3 ms·
This won't fly because: * You can't put it in your resume. And that is importante because many academics need a minimal amount of publication each year. Perhap
by gus_massa 8y ago
This won't fly because:
* You can't put it in your resume. And that is importante because many academics need a minimal amount of publication each year. Perhaps someone with a tenure can have the luxury of a hidden article, but most of them have some graduate student or postdoc that is a coauthor and wants to increase the total count of papers by any mean.
* If the article is controversial enough, the authors will be identified using a text analysis. Most papers reuse a lot of parts of the previous papers of the authors, so it is not so difficult.
* Each controversial article will get the offended side (right/left/whatever) asking for an exemption of the anonymity and/xor deplataforming the journal.
- anonytrary 8y agoText analysis is like a polygraph, it's not really conclusive in and of itself and it's not really grounds to convict someone. It might help point you in the right direction if you ask the right questions, which may help lead you to something more conclusive.
- endominus 8y agoI don't think the standards of evidence demanded by those that authors of controversial articles fear are stringent enough that "equivalent to a polygraph" fails them.
- gus_massa 8y agoI think that looking at the reference section will detect 99% of the time who is the author or at least reduce the possibilities to a small group. People usually have a lot of citations of their previous amazing papers and the papers of the advisors and papers of friendly groups. It's possible to avoid this, but there is a strong bias. (It's more evident if you remove the common citations that everyone in the are is using in all the papers.)
- gnicholas 8y agoI'm not sure I agree. It's possible that some people will publish anonymously here and then later, if their work is sufficiently accepted by a large enough chunk of academia/society, they would come out from the shadows and claim ownership. I agree that untenured academics need to publish papers they can put on their resume, but it's not a fatal flaw if most of the early articles are penned by tenured professors. I'm not an expert in text analysis, but I think that if someone is trying to obfuscate their authorship they could probably do so.
- joemi 8y agoI think your first point (can't put it in your resume) is your strongest, and the most likely issue this publication will have. I'm not sure if it'll be enough of an issue to kill the journal though. The reason I don't think your second and third point are too big a deal is because they seem to be predicated on the assumption that the articles published in this journal will be wildly controversial. I don't think that's necessarily true. Presumably, the people running the journal will still decide what they want to publish and they won't be giving a free pass to every single submission. If someone decides to submit a study that is an unrigorous veiled attempt at justifying racism, I expect those reviewing the submissions will reject it. There are all kinds of things academics are likely afraid to publish with their names on it in the current sociopolitical climate out of fear of _potential_ blowback, without even getting into the things they won't publish due to _certain_ blowback. So in summation, I think it could potentially succeed if A) there are enough submissions even though people can't put it on their resumes, and B) the journal publishes enough not-so-controversial studies.