4 ms·
>> "As a tradinally Left person myself, I'm deeply troubled by the disourse in the U.S., where the Left and the extreme Right use the same phraseology and attit
by Kye 8y ago
>> "As a tradinally Left person myself, I'm deeply troubled by the disourse in the U.S., where the Left and the extreme Right use the same phraseology and attitude, while the former feeling vindicated and justified. And throwing away due process in the interest of the Greater Good?"
I mean, yeah, but Quillette is still a rag. It exists to exhaust people with the time, energy, and knowledge to debunk it so people without that will be duped by its arguments that only seem reasonable on the surface and one or two layers below, right above the trash.
Quillette is like a knowledge slot machine to people who want to be well-informed but don't have the resources to do it without leaning on others who do. It lures you in with surface plausibility.
- mancerayder 8y agoWe read rags all day: Politico, Vox, even the Guardian and the NYT do plenty of ragging. It's not all flak-jacket reporting with helicopters buzzing overhead and sandstorms; there's plenty of polemics to go around. The article I linked above is very rational and supported with references.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- Kye 8y agoI'm sure it is, but I don't see why Quillete needs to be given attention. It's bad media. It feeds on people without enough patience to resist skilled manipulation. It leans on confirmation bias and hammers it in. Someone elsewhere likened it to Galileo. Quillette is more like the Church. It says "the Earth is flat!" How many times do you walk someone through the math of proving the Earth is roundish before you realize it's futile? Unchecked confirmation bias always wins. The best treatment is to starve it of air. It doesn't need profiles in mostly credible outlets. It needs a faulty backup and restoration plan and a power surge.
- markdog12 8y ago> It doesn't need profiles in mostly credible outlets. It needs a faulty backup and restoration plan and a power surge. Who sounds like the church?
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- klagermkii 8y ago> Someone elsewhere likened it to Galileo. Quillette is more like the Church. It says "the Earth is flat!" How many times do you walk someone through the math of proving the Earth is roundish before you realize it's futile? Unchecked confirmation bias always wins. The best treatment is to starve it of air. I don't think this is a healthy view for the long term success of a culture built around social justice (the combination of how-often-do-I-have-to-repeat-this with it's-not-my-job-to-educate-you). It's been less than two decades since swinging popular opinion over onto the side of broader rights and already the people who should be the stanchest advocates seem tired of trying to persuade people. This is a fundamental part of human culture, you have to keep explaining the so-called basics again and again, rather than being exasperated whenever people want it explained for the umpteenth time. Learn from religions, and see how even when Christianity was the absolute dominant Western culture, that they were happy to explain it again and again to anyone that wanted to listen. That is what you need to do if you want to keep your gains and keep everyone on the same page.
- Kye 8y agoInoreader's stats say it posts 14 articles a week to 306 subscribers, just on Inoreader. Their Twitter has close to 100k followers. I might persuade one person in the time they convince or reinforce 10 beliefs in 1000 people. What hope does good information have against that kind of persuasion engine? There's a reason religion's decline started with the rise of mass media. It had competition.
- mancerayder 8y agoI mean, yeah, but Quillette is still a rag. It exists to exhaust people with the time, energy, and knowledge to debunk it so people without that will be duped by its arguments that only seem reasonable on the surface and one or two layers below, right above the trash. Quillette is like a knowledge slot machine to people who want to be well-informed but don't have the resources to do it without leaning on others who do. It lures you in with surface plausibility. I think you edited after my response below, so: If your words are true, the entire thing is discredited. It feels hand-wavy, so do you have any examples or references? The article I linked above has supported references and links, and it's quite long. You're saying it's a complete fraud?
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- mancerayder 8y agoYou've provided no evidence for your claims at all, only one post-comment-edit and a repetition of your ad-hominems against the publication. It's bad because it's bad, it's a fraud because it's a fraud, and when asked to clarify what's fraudulent about it, we're told there are "gradients."
- Kye 8y agoIt's the same tired old conservative talking points with the edges filed down. It's futile. People believe what they want to believe. When they're ready to question it, they can see all that's been written over the last couple decades about conservative media. I am not re-treading it for the nth time just because someone repackaged the same stuff for a new generation. I've been down this road. It goes nowhere at best, and turns into demon threads (https://www.lesswrong.com/posts/BZtAavpsy9WtMYgEL/demon-threads https://www.lesswrong.com/posts/BZtAavpsy9WtMYgEL/demon-thre...) in the average case.
- DanBC 8y agoThis article by a quillete editor but written for WSJ is horseshit. https://www.wsj.com/articles/a-visit-to-islamic-england-1535581583 https://www.wsj.com/articles/a-visit-to-islamic-england-1535... Note the correction: > An earlier version mistakenly identified the public context of a sign that declared “Alcohol-restricted zone.” Such signs refer to a prohibition on public drinking and appear in many English neighborhoods, irrespective of Muslim population. That's what you get when islamophobic idiots write articles about a country they don't understand. These signs really are common across England. There's one outside my house. (Muslim population in my street = 0, and in this part of town = < 2%). But the article is full of this kind of horseshit: "no one makes eye contact" - yep, this happens, but it happens between everyone regardless of religion: we don't talk to each other in the south. About the only thing that's true is that some mosques distribute unpleasant material. I'd ban it, but then I'd also ban this shitty article. Mr Ngo is a hypocrite for calling out these pamphlets while writing material as objectionable himself.
- yesenadam 8y agopeople who want to be well-informed but don't have the resources to do it without leaning on others who do Uh, isn't that absolutely everyone? All your comments on this page are very ugly, and remind me of the SJWs in the movie The Red Pill - so certain they're right that they have no need to think about, engage with, consider the matter/group/publication in question. They are good, the other is bad, by definition. I hadn't heard of Lehmann or Quillette. Reading most of the comments on this page, I expected some ranting far-right lunatic website. But a couple of comments made me think it might be worth checking out.. And what a surprise. It seems full of interesting articles. Has supportive blurbs from quite a lot of writers I like. I was expecting at best an intelligent site from the right[0]. It's actually nothing like that, just seems full of good articles from good writers. Why the hate and fear on this page, I have no idea. So I bookmarked quillette.com and will be reading their stuff. Thanks HN. [0] I like to sometimes read "conservative" stuff, to counterbalance my natural far-left inclinations. e.g. I love the books of Roger Kimball and David Stove, and have learnt a lot from them. Plus they're excellent writers, and can be very funny. (Although I read one of Kimball's purely political pieces online once, OMG it was embarrassingly bad. But in matters of general art/culture/philosophy I don't often disagree with him.)
- Kye 8y agoI wouldn't describe any of my 5 comments on this page as ugly, but I guess interpretation is the core of this whole conflict. 1 is a simple statistical note. 1 is admitting I might be wrong. 1 is a bit harsh. 1 is a bit mean. I shouldn't have called it a rag. They at least seem pro-a lot of things I care about and don't seem malicious. 1 is a tame assessment based on several articles I read that became popular here on HN. I plan to give it another look based on /u/natalyarostova's comment. Maybe you should do the same with the comments you find so ugly.
- yesenadam 8y agoThe majority of your sentences are full of bile, prejudice, raging hypocrisy, ridiculous comparisons etc, the kind of writing that will get you downvoted, flagged and banned from this site.