5 ms·
Really did say a lot about the state of government subsidizing big business that mayors and governors were falling over themselves to offer tax rebates to one o
by jazzyjackson 8y ago
Really did say a lot about the state of government subsidizing big business that mayors and governors were falling over themselves to offer tax rebates to one of the richest companies on earth.
- bunderbunder 8y agoIt says something about the incentive structures affecting politicians. I'd be willing to pay crazy high money for a shiny bauble that I'd get to brag about to all my friends and coworkers, too, if I didn't have to use my own money to pay for it.
- fjsolwmv 8y agoIt's simply competition. When there are multiple sellers, the price drops. Unless state engage in collective bargaining and revenue sharing in some sort of federation, there's no avoiding it.
- StevePerkins 8y agoI honestly can't tell if this is sarcasm or irony.
- gedy 8y agoIt's ironic to me that the desire is to bring in "jobs", when Amazon has a huge negative impact on local retail jobs.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- dorfsmay 8y agoRetail jobs lost to online shopping are gone regardless of a city hosting an ecommerce company or not. The economy is constantly shifting, it make sense to adapt to it.
- gedy 8y agoMaybe, but Amazon is uniquely large impact, and makes no sense to cut tax deals, etc for them either.
- dorfsmay 8y agoThese are orthogonal concerns. > Amazon is uniquely large impact Amazon's impact happens regardless of them offering jobs in your city. If you want to address their impact on local business then you the city should work out a local tax on good delivered to the city. Preventing Amazon to bring jobs in a city has zero impact on lost retail jobs! > makes no sense to cut tax deals A city should offer incentive for potential new employers, promise to augment public transport, accelerate the red tape to build their building (maybe the city hires more people temporarily to deal with that extra work?), possibly cut tax for the first few years in exchange of some written commitment. But I agree with you that it has to be financially sound long term, a tax break for ever that ends up being subsidized by the tax payer makes no sense except for somebody looking for re-election.
- kazagistar 8y agoThe competition of the free market leaves little room for morality or justice. The tragedy of the commons strikes again: "if we dont, the other city will get all the benefit and none of the loss" and we are apparently too averse to regulations in the US to actually cooperate in our best interest.
- assblaster 8y agoGovernment leaders doing whatever it takes to bring jobs and prosperity to their constituents is a good idea. Seeking favors and special treatment under false pretenses is bad. Amazon is in the wrong, clearly, since they actively misled others. If my city got a second headquarters for Amazon, I would have been ecstatic.
- ethbro 8y agoAnnouncing the list of finalists was in poor taste. Amazon could have at least let unchosen smaller cities believe they were seriously considered.
- esrauch 8y agoI assume the point was to get people (property owners, other constituents) in those cities put on pressure to the local government to land to deal even with more favorable terns for Amazon
- dorfsmay 8y agoWhy? Anoucing early who's out prevents those contenders to spend more money and waste further time with the bid.
- untog 8y agoThey could be notified privately. After all, all details of the negotiations had been private up until that point.
- ethbro 8y agoIndeed. The announcement and the mundanity of the finalist cities was pretty shitty to all the smaller towns Amazon insinuated could be in the running. I live in on the finalist cities, but I also have good friends in a nearby regional hub who made a good faith effort. It would have been one thing to tell them "We didn't select you." It's something different to say "We're still considering cities, but definitely not yours."
- eksemplar 8y agoCompanies are important to cities, and that means they get privileges. Maybe that’s not fair, but a company with a few thousand employees will pay for quite a few things through income taxes. All those employees will also bolster the community with purchases and what not.
- ashelmire 8y agoWhat about existing companies? What about the plethora of small businesses in them? Do they get incentives? After all, they are the majority of the workforce. It’s absurd that large businesses get to use our resources and pay less than small companies, as though our markets weren’t distorted enough.
- maxxxxx 8y agoTotally agree. Existing businesses get screwed over to get some shiny big company in. I think part of the problem is media coverage: You don't hear much about 1000 companies with 10 people each but there is a lot of news in a facility with 10000 people and a famous company name. Although I'd argue that the 1000 small companies are much better for for the area.
- prolikewh0a 8y agoSmall companies also aren't shipping 25,000 people in from all around the country or world to displace your family and friends by raising rent and living costs hundreds of percent. The incentives are given so that already rich individuals get even more rich; so already rich property owners get to drown in profits while the poor and lower middle classes struggle and are segregated out of their cities. Incentives for small local community buisnesses that care about your community should be a higher priority for all Americans.
- aswanson 8y agoIf there is one aspect of populism I agree with, it's this. Existing small businesses get nowhere near the level of policy protection and corporate welfare multinationals do.
- dazc 8y agoThe country of Ireland has done much the same on a grand scale, much to their own benefit. I agree it does seem crazy but if these businesses bring about a net benefit to where they are located it can't be all bad? I'm not familiar with the US tax system but in the UK, and much of Europe, the system is lagging behind the real world of business by a measure of decades.
- pekko 8y agoAnd, thankfully, EU has regulations against such schemes. We can have international treaties and organisations to prevent cases of tradegy of commons. For example, EU forces Ireland to collect taxes from Apple, because it deemed such rebates to be illegal state aid. See https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/EU_illegal_State_aid_case_against_Apple_in_Ireland https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/EU_illegal_State_aid_case_agai...
- asdfasgasdgasdg 8y agoThey did not force them to raise their tax rate though, so it is still highly beneficial to Apple to be in Ireland compared to, say, France. What member countries really should do is similar to the revenue tax that was recently proposed. But not exactly, because that's a pretty blunt tool. Instead, the calculation should go something like this. # Exclude payments to/from subsidiaries. global_revenue = all external revenue global_expenses = all external non-tax costs global_profit = global_revenue - global_expenses global_tax = this_country_tax_rate * global_profit country_tax = this_country_revenue / global_revenue * global_tax The goal being to remove the benefit of tax avoiding schemes like Ireland. It doesn't matter how you move the money around, you'll pay taxes to this country based on how much money you make here. Require the company to estimate and pay this tax quarterly, and provide reasonable fines for underpayment. Granted the first two lines might be difficult to compute, so you would only do this for companies big enough to be worth going through the trouble for. Disclaimer: not a tax policy expert. Would love to be corrected. Please poke holes.
- matt4077 8y ago