9 ms·
The Lost Art of Steam Heating (2017) [video]
- seidleroni 8y agoI read his book by the same name last year when I moved into a house with steam heating. The book goes into great detail and helped me resolve some banging pipes which kept waking me up in the middle of the night. This was after I had 2 heating "experts" come try and help. As Dan says, steam works great but only dead men know how to do it properly.
- larrywright 8y agoIn my younger years, I lived in an apartment in an older house (early 1900s). The house had steam heat (and no air, which was kind of awful). Steam heat is a bit noisier and I’m guessing the systems are finicky, but the heat they produce is incredibly comfortable. I live in the Midwest, so temperatures can get quite cold. I felt warmer in that apartment than in any other place I’ve lived, and it’s not a drying heat the way that forced air is. The house was a bit of a dump, and the quality of the heat didn’t really make up for the lack of air conditioning, but I still have fond memories of that steam heat 20+ years later.
- bunderbunder 8y agoI currently live in my first ever apartment that's heated by a furnace. We've seriously discussed moving again just to go back to having steam heat. The dry air from the forced air system makes the winter that much less pleasant. The previous place had a fairly modern boiler, no more than a decade or two old. Being a tenant, I have the luxury of getting to largely ignore these things, but, from what I could tell, it required less maintenance than the current place's furnace.
- wallace_f 8y agoTo play devil's advocate: can't you just boil a pot of water, run a hot bath, or just buy some humidifiers to improve this?
- euroclydon 8y agoHaving N sources of dry air (the vents) and one or two sources of humidity, scattered over your house, coming in and off all the time is a lot let desirable than a static system linked to your opening and closing of doors plus house leaks. It’s difficult to tune.
- wallace_f 8y agoSure, less desirable, but you you can buy n humidifiers
- thrower123 8y agoThat is the simplest method. I grew up with a hot-air wood furnace in the basement, and we just stuck a giant galvanized pan on top at the start of the ducting. About once a week I'd have to fill it back up. Man, I miss wood heat.
- astura 8y agoWhat maintenance does a forced air furnace need? Other than air filter changes? I've only had steam heat. I have a modern boiler and the only maintenance I have to do (so far) is pay a professional to do the yearly servicing.
- larrywright 8y agoIt depends on the model, quality and features. The one that came with my current house was very finicky and needed a fair amount of handholding (including pouring water into a little tube at the start of the season - something about a proper vacuum). I replaced it a few years ago with a new, near-top-of-line Trane with an air filtration system and a whole house humidifier. This one only needs to have the filter vacuumed monthly (three-stage electrostatic filter), and to have the humidifier water panel replaced once a year. Otherwise it’s basically no maintenance. Any forced-air system has ductwork, however, and that can get filthy over time and need cleaning.
- bunderbunder 8y agoI don't know about furnaces in general. It's just that the old place's steam heating never really gave us any problems, whereas our furnace has needed repairs multiple times over the past few years. Maintenance was bleeding the pipes occasionally, which I generally found to be less of a bother than replacing filters.
- jackhack 8y agoformer HVAC tech here. Sorry for the wall of text but here's most of what I would do as a seasonal change-over inspection: Every year, a full visual inspection of the heat exchanger, especially important after 5 years of life. We're looking for the first signs of perforation, and/or cracks. A "smoke test" isn't sufficient. Visual inspection of ductwork take-offs on plenum - leaks, seals, etc. Same for system cabinet. Check the safety switches -- roll out/limit sensor (millivolt), draft induction (exhaust blower) pressure switch, cabinet switches, etc. Clean the flame sensor. Visual inspection on the ignitor. Cracks = replace. Check values on start capacitor for blower motor. Replace if > +/- 15% of spec. Blow out P-trap on condensor drain (only applies to condensing furnaces, of course -- the >85% efficiency models, but that's most of what is installed these days). Oil blower motor and draft induction fan bearings. Observe flame color. After 10 years, or as needed, check exhaust with combustion analyzer for proper C0/C02 range. Observe 2 startup/cool down cycles for proper operation. Look for proper ignition, flame color/depth/shape, listen for odd sounds that would indicate issues (vibration, flexing, etc.) Replace the filter unless it's obviously new. (btw, This filter is there to protect the unit from dust/lint, not there to clean the air in the house.) Replace CO detector battery Not just "ask homeowner to do it" but do it myself. Replace detector out of date (they only last 10 years or so). This is mandatory if you are operating a fuel burning appliance. And Remind homeowner to change smoke detector batteries. Present a written report of all findings. Compare to last year's report -- look or trends. Keep copy of new on on record at the shop. This takes about an hour. If your "HVAC Guy" just shimmies into your crawlspace or attic for 15 minutes before climbing back out and saying "everything looks great, see ya in the spring" you're risking your safety and being cheated. Most don't do the whole job. Also, what most shops call a "tune up" isn't anything of the sort; at best it's a cursory visual inspection with gauges on the A/C unit and a check of the start/run capacitors. Most don't even bother to oil bearings. Every shop is different. There is a wide spectrum of hacks and pros.
- sandworm101 8y agoDry air is only bad in dry climates. Im in the pacific northwest, a literal rain forest. Moisture is constant. We want that dry air to keep the house free of mold. And it can do a gew things steam cannot, such as move air around without adding heat, a great form of air conditioning without actual AC.
- larrywright 8y agoA good humidifier is a must with forced air heating. The Wirecutter usually has some good recommendations for those.
- overcast 8y agoWhole house bypass humidifiers are cheap ~$500, and pretty quick to setup and easy to maintain. It sits inline where the dry hot air exits the furnace. You tap into the hot water line from the boiler, and a little solenoid spills water onto an evaporator pad. Replace that once a season. Amazing how quickly your humidity will ramp up after that gets in there. Definitely should be mandatory with ANY forced air furnace.
- earthscienceman 8y agoIt's so interesting to see this on Hacker News. Through the bizarre strange fortune of life I'm the owner of a mediocre building built in the late 1800s located in an old mining boom town. It has a very robust steam heating system in place but the town is absolutely in the middle-of-nowhere. The cost of getting someone to just look at the pipes is about $200, not to mention any work. Paid three different people to look at it and nobody knew up from down, got 3 radically different opinions on what should be done. After a ridiculous amount of searching and reading, I've come to find that basically nobody knows what they're talking about on the subject. The advice online and in person essentially amounts to witchcraft. I noticed people using the same adjectives/verbs to describe steam-heating that sellers of essential oils use. Finding Dan Holohan's website was like finding a miracle. Steam heating is so simple and efficient but it was done in an era when documentation and standardization was more nonexistent than today. If you sit down and draw diagrams and think about the system you have in your house it becomes so simple... but without that hour of logic and shaping of the problem you get no where fast. It was such a good 'back to the basics' experience for me that I wouldn't trade for my doctorate degree.
- ransom1538 8y agoThere are buildings in SF that still use steam. There must be a maintainer there still alive.
- chrisdhoover 8y agoMost homes in San Francisco have zero heat. Many added a gas wall heater in the late ‘50’s but they are a ridulcus heating method. To stay warm in Frisco, drink hot toddy’s, where three layers; t shirt, flannel shirt, hoody, rest in bed with you running laptop on you chest, and — go to the corner bar full of people and drink some more.
- scottlocklin 8y agoI was horrified the first time I saw a gas wall heater. Gas fireplace to heat the outside! Even more horrified when my Lebanese roommate needed to keep the ambient temperature 85 using a gas wall heater.
- dugditches 8y agoHere's an article on this talk: https://www.newyorker.com/magazine/2016/01/04/steamed-the-joy-of-steam-heat https://www.newyorker.com/magazine/2016/01/04/steamed-the-jo... This type of heating is still used in 'intrinsically safe' environments(where no natural gas/electric heaters can operate safely). Lots of banging and knocking pipes.
- nimbius 8y agoIm an engine mechanic at a small chain of midwestern shops, and Ive noticed the closer our location gets to the great lakes, the more likely the shop heat is going to be steam. The shop I work out of has reed radiators powered by a coal furnace. We use our Reznor gas units because nobodies ever cared to get the old system running again, but I feel like this would be a fun project.
- jadams5 8y agoI live in a 90 year old house that still uses the original steam heated radiators. It's actually been a lot of fun learning about the old technology with its pros and cons. As an example, I always assumed that the radiators were always just full of steam while running, but the systems actually work by cycling between steam production and condensation phases. There's an alcohol filled bladder at the base of every radiator that boils and expands when the steam fills the radiator, sealing off the flow at that point, forcing the steam to route around to the next radiator. Once all the radiators seal off the pressure in the system rises, triggering the boiler to shut down. The water condenses inside the radiators as they emit their heat and cool, the bladders open, the water drains back down to the boiler, and if the home temp is still low the cycle starts again. Who knew? For now we're actually planning on keeping it around while it's all in good working order.
- nkurz 8y agoInteresting. I think the system you are describing is a variation of a "two pipe steam" system that is not very common these days. More common systems have have an air vent, and do run on a continuous cycle. Holohan describes the differences here: https://heatinghelp.com/systems-help-center/a-steam-heating-primer/ https://heatinghelp.com/systems-help-center/a-steam-heating-... He also points out that the failure point of the system you have is that the "steam traps" tend to fail frequently and silently. The system still heats, but runs less efficiently. He says the traps typically have only a 3 year lifespan.
- jadams5 8y agoYep, it's a two pipe system. One of the first things I did was verify that the traps were all functioning. Amazingly enough, they were! The house was built in the 20's by a commercial plumber who put in some more commercial-style amenities including some state of the art for the era tankless flush-valve toilets. I love them, wife hates them.
- soperj 8y ago>tankless flush-valve toilets Quickly tried to find a picture of this, but don't know what exactly i'm looking for. Can you post a link?
- nkurz 8y agoA couple of comments here mention how great steam heat feels, apart how noisy it is. This is ironic, as one of Holohan's main points is that when operating properly, steam heat is silent. The problem is that most people have never experienced a properly operating steam heat system. Here's some quotes from the intro to his Greening Steam (which is a great book, which you should definitely read if you have a steam heat system): Steam Heat Should Be Silent Water hammer, that banging and knocking that is so prevalent in steam heating, is not normal. Don't let anyone tell you that it is. Water hammer is also destructive. It can break pipes from fittings and cause injury. It's not normal. It has definite causes, and you can make it go away. Hissing air vents aren't normal. In a well-balanced steam system, you should never hear air venting. When a vent makes noise, it's trying to tell you that it's handling too much air. Holohan's main conceit is that there are very few plumbers who understand steam heat, and as a result, there are very few systems that work as designed by the "Dead Men". The idea that steam heat is inherently noisy is one of the main myths that he wants to dispel. Tying this back to HN, there's probably some useful parallel here to systems architecture and maintenance programming. How many systems will keep working as well as they were designed after several generations of "repairs" have been performed on them? How can one design systems to make it more likely that they will continue to work as designed?
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- romed 8y agoThe problem as usual is with the users not the system. If anyone in your building turns the valve on their radiator off (because their space is overheated) then the water will condense and when they open it again the entire system will hammer, forever, until the building engineer drains it. As for the air vents it seems that building supervisors just can’t resist painting them, which renders them inoperable. They should know better. So in summary steam is wonderful as long as humans don’t get involved.
- nkurz 8y agoIf anyone in your building turns the valve on their radiator off (because their space is overheated) then the water will condense and when they open it again the entire system will hammer, forever, until the building engineer drains it. Theoretically, I don't think this is correct. And in practice, I'm sure it's not always true. That is, I've tuned up a steam system using Holoway's advice, and there was no problem with turning individual radiators on or off. In normal operation, the steam is condensing in the radiator, and then draining back to the boiler by gravity. Opening the valve after a period of nonoperation is not significantly different than the rush of condensation one gets at system start up when the radiator is cold. If the pipes are layed out correctly, when the valve is opened the water will drain back to the boiler with no outside action required. What is true is that the standard "one pipe" steam radiators work poorly when the user decides they want half the heat, and turns the steam valve halfway. In this case, the higher speed of the incoming steam through the smaller opening prevents the water from flowing out, and the radiator works poorly. The correct approach to variable heat on one-pipe steam systems is an adjustable exit air valve. Still, this should also "fix itself" quickly as soon as the shut-off valve is fully opened.
- ot8 8y agoI think it may come back in about 10 years coupled with a solar thermal collector. https://www.chalmers.se/en/departments/chem/news/Pages/Emissions-free-energy-system-saves-heat-from-the-summer-sun-for-winter-.aspx https://www.chalmers.se/en/departments/chem/news/Pages/Emiss...
- subpixel 8y agoA section of downtown Cleveland is still heated using a closed-loop steam-powered district system. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/District_heating https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/District_heating https://www.flickr.com/photos/timevanson/28933250436 https://www.flickr.com/photos/timevanson/28933250436
- pentagonpapers 8y agoDowntown Philadelphia as well. In fact, the small access street behind my work has a giant boiler in a back of an 18 wheeler that seems to be hooked up to our building while they are working on pipes and such. it's crazy! It was rented which i think was weird, there was a sign on the side to powerhouse, a quick google reveals the link below https://www.powerhouse.com/boiler-rental/trailer-mounted-boilers https://www.powerhouse.com/boiler-rental/trailer-mounted-boi...
- ablation 8y agoFascinating, thank you for posting. I'm always intrigued by steam systems in places like NYC.
- sailfast 8y ago"By the way you're a good looking group. Thank you for taking care of yourselves. Last week I spoke to a group that was butt ugly and it was really difficult. Speaker's burden, so... thanks for taking care of yourselves" Now THAT is a technique haha. This guy's so amped up and excited about this stuff it's amazing - even if you are not interested in steam heat, you are now! EDIT: This presentation is also great - similar, but more history: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nkgM0qCy5o4 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nkgM0qCy5o4
- JackFr 8y ago"If you see something that's old and it's been there for a long time and it's working, don't laugh at it."
- JackFr 8y ago"Nothing happens until someone picks up a hammer"
- jhallenworld 8y agoGet the book, it's awesome: https://www.amazon.com/Lost-Art-Steam-Heating/dp/0996477241/ref=sr_1_1?ie=UTF8&qid=1542127393&sr=8-1&keywords=lost+art+of+steam+heating https://www.amazon.com/Lost-Art-Steam-Heating/dp/0996477241/... I had oil fired steam heat (live around Boston). Back when heating oil hit $5 / gallon, I got rid of it. It was costing me $3800 / year, but the efficient gas furnace that replaced it costs $700 / year. I'm sure this will only last as long as the fracking boom, but it definitely already paid for the installation. So now my most expensive utility is water ($1700 / year).
- tvprod1203 8y agoI've yet to watch the video, but it seems weird to see praise for steam heating systems to me when I've had literally nauseatingly overheated apartments due to it. Was I just unlucky enough to have to cope with lowest-bidder systems?
- astura 8y agoThere's nothing particular about steam heating that will cause overheating on its own; it works identical to any other heating or cooling system; there's a thermostat where you set the temperature and it turns the system on and off to maintain the temperature at its set point. You change the set point if you are uncomfortable. Sometimes for multi unit buildings the landlord or super controls the heat for the whole building, that can be a case of the heat being set hotter than the occupant prefers, or perhaps just due to poor maintenance the system isn't maintaining temperature properly. I'm not sure why they couldn't just turn off individual radiators in this case though. A properly set up and maintained steam heating system keeps temperature properly and doesn't overheat the occupants.
- tvprod1203 8y ago> I'm not sure why they couldn't just turn off individual radiators in this case though. Mine had no valves or anything. If you wanted to turn it off, good luck.
- bootlooped 8y agoI looked at an apartment that had steam heating via radiators in every room. The landlord was very adamant that the tenants were not to adjust the radiators. My guess as to why is that turning one off/down could make the others hotter.
- tvprod1203 8y agoReading up on some of the links provided in this thread, I think that would indicate a badly maintained system/too much pressure. And I'm now quite sure I had to deal with a single-pipe system modified to not have individual valves. Quite insane, but I guess that's what cheap owners will do.
- ryanmercer 8y agoIs it a lost art? If I'm not mistaken it's very much a thing still on the east coast and in places like Iceland and parts of Russia.
- kgilpin 8y agoI think it’s a lost art in that they aren’t being built any more, yet lots of people have them. In any case I live in Massachusetts and had steam heat for many years and found these books super helpful. There are however some plumbers around here that know their way around these systems.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- frankus 8y agoA few years ago I was looking at the specific heat of common substances and water is pretty much off the charts compared with everything else (http://hyperphysics.phy-astr.gsu.edu/hbase/Tables/sphtt.html http://hyperphysics.phy-astr.gsu.edu/hbase/Tables/sphtt.html). But the heat of vaporization is also huge: it takes about the same energy to boil a quantity of water as it does to take it from 0°C to 100°C. The main downside is that the vaporization/condensation has to take place at 100°C, which is arguably a bit hotter than is ideal for safe space heating. Also the water returning to the boiler might not be cold enough to condense out the water vapor from the fuel (more important in fuels like natural gas with a big difference between HHV and LHV). I've sometimes wondered if it would be practical to operate a steam heating system at a partial vacuum so that the condensation/vaporization could occur at a lower temperature, but I haven't seen that done anywhere so I'm guessing the answer is no.
- avhon1 8y ago> I've sometimes wondered if it would be practical to operate a steam heating system at a partial vacuum so that the condensation/vaporization could occur at a lower temperature He actually talks about exactly this in the video! https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TQB0KK2rxcw&t=573 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TQB0KK2rxcw&t=573 "You'll be sending steam up into the building at temperatures, in some cases, as low as 150 degrees" (83 degrees C)
- userbinator 8y agoLook up "vacuum vapor heating" for more info --- quite clever to do it even without using a vacuum pump, just special vent valves.
- randyrand 8y agoGreat talk. Thanks Dan.
- jonbaer 8y agoOne question I have with steam heating in say an old Brooklyn apartment building is how healthy could it possibly be after so many years? Also some of the valves are not really controllable, it's either you deal with extreme heat or you shut it entirely off (for the room).
- jabl 8y agoForgive the dumb question, but what's the point of these systems, compared to just using hot water? Here in northern Europe, these systems are virtually unheard of. What's quite common, OTOH, are city-wide district heating systems, often run from the waste heat from electric power plants. IIRC the temperature of the heating water mains when going out from the plants is around 110C or so (it's water, not steam, due to it being slightly pressurized [1]). Each house or block then has it's own heat exchanger, used for heating the water that goes to the radiators (which IIRC is kept above 60C to avoid bacterial growth) as well as producing warm tap water. [1] Which makes for a nice show when there's a break in the heating mains somewhere; lots of steam coming out of the ground.
- nkurz 8y agowhat's the point of these systems, compared to just using hot water? The main advantage is probably that you don't need any pumps. This can increase efficiency, and removes a major point of failure. The other big difference is that phase transition from water to steam is very high energy. By weight, steam transports 6x the heat of liquid water, and releases 5/6 of this as soon as it condenses back to water. Depending on the situation, this can be an advantage. In general, I don't think that either system has a tremendous advantage -- they are just different. For modern systems, advantage probably leans to hot water.
- DanHolohan 8y agoThanks for the kind words and for your interest in steam heating. There's a delicious amount of history wrapped up in this stuff. I gave that talk at The General Society of Mechanics and Tradesmen of the city of New York, not at The Arsenal. I did talk about the Arsenal, though. That's a wonderful place. GSMT is at 20 W. 44th Street in Manhattan. It's a landmarked building, across the street from the Harvard Club. Visiting there is like watching Night at the Museum. I'm currently V.P of the Society. I founded HeatingHelp.com in 1997. I retired in 2016 and our daughter, Erin Holohan Haskell, now owns the site. It's a terrific resource for heating system, both old and new. Dan