3 ms·
Apps have been free to abuse UDP all this time, but it's not been a real issue. Even data-hungry applications like video-streaming have gone with TCP almost eve
by MaxBarraclough 8y ago
Apps have been free to abuse UDP all this time, but it's not been a real issue. Even data-hungry applications like video-streaming have gone with TCP almost every time.
Also, couldn't the OS still throttle back greedy applications? No reason it couldn't detect the heavy stream of UDP traffic.
- quotemstr 8y agoI worry that it'll become easier (and this more common) in an all QUIC world. It's always been possible, but few people have had the expertise and motive. The OS can throttle sends on a single machine, but it can't arbitrate across machines or do anything about incoming flows.
- profmonocle 8y ago> The OS can throttle sends on a single machine, but it can't arbitrate across machines or do anything about incoming flows. Isn't that the case with TCP's congestion control as well? If the server's kernel isn't backing off properly, how can the client's TCP stack mitigate that?
- quotemstr 8y agoPeople running services can and do play games with TCP send-side congestion control: see https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1942442 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1942442 So far, these hacks have been limited by the need to work with stock receive-side TCP stacks. Once you move to UDP, all bets are off.
- M2Ys4U 8y ago> Apps have been free to abuse UDP all this time, but it's not been a real issue. Even data-hungry applications like video-streaming have gone with TCP almost every time. I suspect that's more down to NAT than anything else
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- adev_ 8y ago> Apps have been free to abuse UDP all this time, but it's not been a real issue. Even data-hungry applications like video-streaming have gone with TCP almost every time. In the past Bittorrent and the creation of the µTP prooved ( http://blog.bittorrent.com/2009/11/13/testing-%C2%B5tp-is-%C2%B5tp-actually-faster-than-regular-bittorrent/ http://blog.bittorrent.com/2009/11/13/testing-%C2%B5tp-is-%C... ) that unmanaged protocol abuse in userspace can lead to big degradation in QOS yes. Mainly due to "unfair" congestion policy between protocols.