3 ms·
There is some very flawed thinking here. One thing is that technology has seesawed the centralization of power between "elite" and masses. Bronze Age armies wer
by Nasrudith 8y ago
There is some very flawed thinking here. One thing is that technology has seesawed the centralization of power between "elite" and masses. Bronze Age armies were elite and superior with professional armies supported by underclasses in a palace economy. Except in addition to the probable famine related bronze age collapse iron won out as quantity having a quality of its own. Horsemen whether heavily armored as in the west or horse archery in the east were the elite that miltia rabble were at a huge disadvantage towards although they faced various setbacks that were slightly democratized like longbowmen or well drilled pikemen (still pretty professional). The reason the French Chevaliers never had their men adopt longbow training was authoritarian - while the English were by no means a bastion of absolute liberty or democracy for anything beyond things to petty to care about like hamlet leading they still had to keep peasants happy enough to not turn their longbows on them. That was unacceptable to the French. Firearms were ultimately their end in relevance as men with guns could be mustered in weeks not months or years. Longbows were technically better in many ways but muskets were cheap. However technology has marched on. If you look at comparable battle reports of a first world professional army they look statistically superhuman in comparison. Apparently the intense training is such that desert locals thought that their body armor had to have air conditioning in it instead of just hydrating up frequently and plenty of PT.
This is a bit of a tangent but the point is that technology goes all over the damn place in terms of what it favors and suppression won't work well.
Also it seems very destroy the village to save it to propose government data gathering as a solution to lack of liberty. Not to mention suspiciously like self justification in both cases.