower paid than private industry. If people are declining your job offers to go work for the government, that suggests something's wrong with your business, not with government.
- dennisgorelik 16y ago1) If government spends $1B for providing a service that I can provide for $1M -- then government still wins even if my business is 100 times more efficient than government's. 2) If I have unlimited money supply -- I can always outbid you so you would not be able to hire anybody for your business.
- skybrian 16y ago1) Well that's true, but we were talking about competition for workers, not customers. Most government services don't compete with businesses for customers. The few exceptions show that private industry does successfully compete with government (Fed Ex and UPS versus U.S. Post Office.) 2) Maybe they could, but in practice, most government jobs don't pay high salaries. You're much more likely to be outbid by another private company.
- adolph 16y agomaximum efficiency happens when people are out of work I'm glad you cleared that up. That explains government economics pretty well, yes.