7 ms·
> The problem with individual takedown notices is that they don't scale. > People can upload illegal content faster than lawyers can issue takedown notices for
by JoshTriplett 8y ago
> The problem with individual takedown notices is that they don't scale.
> People can upload illegal content faster than lawyers can issue takedown notices for them.
Why is a massive copyright-owning organization's failure to scale a problem that anyone else should help with?
I'm aware of the original lawsuits against YouTube to that effect, and the arguments are just as wrong now as they were then.
(Also, I fully believe that filing an incorrect takedown notice should have legal repercussions, which today it never seems to.)
- ocdtrekkie 8y agoWhy is YouTube's inability to scale to meet the EU's regulation anyone else's problem but YouTube's? Your logic applies again, to YouTube as well. If YouTube can scale to ship videos, they can scale to actually be responsible for them. Shouldn't they be held responsible for the illegal activity they profit from? And be responsible to figure out how to make a business model around that basic responsibility?
- JoshTriplett 8y agoYou're begging the question by assuming the EU should get to define "responsible" for YouTube, or that they've done so correctly.