4 ms·
Decision tree based processes like you outline are not only naiive (It does not operate with complete observability) and it's not resilient (It is susceptible t
by AndrewKemendo 8y ago
Decision tree based processes like you outline are not only naiive (It does not operate with complete observability) and it's not resilient (It is susceptible to workarounds).
That explicit reasoning approach falls squarely into GOFAI, symbolic reasoning, expert systems etc... so we're well past that at this point and know the problems with it.
Anyway, again, it's not a tractable problem. Something smarter than you is going to be able to eventually beat whatever restrictions you put on it. Might as well just be comfortable with it.
- antidesitter 8y ago> That explicit reasoning approach falls squarely into GOFAI, symbolic reasoning, expert systems etc... so we're well past that at this point and know the problems with it. The symbolic reasoning you're talking about is going to make a comeback through probabilistic inductive programming, so don't dismiss it. It is necessary to attain sample efficiency and generalizability, which is virtually impossible with purely statistical approaches. I recommend you look into Josh Tenenbaum's work: http://science.sciencemag.org/content/331/6022/1279 http://science.sciencemag.org/content/331/6022/1279.
- AndrewKemendo 8y agoI wasn't clear with that statement. As clarification, I'm not saying that GOFAI approaches aren't going to get better or be more relevant. Rather, the AI community has really good confidence that you can "fool" every AI approach to date. That has been true the longest for GOFAI approaches, and now we're doing it for DL/RL.