3 ms·
But the point is that 'black' is not really all that meaningful because it encompasses potentially dozens of very disparate quite genetically distinct populatio
by cmrdporcupine 8y ago
But the point is that 'black' is not really all that meaningful because it encompasses potentially dozens of very disparate quite genetically distinct populations and lineages -- I mean what's CRC prevalence like among continental Africans? Maybe it's possible that CRC is more prevalent among African-Americans because of some higher occurrence in the west African populations where most slaves came from. Or maybe it developed in North America. But to talk about it in terms of race implies that black skin and African origin is the most important binding element -- when in fact what we are talking about is a specific African-American population.
- AnimalMuppet 8y agoAnd the guy who got his wife the test was in fact an African-American. So you can argue all you want about whether the label "black" fits, but the fact is, it communicated correctly. Now, you do have a bit of a valid point - such results can be taken to say more than is actually valid of them. But it seems to me that most people protesting aren't actually concerned with that at all. They're concerned with the sociological aspects, rather than the correlation between the genetics and particular populations.
- novacole 8y agoIf you read the Tiskoff paper [0] on the genetic diversity of Africans, it’s actually thousands of genetically diverse groups. Africans as a race is nonsensical genetically speaking. [0] The Genetic Structure and History of Africans and African Americans https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2947357/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2947357/
- cm2187 8y agoIt is pretty relevant to a dermatologist. Racial statistics are banned in France so dermatologists have to resort to code words, because skins of different color behave quite differently.
- Iv 8y agoJust to nitpick: racial statistics are not banned in France. But they have to be voluntary and anonymous. What is forbidden is to make a file telling if a specific person is black... or jewish, as has been the case not too long ago. So the census (which is mandatory) is banned from asking questions about ethnicity, religion or political affiliation. You can however make a general statistics about blacks or muslims as long as you guarantee anonymity and consent of the participants.