2 ms·
> Consciousness cannot be reduced down to a bunch of changes of the brain's matter. This is a claim, show the proof then. > Consciousness is qualitatively dif
by pas 8y ago
> Consciousness cannot be reduced down to a bunch of changes of the brain's matter.
This is a claim, show the proof then.
> Consciousness is qualitatively different to how the brain functions,
Again, you need to prove this. First of course define what is what and why they are irreconcilable.
We have a consistent theory of the world for the small and large, from nuclear physics to cosmology, and everything in between, and none of them require extraphysical things. Why consciousness would be different?
> and yet no explanation has been offered as to how the brain can magically create consciousness.
I just offered one, and there are probably countless other explanations. The problem is usually testability not abduction of explanations.
> There are literally no models at all that demonstrate, solidly and irrevocably, how particular configurations of brain matter directly translate into consciousness.
We don't have to, we can test and weight hypotheses and eliminate them in other ways.
So far you have offered nothing that would help eliminate this hypothesis (counterexamples or other arguments would be great).