3 ms·
Immigrants aren't only laborers. They are also consumers, increasing demand for economic activity. At least in the US, claiming that immigrants hold "our value
by lupire 8y ago
Immigrants aren't only laborers. They are also consumers, increasing demand for economic activity.
At least in the US, claiming that immigrants hold "our values" in lower regard than citizens is not at all obvious.
Why wouldn't workers have recourse? Only illegal immigrants are excluded from protection under law. Unless your claim is that no low-skilled laborer are, which undermines your claim about "our values".
- toomuchtodo 8y ago> Why wouldn't workers have recourse? Only illegal immigrants are excluded from protection under law. Unless your claim is that no low-skilled laborer are, which undermines your claim about "our values". Legal immigrants would of course have employment law recourse. The vast majority of illegal immigrants currently do not (but should!), and that is what I was referring to. Those dangerous jobs I mention haven't been automated away yet solely because illegal, unskilled labor exists to perform them (see: dairy farms in Wisconsin that cannot exist without that labor [1]) (or the business cannot exist paying legal wages). Illegal immigration subsidizes business owners through the suffering of those immigrants. Legalizing those immigrants (and therefore, pushing their wages into what legal workers command) would eliminate those jobs. Catch-22. [1] https://madison.com/ct/news/local/under-trump-wisconsin-dairies-struggle-to-keep-immigrant-workers/article_198b9d16-b3b5-5557-b492-1a52e9195680.html https://madison.com/ct/news/local/under-trump-wisconsin-dair... (Under Trump, Wisconsin dairies struggle to keep immigrant workers)