3 ms·
But I can use this to download things that are not open source... I can use this to download SOCKS proxies (that despite not being VPNs I believe are still bann
by saurik 8y ago
But I can use this to download things that are not open source... I can use this to download SOCKS proxies (that despite not being VPNs I believe are still banned in the Chinese App Store, though I might be wrong about that: they are definitely illegal in China)... hell: I can use this to download other (even less efficient) emulators for other architectures. I mean, this is literally "an emulator", which is a core example of a thing that Apple wants to not exist.
I mean: this is a great implementation of an emulator. I have downloaded and tried iSH, and it is actually "kind of epic". This isn't exactly what I thought it would be, glancing at the source code: it sounded like it would be running the Linux kernel (so actually be Linux) in console mode, but this is a library operating system and is very similar in many ways to the project I sometimes talk about (which also provided a library operating system, but was going to distribute pre-compiled code as part of the application to avoid needing an emulator), but this is clearly better as an emulator (and is much easier to do, despite this emulator being a slightly harder emulator to build than most).
So, this is a great implementation of this--this is even a "heroic" implementation of this--but, at the end of the day, this is the thing Apple was trying to stop (as much as I hate Apple for that).
- saagarjha 8y ago> But I can use this to download things that are not open source. Ok, let's widen our view of open source then. Pythonista lets you download Python code and then it interprets it, and iSH lets you download compiled x86 code and then interprets that. So it's still open source, see! > I can use this to download SOCKS proxies (that despite not being VPNs I believe are still banned in the Chinese App Store, though I might be wrong about that: they are definitely illegal in China) I'm not following you. How would iSH be able to actually apply these proxies system-wide unless it's a VPN app, which as far as I'm aware it's not? All it can do is possibly download VPN profiles, but I can do that in Safari too. Perhaps I'm misunderstanding how SOCKS works, but I don't see how this could change anything except traffic you're sending in-app at the most. > I mean, this is literally "an emulator", which is a core example of a thing that Apple wants to not exist. You're going to have to provide evidence for that–Apple used to do this by citing 2.5.2 in their App Store Review Guidelines, which explicitly forbid this kind of thing, but as I mentioned there is now an exception poked in it for "educational use". Has any "educational" (i.e. non-piracy) emulator recently been rejected by Apple, and if so, under what grounds? > at the end of the day, this is the thing Apple was trying to stop Again, I disagree that Apple would try to stop this, at least under the current set of rules that they have. The fact that it made it through TestFlight review is pretty telling, I think.