3 ms·
In general, I am cautious of running my own open source thing without being an expert in the relevant area (or interested in becoming one) -- having to put some
by jrochkind1 8y ago
In general, I am cautious of running my own open source thing without being an expert in the relevant area (or interested in becoming one) -- having to put something together (and maintain it) yourself seldom, in my experience, ends up _more_ secure or _more_ maintainable, when you don't know what you're doing.
However, routers may be an exception. Apparently the industry has basically no business motivation to keep consumer-grade networking hardware secure, at all. Irrelevant to their profits or reputation.
I'll consider it. When I bought my router I intentionally got one that can run OpenWRT, but never ended up installing it, cause, who's got time for that? But perhaps there isn't really an alternative, unless you want a bot-net-ed router. Which honestly, and with shame, I'd just ignore the botnet sending out spam to other people if I didn't think it was compromising the functionality (and security) of my router for me. Last thing I wanna do is spend time becoming a network engineer after a day of getting paid to write software, but i guess that's where we're at.
(Oh crap, I just realized it could be my DSL modem instead of or in addition to my (wired and wifi) router. I know even LESS about that thing. I think none of these consumer products, owned by people who know a lot less than me, are ever gonna be protected, if even I am intimidated by trying to figure it out).
- spudlyo 8y agoIt may not be as hard as you think. Doing a little homework, flashing the router with the OpenWRT firmware, and getting a basic config up and running should take most folks an afternoon. If you already understand concepts like CIDR addressing, DNS, DHCP, and NAT then it's an hour tops. OpenWRT is not a pain to use -- it's not all that different than the web GUI that ships with most routers.
- creeble 8y agoAnother option is to buy a pre-configured router from someone like FlashRouters.com (not affiliated, but a customer). They provide routers with DD-WRT or Tomato pre-installed. Yes, you should probably know how to update your router at some point in the future, but your starting point is probably much safer than depending on the poorly-tested and heavily-exploited factory firmware.
- jsjohnst 8y agoI’d recommend swapping out your consumer grade router for a commercial packaged version of pfSense. Just as easy to setup as most consumer grade routers and it auto updates (if you want) and has a decently secure base. Sure, you’ll spend $50 more, but isn’t the piece of mind worth it?
- xorcist 8y agoYou're going to have to upgrade your firmware anyway, so why not upgrade to something that actually cares about basic functionality? Some people unused to open source solutions sometimes have this idea that all software developed by enthusiasts by necessity is hard to use or require tinkering, but that's not a fair picture. When developers share your interests, that's when software gets usable. That interest might not always be UI, but sometimes it is. OpenWRT (and friends!) is clearly much easier to use and delivers richers functionality than any of the software it replaces. If your router is listed as supported, go for it.
- jrochkind1 8y agoThe good reviews of OpenWRT help. The caution is mostly because it's unclear to me how hard it would be to switch it back. But yeah, probably will.
- styfle 8y agoNot to mention the idea that you might Bork your router during installation and have no internet therefore no way to install the old fw version.