5 ms·
> Ever used one of those fancy color palette generators? You know, the ones where you pick a starting color, tweak some options that probably include some music
by weinzierl 8y ago
> Ever used one of those fancy color palette generators? You know, the ones where you pick a starting color, tweak some options that probably include some musical jargon like "triad" or "major fourth", and are then bestowed the five perfect color swatches you should use to build your website?
> This calculated and scientific approach to picking the perfect color scheme is extremely seductive, but not very useful.
Just recently I wondered if there is any scientific basis behind these approaches.
I skimmed all research papers that I could find but not a single one of them provided serious data based support. All justification for these methods I found were historical, i. e. artists used color wheels and different methods of color selection on the wheels for a long time.
My conclusion so far is: There is no science what so ever behind these color palette generators.
I only spent about a day on this research and I'm not an expert, so if anyone has some pointers to serious research in that direction I'd be happy to know.
- sandworm101 8y agoGoogle how the human eye works. The rods and cones. Colour and harmony between colours is rooted in our biology. Your iphone screen looks very unnatural, unattractive, to a dog or a goose. They see very different colours than we. Our affinity to bright red is tied to how we used it to identify ripe fruit. Notifications, things they want you to click/grab/poke work best in red. You dont see many brown buttons on websites. We dont like touching brown the way we do red.
- yread 8y agoThat might be true but this article basically says you have to rely on your eyes. You might as well get the designer to do everything. We programmers should also publish articles like this: dont even bother with Excel formulas you need a programmer
- weinzierl 8y agoI didn't want to criticize. My argument was meant to support the thesis that the palette generators are useless. They are not only useless from the designers point of view stated in the article but also from a scientific view. > You might as well get the designer to do everything. We programmers should also publish articles like this: dont even bother with Excel formulas you need a programmer I couldn't agree more.
- davidivadavid 8y agoWhether you see it as having science behind it or not really depends on what problem you're considering. There are some interesting in-depth articles about how people build those palettes and ramps that you might find interesting: https://uxplanet.org/designing-systematic-colors-b5d2605b15c https://uxplanet.org/designing-systematic-colors-b5d2605b15c https://design.lyft.com/re-approaching-color-9e604ba22c88 https://design.lyft.com/re-approaching-color-9e604ba22c88
- weinzierl 8y agoThanks for the links, I skimmed the articles, they are very interesting and I will certainly read them later. They are not what I'm looking for, however. What I'm looking for are empiric, preferably cross-cultural, studies on color harmony. I'm interested in work similar to what has been done for Unique Hues and Focal Colors but for combinations of two or more colors and for the notion whether people find these combinations pleasing, neutral or displeasing. I wouldn't be surprised too much if we couldn't find universal pleasing combinations but I'm surprised that apparently no one has done these type of studies.
- chazzyluc 8y agoMay not be exactly what you want but you could look into the World Color Survey: http://www1.icsi.berkeley.edu/wcs/ http://www1.icsi.berkeley.edu/wcs/ https://youtu.be/gMqZR3pqMjg https://youtu.be/gMqZR3pqMjg
- guitarbill 8y agoI'm happy to give them the benefit of the doubt, and I think many colour pickers wanted to do the right thing. HSL or HSV was a step up from RGB, so it made sense to use it to derive other colours quickly. Because if you're an underpaid freelance developer, the primary colour is usually set by the client, but they usually son't have a full colour scheme. Using a colour wheel based tool gave good enough results fast. Not only are perceptual uniform models like CIE Lab*, and the derived CIELCh or CIEHLC mindbending to understand and code, but monitor colour gamuts sucked, and so it was overkill. So is it scientific? If what you wanted was an easy way to derive a number of colours, sort of. If you need them to "look good", well that's art, not science. So ultimately, IDK what answer you're looking for. Colour wheels have always just been a nice way to visualise hue.
- weinzierl 8y ago> If you need them to "look good", well that's art, not science. I'm not so much interested in "look good" but in "look pleasing or harmonious together" and I think that's a question science might have an answer to. It's no coincidence that the palette generators borrow musical jargon. In music the definitions of minor second and perfect octave are completely uncontroversial. That these two intervals have different musical qualities, we call them dissonance and consonance, is uncontroversial too. Sure, some cultures use dissonant intervals heavily in their music but they still recognize the different qualities. Most importantly there has been a ton of research in this field. Contrast this with the state of the art in color science: When it comes to color harmony there is not even a single universal definition of opposite or complementary. Look at the Wikipedia article about that topic [1]. It mixes up three completely separate topics: 1. Colors that when mixed together give a neutral hue 2. Colors that are opposite of each other on some wheel 3. Colors that supposedly have a certain effect, like contrast or harmony, when perceived next to each other Color wheels are a dime a dozen. There is no shortage of claims that this and that color go well together but there doesn't seem to be any serious research. I wonder if that is just my impression because it's not my field, or if maybe color science really is just not developed enough to tackle these kind of questions. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Complementary_colors https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Complementary_colors
- rriepe 8y agoI've made one so maybe I can help (http://strapless.io/ http://strapless.io/) It's only really scientific insofar as it's based on a model. We basically make a big cube with R,G,B on its sides instead of X,Y,Z. Different approaches will then "smush" that cube to try to better match how humans perceive colors. Those different smushes will usually have some scientific thinking behind them (mine is based on... historical justifications, good post here btw). Then we move around the cube to find colors. When I get a color, I try to match the luma too. Luma is itself a weird value, which tries to work through the relative perceptual brightness differences in colors. The relative perceptual brightness difference is, as far as I can tell, the thing that really makes a color look "wrong" in a color scheme. I didn't solve that with problem with Strapless, but instead relied on whomever figured out luma. I think if you looked into how luma works you'd find the current best scientific model for whether two colors "fit" together. I'd agree that color-generating isn't a science (definitely more of an art) but any good approach will have a bunch of underlying science and math.
- jacobolus 8y ago> Just recently I wondered if there is any scientific basis behind these approaches. No, not really. It’s mostly 17th–19th century pseudoscience, propagated by generations of uncritical art teachers. (Note: not all art teachers; some are amazing.) Complementary colors (which mix to neutral when you e.g. paint two sides of a top with them and spin it) are a thing though.
- pfranz 8y agoMost of those generators are showing you sets of colors that all compliment each other. When you're designing an interface you have different priorities, you need a more of a fill and accent colors, as well as other colors that give contextual clues (like confirmations or warnings). I think both concepts are useful, but this article is a way better approach.