2 ms·
> What you won't see is any appreciation or consideration or even interest in the reason for the existence of copyright Sure you will. In the US, at least, cop
by JoshTriplett 8y ago
> What you won't see is any appreciation or consideration or even interest in the reason for the existence of copyright
Sure you will. In the US, at least, copyright exists for the sole stated purpose of encouraging the production of more works by temporarily granting some exclusive rights over those works. In other words, the public wants both more works and a rich public domain; that's a tradeoff. Now, how much exclusivity, for how long, do you need to grant to generate more than enough revenue to justify almost any work ever produced? What incremental additional works will be produced by the umpteenth new expansion of copyright?
As you said:
> Personally, I believe copyright of maybe 5 years on movies, 10 on music
If that, yes. And no more than 5 years on software, either, possibly less.
> I think if people were less entrenched in this mindset, you'd see far more ideas for better solutions being generated in the comment.
I've seen many good ideas, not least of which: make copyright shorter (5-10 years), and permit all non-commercial usage from day 1, limiting only commercial use for that duration. The problem is not in having ideas, it's in getting those ideas adopted.
> Case in point: I think you could make an ad blocker that blocks 100% of ads that are annoying, dangerous, or tracking you, yet let unobtrusive ads pass. Something like that would likely block maybe 20% of ads
You have a very different conception of what "annoying" means than many users of adblockers.
If my adblocker is blocking less than 100% of ads, it has a bug and will be fixed or replaced.