3 ms·
None of this is really new. Back when factories actually meant big money, entire countries competed to get this or that manufacturer’s plant - every time the pl
by toyg 8y ago
None of this is really new. Back when factories actually meant big money, entire countries competed to get this or that manufacturer’s plant - every time the plant would have been “the most advanced “, “key to the future of the company” etc etc. Then, a few years after the plant was built and subsidies were collected, they would close the plant and start the carousel again. RyanAir did it with regional airports for a bit. Every supermarket does it with their suppliers.
It’s sad that politicians always think they are smarter than anybody else, that “this time it won’t happen” or simply that, even considering negatives, the opportunity is still too good to pass. Unfortunately, nobody ever got re-elected for saying no to this sort of opportunities.
- nkassis 8y agoI'm pretty sure politicians know what they are doing and know what it really means. They do it because of the huge publicity impact helps them get reelected. The incentives are misplaced for them to make decisions good for the people. It's our fault as voters for being swayed by these gimmicks.
- shaki-dora 8y agoPoliticians aren't quite as stupid as you (and, apparently, everyone else, believes). The dynamics in such a situation are simply a prisoner's dilemma. Meaning: without cooperation, bidding for and getting HQ2 is net positive for the city. Nobody really sees much of a problem here, and your (and the sibling comment's) tiresome invocation of the lazy stupid-corrupt-politician-cliché is, as always, superfluous. The actual issue is that, quite obviously, Amazon would expand and hire more employees anyway. This competition exploits the dynamic mentioned above to move money from the public to Amazon in a zero-sum game. And the total loss of this scheme is even larger than "just" billions in taxes: when Amazon makes this decision based on the subsidies they are promised, they (by definition) must put lesser weight on all the factors that would otherwise dominate the decision. So they will end up at a location with lower quality-of-life, higher prices, or some other trade-offs. Amazon is essentially asking cities to pay them for crippling itself, and for compromising their employees happiness. Which, come to think of it, really does not strike me as the set of priorities one would expect from a stable company with a long-term focus and healthy values. Anyway, that's why somewhat sane jurisdictions such as the EU put limits on subsidies and bespoke tax deals: it's cooperation that, when managed fairly, benefits everyone. There's still competition between locations, but it's about quality-of-life, infrastructure, or education, instead of a voluntary effort to impoverish. The fault, therefore, is the American fetishisation of market-based mechanisms[0], the seemingly endless willingness to starve public administrations of resources without any regard to their actual, absolute levels, and a somewhat pathological fear of showing weakness by treating any situation cooperatively, instead opting to turn everything into some sort of competition that at least guarantees the sweet payoff of others losing even worse. [0]: This is particularly interesting here: The dedication to a free market runs so deep, that voters and politicians are essentially turning down the possibility to form a cartel amongst themselves. I one were to believe they are doing this knowing- and willingly, one would have admire it as a rather rare display of altruism in the service of a larger principle.
- specialist 8y ago"...American fetishisation of market-based mechanisms" Conflating incentives, pricing, and competition drives me nuts. They're orthogonal concerns. Like conflating capitalism and corporatism. Corporations are anti market, driven to eliminate competition. Duh. But criticize corporatism and you're branded an anti capitalist nut bar. It's almost as if there's a massive disinformation campaign about how economies work.
- bane 8y agoCosta Rica used to have an Intel fab that accounted for something like 20% of their national exports.