4 ms·
It's a neurotic fear of pollution and poisoning that is constantly reinforced instead of dismissed. Once you've convinced people that smoking is the most danger
by pessimizer 8y ago
It's a neurotic fear of pollution and poisoning that is constantly reinforced instead of dismissed. Once you've convinced people that smoking is the most dangerous thing in the world, and they know that people smoke in order to get nicotine, it follows that any inadvertent inhalation of cigarette smoke is extremely dangerous, and that nicotine is the most deadly poison.
The data on close-quarters constant second-hand smoke (working in bars, having a partner that smokes) is sketchy, the idea that passing someone while walking outside and momentarily catching a whiff of smoke a couple of dozen times a day is a public health crisis that requires immediate worldwide prohibition is absurd, but common.
It's also a convenient piece of do-nothing legislation for local politicians to campaign on.
- eric_h 8y ago> The data on close-quarters constant second-hand smoke (working in bars, having a partner that smokes) is sketchy Okay, but the data on smoking is not sketchy at all, so it’s not a stretch to suggest that constant exposure to second hand smoke in a poorly ventilated environment is comparable to smoking. Unfortunately there’s no way to set up a classical controlled experiment to test that hypothesis ethically, so we have to make do with other experimental setups and data analysis. We do have studies that assess the affects of air pollution in cities, so surely we can come up with some way of extrapolating, no? > It's also a convenient piece of do-nothing legislation for local politicians to campaign on Sure - cigarette smoke does not smell good to non-smokers so it’s an easy win these days since most people don’t smoke. I’m just trying to come up with a way of legislating these things based on our best abilities to make conclusions based on data rather than feelings, but I feel as though the onslaught of information brought about by the internet is making it harder to disseminate the wheat while more disseminate the chaff. Not to mention all the ways one can make feelings look like data.
- cyphar 8y agoThere is a lot of evidence that second-hand smoking is harmful. [1] is a summary on this topic from 2006 and cites 194 papers. To describe the science on second-hand smoking to be anything other than solid is to simply lie about our knowledge on the health effects of smoking. To add to this, there is also significant evidence that SIDS is strongly correlated with parents who are smokers (and thus appears to be likely caused by smoking while pregnant, and second-hand smoke during infancy). [1]: https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/books/NBK44330/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/books/NBK44330/
- cyphar 8y ago> it follows that any inadvertent inhalation of cigarette smoke is extremely dangerous, and that nicotine is the most deadly poison. Nicotine isn't what most people are worried about, and presenting it this way is simply disingenuous. Tobacco smoke contains many other components than nicotine such as cyanide, benzene, arsenic, as well as 50 other known carcinogens. Literally nobody cares about your nicotine addiction, it's all of the other toxic components that are the problem. The studies on second-hand smoking are very solid, and your calling them sketchy is very close to being an outright lie. Here is a summary of the many studies (dating back to the 80s) that all show the various impacts of second-hand smoking[1] -- it cites 194 papers. The WHO, CDC, American Cancer Society, American Lung Association, and many other groups (from other countries too) all concur that second-hand smoke is a very significant threat to the public's health. Second-hand smoke is very likely one of the causes of SIDS (Sudden Infant Death Syndrome) for fucks' sake. [1]: https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/books/NBK44330/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/books/NBK44330/