5 ms·
There is another angle to this story that the article misses. I think the "Lenin was a Mushroom" story was satire on the many Lenin stories that Soviet PR used
by weinzierl 8y ago
There is another angle to this story that the article misses. I think the "Lenin was a Mushroom" story was satire on the many Lenin stories that Soviet PR used to
paint him as a great guy. These stories, modern legends if you will, were sometimes so exaggerated that no one could possibly believe them - yet no one could say so publicly.
Here is one example[1]:
"One example, which all Russian people know by heart – Volodya Lenin was playing in the house and accidentally broke crystal graphene (crystal bottle for water or drinks). He was afraid that he would get punished, so he lied that he had nothing to do with this accident. But deep inside he was a good boy, so he felt bad about it. And several days later he told his relatives that it was him who broke the thing."
"Lenin was a Mushroom" was just taking this to an extreme and that's why people in early 90s USSR found it funny.
[1] https://understandrussia.com/lenin/ https://understandrussia.com/lenin/
- pavlov 8y agoIn American folklore, George Washington occupies this same "honest boy becomes national founder" niche.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- Mediterraneo10 8y agoThe "Lenin was a great man even in childhood" legend that I heard involves him eating apples that his mother told him not to, and then later his conscience nags him for it. In any event, Lenin was subjected to the same mythologization as George Washington who supposedly cut down a cherry tree and confessed to it.[1] [1] https://www.mountvernon.org/library/digitalhistory/digital-encyclopedia/article/cherry-tree-myth/ https://www.mountvernon.org/library/digitalhistory/digital-e...
- weinzierl 8y agoI still think there is an important difference here that made the joke[1] work in the USSR. I believe it wouldn't have worked in the US the same way. In America, when children grow up, parents could have that talk with them about how George Washington really was a great guy and how much they appreciate if their children wouldn't cut down the cherry tree in the garden but also about how this story about George Washington is just that - a story. I wasn't there at the time, so this is just my take on it: I imagine in the USSR it could have been dangerous to talk to children like that and one way out was to exaggerate the stories until the child notices what's going on. Now daddy Sergei Kurekhin was doing that to the whole Soviet Union - and that's why they laughed about it. [1] I call it a joke and not a hoax, because I think hoax kind of misses the point. I wasn't there at the time but this is my opinion: I don't think anyone believed it, I think people didn't say so partly because they didn't want to destroy the joke and partly because this was still the USSR.
- dec0dedab0de 8y agoAnnecdotal Hear-say, but I have spoken to a few people who grew up under the Soviets. They all had stories of their parents being very explicit about what was happening and being told exactly what they could not say in public. Then again these are people who ended up in the US so maybe they were atypical.
- the_grue 8y agoNo, this is totally not how it was. People used to speak quite freely at home (aside from when Stalin was in power, and even then).
- Viliam1234 8y agoYou can't speak freely at home when your little children hear you, because there is a risk they will repeat your words in public, which can get you in trouble. It's probably also quite dangerous with teenagers around; they may get a wrong idea about appearing cool to their peers by saying something that can't be say, and then get reported on. First, you need to make sure your children understand the magnitude of danger from repeating what they heard at home. That requires some maturity and intelligence, but more importantly the idea that "there are important truths that you can get punished for saying in a wrong place" is itself one of those important truths that you can get punished for saying in a wrong place, so you either need to approach this very very carefully or take a risk and hope for the best.
- pessimizer 8y agoSounds like a "Lenin or Washington" game waiting to happen.
- poilcn 8y agoYou can find the same stories about Stalin coming from his "fans". How he recommended one person to attend to some baptist church to learn English. Or stories about North Korean leaders, what wise things they teach workers when they fail. There were attempts to replace Christian symbols with Communist symbols. Like they replaced Christian trinity with Communist trinity: Lenin, Marx, Engels, for example. So they had to make up lots of legends about Lenin to make him new Jesus. How he was smart and when he was in jail he wrote with some sort of juice that made his texts invisible for guards.
- richard_shelton 8y agoI think there definitely is some similarity between Kuryokhin and Zoshchenko. "Stories about Lenin" by M. Zoshchenko have some absurd/satire elements. And these elements were almost invisible for many Soviet citizens. They started to notice these moments in the text only after the dissolution of USSR.